3 ms·
> 3.) During most of the Cold War there were two main actors with nuclear weapons. There are now at least 9. [1] If instability in the US breaks trust in the nu
by jcranmer 9y ago
> 3.) During most of the Cold War there were two main actors with nuclear weapons. There are now at least 9. [1] If instability in the US breaks trust in the nuclear umbrella I would expect that number to increase rapidly. Even the US/NK standoff is a multi-polar problem, something that seems to have escaped most US-based commentators.
The UK developed nuclear weapons in 1952, France in 1960, and China in 1964. At the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis (the height of the Cold War), there were 4 nuclear weapons states.
- nickelcitymario 9y agoI think the key word was "main actors". The UK, France, and China were not main actors in the Cold War, unless I'm terribly mistaken.
- jcranmer 9y agoIf the UK, France, and China were not main actors in the Cold War, then why are they, along with Israel, Pakistan, India, and North Korea, main actors in the modern world? The UK and France haven't exactly been getting more important in the past 50 years in global affairs.
- hodgesrm 9y agoThe other arsenals were pretty small and the confrontations that I'm aware of were between the US and USSR. The Soviet response to Able Archer was triggered in part by paranoia about US Pershing II missile deployments, which were in progress around that time. NATO nuclear policy was almost entirely a US game as far as I know.
- jcranmer 9y agoI'm arguing less against the fact that the US and USSR drove the nuclear MAD in the Cold War than the fact that you cite the number of important nuclear powers as going from 2 to 9. In terms of modern countries, the US and Russia are the only countries with significant stockpiles. UK and France have reduced their stockpiles from the Cold War (so if they were insignificant then, they're even more so now). The other 5 countries have increased or maintained stockpiles, but only China reaches British/French levels. India, Pakistan, and Israel have even fewer and are only sufficient to effect war on a small scale against specific rivals. North Korea's nukes are incapable of doing anything more than seriously pissing off the entire world (arguably, their ability to shell Seoul is more effective deterrent than their nukes).
- gaius 9y agoThe UK developed nuclear weapons in 1952, France in 1960 The US, UK and France would collectively be considered “the West” or NATO, just as nuclear weapons inherited by Ukraine when the USSR collapsed would have been considered at the time as collectively part of the USSR.