4 ms·
City-owned Internet services offer cheaper and more transparent pricing
- grahamburger 9y agoArticle links to this site which also has a lot of relevant info: https://muninetworks.org https://muninetworks.org
- xrd 9y agoAnd from there, this map: https://muninetworks.org/communitymap https://muninetworks.org/communitymap
- Simulacra 9y agoI remember in North Atlanta a huge problem to competition was access to utility poles. Comcast and other entrenched monopolies preventing companies like Google access to those poles. Is this still an issue?
- dboreham 9y agoI'm guessing "it depends" on the locality but in general there's nothing magical about being an entity that can sling cable around the town on poles. There are already typically two providers doing so (besides the electricity utility) : phone and cable tv. If you want to you can start a company and do it too, if you live by their rules, man. Rules include things like using qualified people to attach stuff to poles, be insured appropriately, other kinds of "government over-regulation" stuff, and of course that there be space available on said poles. In our very small town there's a retail store that has their own fiber between two of their locations. I suspect they contracted its installation to one of the regional fiber maintenance and installation companies. That's probably how you'd do it too unless you like owning bucket lift trucks and being on-call to come out and repair fiber when someone drives into a pole. Now, in some cases the city has issued a "licence" to a provider to deliver some service city-wide (e.g. cable tv). That agreement might include some non-competition provisions, on the basis that said provider spent $$$ installing their system and is only willing to do that if they are guaranteed to not have competition. This might be viewed as "not allowing access to poles" even though it actually isn't.
- davycro 9y agoMost of the municipalities listed in this table are located in the Southeast Appalachia area. Does anyone know why community owned fiber is biased towards this part of America? https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/muni-broadband-prices.jpg https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/muni-...
- autokad 9y agomight have something to do with hydro electric dams and cheap electricity, so they can subsidize the costs (Just guessing)
- mlinksva 9y agoSeems ridiculous to me that the researchers chose to abide by telco website dubious terms of service restrictions, resulting in less complete research. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16152194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16152194 is discussion of the research this story is reporting on.
- yorby 9y agoCould the federal government "force" cities to offer fiber services? that might speed up the process... (they would offer grants based on city population density... lower density = more money (Build It, They will come!))
- delinka 9y agoAnd which federal entity will over see this? Considering it's a Communications service, perhaps a Federal Communications Commission? We have one. Have you seen what they've been up to? What's the likelihood this policy would ever be enacted under the current administration?
- yorby 9y agoMaybe we need a new federal entity... one that doesn't allow lobbying. Maybe it could be called: For The People.
- Pharylon 9y agoIn news that will shock only Americans, it turns out the government is better than the private sector at offering public utilities. :)
- vinay427 9y agoI'm not sure how you arrived at "only Americans." How many countries offer a public ISP as an option to all of their people?
- amiga-workbench 9y agoAmericans have a unique way of ignoring the failings of private enterprise.
- duckMuppet 9y agoIn news that will shock only Americans.. After regulations imposed by govt at all different levels (state, fed, municipal), it turns out the only ones capable of competing in such an environment are the ones who restricted and closed the market to competition in the first place.. ftfy
- scarface74 9y agoIt's not about regulation, providing internet service over cable is capital intensive and all the incumbent has to do is lower prices, drive the new entrant out of the market and raise prices again.