4 ms·
I'd imagine it's solvable by just about everything. This is one of those cases where the core problem isn't that the problem is hard, it is that it is so easy t
by jerf 9y ago
I'd imagine it's solvable by just about everything. This is one of those cases where the core problem isn't that the problem is hard, it is that it is so easy that it is a challenge to get humans to even perceive it as a problem on such a small scale. Any planning system will hit something like this all but immediately.
I'd say a lot of the earliest AI optimism was a failure to understand just how hard things that in the simplest case are so simple we don't even perceive them as problems in the first place. For a much more complicated example, I doubt anyone in 1970 would imagine that in 2018 we're still trying to get robots to walk from here to there. (Yes, lots of progress has been made, but it's still very much cutting edge, a research project, and a bespoke one-off effort each time, not a "Oh, I'll just swing on down to the robot store and pick up a walking chassis".) We don't see it as a challenge because for our conscious minds, by the time we're old enough to be doing robotics research, it's zero cognitive effort for us.
- FabHK 9y agoMoravec's paradox - stuff we thought is hard (chess, derivatives) is easy, while stuff we think is easy (face recognition, getting out of a car, opening a door) is really hard. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox One of my favourite videos is this compilation of robots falling (failing) during the simplest tasks at the 2015 DARPA challenge: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0TaYhjpOfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0TaYhjpOfo
- lloeki 9y agoTo be fair, it takes us humans a solid couple of years of continuous training to make sense of our sensory inputs and get accustomed to our limbs enough to begin doing anything significant with them, so I am regularly flabbergasted at the expectations we place in our lowly contraptions to outdo us by two to three orders of magnitude.
- bsaul 9y agoAnd yet humans need even more years to correctly play chess.
- Frqy3 9y agoHumans have had millions of years of system level optimisation (evolution) which then only needs a couple of additional years to train the wetware to operate the system for daily activity. Chess has only been around a mere 1,500 years and has had an evolutionary impact on only a very minute portion of the population. Hence it takes a few additional years to specialise a human for optimal chess performance.
- Simon_says 9y agoOptimal chess performance is not remotely achievable by humans.