5 ms·
Hawaii missile false alarm due to badly designed user interface, reports say
- rovek 9y agoThis will be an incredibly useful, accessible case study the next time I need to push back on "can we add a confirmation popup?" with corporate bods.
- atoko 9y agoThe answer here is to make the action easily reversible if possible.
- dentemple 9y agoor at least allow a second-round of vetting for the "Everybody Panic!" option
- lemoncucumber 9y agoBrings to mind this old but good article from A List Apart: https://alistapart.com/article/neveruseawarning https://alistapart.com/article/neveruseawarning (Not to suggest that could or should be the solution in this particular case — obviously undo doesn’t seem like the right fit once the alert has gone out).
- gooseus 9y ago> “Even though the menu option still required confirmation that the user really wanted to send an alert, that wasn’t enough, on this occasion, to prevent the worker from robotically clicking onwards.” > “It was too easy — for anyone — to make such a big mistake,” Rapoza told the Post. Is the "ballistic missile alert technician" role filled by freaking interns or something? HEMA is a part of the DoD, so is this not a military role of some sort where discipline is impressed upon people? > HEMA has also added a requirement for a second person to confirm the message to be sent, hopefully preventing the first from simply clicking through mistakenly. But don't worry, we'll just double the humans required (and likely, the cost) since you can't actually trust one human to read confirmation boxes when they're dealing with a first-line defense system that impacts millions of people.
- waldfee 9y agoId say such critical actions always warrant confirmation by a second pair of eyes
- carlmr 9y agoWhy don't we just redesign the system with good UX? I want to send a copy of "The Design of Everyday Things" to the Hawaiian government now.
- gooseus 9y agoCertainly UX can always be improved, but doing so without proper training and making the operator ultimately responsible for their actions is just ridiculous. Sure the buttons could have been named something different, but with a confirmation box, this UX passes what should be considered reasonable to prevent a literate and aware individual (the only type that should be approved for this position) from making a mistake like this. I'm really astonished at the need to defend my position on this... it's almost like everyone replying here is thinking that they, too, would treat a legitimate missile defense drill (in the era of saber-rattling between Trump and Kim) the same way they treat installing a software EULA or an update to their FB ToS.
- pheldagryph 9y agoYou're staking out some pretty tough ground, there. Human error can be unconscious or reflexive, and that type of UI element is sometimes barely a speedbump, cognitively. Occasionally I reflexively click-through a confirmation dialogue box and regret it. I feel like I've been trained by the software industry for decades to bludgeon my way through these confirmations, many of which are unnecessary to begin with. I basically have muscle memory for it, the skids are greased for clicking-through. I know I'm not the only one. So, I could see myself making this type of slip. It's really hard to know the balance between human and system error for this incident, but to me it looks like the system naively assumes a perfect human. Even if the incident turns out to have been an intentionally malicious act, the problem with the system would still remain.
- oftenwrong 9y ago>On Saturday, sending that second “false alarm” alert required extraordinary permission, delaying it for 38 minutes. It was easy to unintentionally send a false alarm, but difficult to intentionally send a correction. Not a great system...
- CodeWriter23 9y agoSorry, I’m not buying it. It takes supervisor approval to void a duplicate scan of a $3 item at Trader Joe’s. No way in hell does an emergency alert system allow just anyone sitting at the computer to send one just because they want to.
- skellera 9y agoIn the event of an emergency, do you really want it to come down to asking a supervisor? It’s literally a worse case scenario and you can’t expect multiple people to be there. The off chance that trying to get supervisor approval taking 10+ mins means that no one gets notified in time. I got the message. I’m mad it was sent out but it’s better they learn these problems now rather than during an emergency. I don’t think having another person approve it would be a better situation. Just make the interface more clear or even add a buffer of 5 seconds to cancel the alert before it even gets sent.