11 ms·
Why Hasn’t the World Been Destroyed in a Nuclear War Yet?
- python-guy-vt 9y agoVery simple: Mutually assured destruction
- zimbatm 9y agoNot that simple, there are multiple historically recorded close calls. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls
- python-guy-vt 9y agoHow does this negate mutually assured destruction? If anything it enforces the idea that this is why we have only had close calls. No one wants to be responsible for starting the demise of (at the very least) two countries.
- snarf21 9y agoOr everyone just prefers a nice game of chess. :)
- fredley 9y agoSurvivor Bias. If it had we wouldn't be writing about it.
- KajMagnus 9y agoYes maybe there are lots of other Earth like planets in our galaxy? universe?, where human like intelligent species aren't wondering and talking about why-not any longer.
- ryanjodonnell 9y agoIn the game series "Mass Effect" there is a race called the Krogans which destroy themselves in nuclear war at about 1950s era technology levels, leaving their world completely destroyed and in nuclear winter. When you come across them in the game it's been many generations since that event and they still havent recovered and only get into space because other aliens come by and "lift them up". Would not be surprised if this is the fate of humanity as well
- ryanjodonnell 9y agoFrom the wiki: "Unfortunately, as krogan society became more technologically advanced, so did their weaponry. The end result is that they destroyed their homeworld in a nuclear war ... The krogan were reduced to primitive warring clans struggling to survive a nuclear winter of their own creation, a state that continued until they were discovered by the salarians two thousand years later."
- cantrip 9y agoIn order for survivor bias to apply here we need other worlds which were destroyed to compare ours to.
- mattbierner 9y agoThe fallacy still applies, we just don’t have enough data to know how lucky we really were. The question itself is biased to our present point of reference because if the world had been destroyed, no one would ask it
- cantrip 9y agoI think you're confusing survivorship bias with hindsight bias. If you're not then it's difficult to argue with this, that's simply not the definition of survivorship bias.
- lostcolony 9y agoI'm not sure if some of these commentors realize that the article is all about answering the question; this is isn't an "Ask HN" thread.
- pwython 9y agoConsidering the closest the "article" comes to answering the question is in its last 2 sentences, it's not "the end of the world" to have a discussion.
- darepublic 9y agoThere are multiple parallel universes, some of which have experienced nuclear war and some which have not
- zyxzevn 9y agoWhich one is Fallout?
- KajMagnus 9y agoYou mean that planet Earth exists in many universes in parallel? (Rather than that there are many different planets, in different universes? but not "copies" of Earth) Maybe there are also many parallel Earth like planets in this particular universe, with human like creatures. Some of which have, some have not.
- cs1717p 9y agoThis. Surprisingly enough, a human is much more likely to find oneself alive in a world in which humanity was not nearly made extinct by nuclear war. Exponentially so, if we assume, reasonably, that even if humans survived (technically) a nuclear war, their descendants would take 100s of thousands of years or longer to recover to pre apocalypse levels, vs. non nuclear war realities where the population simply keeps increasing exponentially, leading exponentially many more humans to find themselves existing in that "timeline."
- darepublic 9y agoThis also explains why, despite my suicidal driving, I am miraculously alive.
- QAPereo 9y agoThis is possible, but probably represents a drastic misunderstanding of MWI/QM. I’d you’re thinking I. Terms of branches from quantum superpositions, then it would be a certainty, but a certainty among u counted multitudes. If you’re thinking Quantum Suicide... just no. Nuclear war does not fulfill the requirements of that gedanken.
- jonathanstrange 9y agoCoincidence, mostly, and perhaps a certain reluctance of people to nuclear armageddon.
- arethuza 9y agoIf you want to be scared silly I can recommend "One Minute to Midnight" by Michael Dobbs - it goes through the Cuban Missile crisis minute by minute with a lot of detail. The number of things that went wrong that almost led to war are remarkable - e.g. who would have thought that the Northern Lights could have helped start a nuclear war.... It also covers the story of the submarine fleet that Vasili Arkhipov was on and why they were a bit tetchy when the US Navy started annoying them.
- zyxzevn 9y agoThe false alarms did not cause any actions, because people were not doing their job like machines, but as humans who care about lives. We should honour those people, even when it is against military codes. I would like to expand it even to non-nuclear warfare. People that stop destruction or give us insights in our destructive policies. This includes whistleblowers and press that report human rights violations, ecological destruction, and are currently punished for it. This happens in the US too.
- dullgiulio 9y agoLuckily one day these pesky humans with their own will and intelligence will be removed by Smart Contract that cannot be reverted or appealed. Hurray. :(
- icc97 9y agoWe should honour these people but we cannot rely on that there will always be a human that decides to go against protocol. It's going to go wrong eventually.
- escapologybb 9y agoLuck and Stanislav Petrov, amongst other reasons. Which is utterly terrifying. I still find it amazing that Stanislav Petrov was fired from his job a few days after averting nuclear Armageddon, I think he was chiefly because he didn't follow protocol. Even though his actions prevented Thermonuclear war. I also don't imagine there was much of a Unfair Dismissals Tribunal type arrangement for nuclear weapons officers in the USSR. ETA: DragonDictate can't spell thermonuclear
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 9y ago> I still find it amazing that Stanislav Petrov was fired from his job... If he were promoted he might have spoken about the faulty system to the wrong pointy haired boss. This is speculation, but Russian Christians have a strong sense of sacrifice, and sacrificing your career for saving the world may seem appropriate somehow.
- rdtsc 9y ago> One particularly ominous example of this nuclear deployment was the Soviets’ “Dead Hand” system, which has only come to light since the end of the Cold War. [...] Almost unbelievably, the Soviet leadership failed to notify the West that it had built this seemingly impregnable nuclear deterrent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Hand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Hand One of the main reasons (besides the obvious one) for having this system was to protect against hotheaded generals at the top. The reasoning is this - if they know they have the capability of a retaliatory strike, they don't have to rush to press the button, knowing they will still have the ability to retaliate. That could explain probably why they never bothered to publicly announce it to the West. Or maybe they assumed the West would find out about it through its spy network anyway...
- 3pt14159 9y agoI talk about WMDs / submarine communications with arms control people for fun sometimes. Well the game theory gets weird with dead hands. Of course you want to deter, but you need to keep the deterrence partially shrouded because you do not want your adversary to know for certain that they've completely designed around you. You want them to have known unknowns (ie, they know that they don't fully know how you're going to respond, but they know the outcome if you are successful). I have an unorthodox opinion about nuclear weapons. I think that we might see one or two be used in the not too distant future if things get super hot with weaponized robotics. Most people assume that all countries are going to push for complete launch or not, but there are situations where I think they could be used. For example a large attack by India towards Pakistan could be met with a small nuclear response on a relatively unpopulated area.
- delibes 9y ago> For example a large attack by India towards Pakistan That's 8th on the list in the movie Wargames :) https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/24ujzq/for_fans_of_the_movie_wargames_a_list_of_all_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/24ujzq/for_fans_of_...
- jdavis703 9y agoIsn't that like a turkey asking why they haven't been slaughtered yet? Then the day before Thanksgiving comes and times up. That's one of the reasons the U.S. needs to adopt a "no first use" policy. If our adversaries don't have to worry about the U.S. launching another first strike, then the risk of a miscalculation goes down.
- delibes 9y agoIs it that easy? If the USA declares 'no first use' do I believe it? How much more than UK, Russia, China, ... Israel, Pakistan, North Korea? In fact, only America has ever actually used a nuclear bomb in a real war. On the balancing side, they've had a series of de-escalating disarmament treaties with the former USSR, so could be argued to be heading in the more peaceful direction than counties further down my list. In the game Civilization I know that Gandhi will always, left to his own devices, eventually nuke me, because of a historical in-game joke. The real world is a lot less predictable.
- BerislavLopac 9y agoThank you for this tidbit, I had no idea: https://kotaku.com/why-gandhi-is-such-an-asshole-in-civilization-1653818245 https://kotaku.com/why-gandhi-is-such-an-asshole-in-civiliza...
- nickelcitymario 9y agoThis is the most interesting thing I've read all day.
- kstenerud 9y agoHe was an asshole in real life as well. http://www.thecrimson.com/article/1983/3/7/the-truth-about-gandhi-pbtbhe-movie/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/1983/3/7/the-truth-about-g... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/09/03/what-did-mahatma-gandhi-think-of-black-people/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/09/03...
- deleted 9y ago
- icc97 9y agoErr this article didn't seem to give me any faith whatsoever. It's basically luck so far. The article seems to suggest that somehow the equilibrium is stronger than we think. But I see no reason for that to hold indefinitely. If that's all we've got a bad run of luck is coming. So it purely becomes a question of when. 50 years? 100 years? 1000 years? Let's hope Mars is self sustaining before this happens.
- ulises314 9y ago"Cause non of them can stop the time"
- phkahler 9y agoMaybe it was destroyed in another part of the multiverse and we're just the ones left to ponder this question. hahahaha, no. That line of thinking can lead to the idea that every big decision can be made by flipping a quantum coin and the result will be right in some universe.
- shagie 9y agoGive All The Myriad Ways by Larry Niven a read - https://archive.org/stream/Galaxy_v27n03_1968-10#page/n31/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/Galaxy_v27n03_1968-10#page/n31/mo... . Its not a world (or multiworlds) I would want to live in.
- raquo 9y agoPlease, give randomness some time to act out. I hope no one thinks that we have 100.00000% reliable processes to avoid a nuclear war, taking both positive and negative human factors into account. Eventually the current setup will fail us if we don't develop into a more civilized society where pointing armed nukes at each other is not needed.
- meri_dian 9y agoIt's interesting to think about this question by asking a similar question. If you live in a house full of people, why hasn't anyone killed anyone else yet? It's a gruesome question, but the point is that even though people living together will certainly have arguments, someone who is sane will never seriously consider killing someone else. Ultimately nations usually act as if they are scaled up people, which makes sense because they are run by people. Full scale nuclear war represents the probability of complete and total annihilation for all parties involved. At this scale of destruction, war becomes an existential crisis for nations themselves, which is intolerable to a nation itself - no longer just a nation's citizens - which, from a nation's perspective, are expendable. This may seem callous, but we need to recognize that organisms of different scales have different sets of concerns and priorities from one another. Just as we often don't think twice about doing something that would cause cells in our bodies to die, like binge drinking on the weekend - which from our cells' perspective would amount to a holocaust - nations have historically not thought twice about going to war when such war represented a minimal existential threat, even if a few thousand soldiers would have to die. Nuclear war represents total destruction of nations in a way that traditional modes of warfare fought, say, between 17th century European powers did not, as this earlier warfare - while bloody and terrible for the individual soldier - would usually at worst (from a national perspective) lead to the loss of a few territories, which is tolerable.
- lostcolony 9y agoThat's a fine analogy...except for all the murders committed by family members in houses. It happens sufficiently frequently that there's the well known (and possibly apocryphal) idea that police always treat a spouse as a primary suspect. So, while I'm willing to bet my wife isn't murderous (I don't -know-, but I'll assume so)...do I really want to assume a -stranger- isn't, knowing that there are murderous people out there, and that if I'm wrong my entire family will die? I mean, you say "someone who is sane will never seriously consider killing someone else" - great, how possible is it for an insane person to end up heading a nuclear armed country? I mean, I don't think I want to trust 192 (or whatever our country count is at) random strangers to all be sane.
- 1_2__4 9y ago
- hodgesrm 9y agoThe conclusion of this article is almost breathtakingly naive. I was assigned to HQ US Air Forces Europe during the Able Archer exercise in November 1983, which triggered mobilization of Soviet nuclear forces. I've been thinking about that experience for most of my life. Here are a few points from long reflection. 1.) Any system that continuously depends on single individuals to make the right decision to avoid catastrophe is defective by design. In the Able Archer case our boss Leonard Perroots made an instinctive decision to stand down that prevented the escalation from going further. [0] 2.) The US and Russia had disciplined command and control systems plus relatively stable political leadership. That won't always be the case; in the case of the US it's arguably not the case now. 3.) During most of the Cold War there were two main actors with nuclear weapons. There are now at least 9. [1] If instability in the US breaks trust in the nuclear umbrella I would expect that number to increase rapidly. Even the US/NK standoff is a multi-polar problem, something that seems to have escaped most US-based commentators. To sum up the reason we have not seen use of weapons to-date is we've been incredibly lucky. Given the known miscalculations in the incidents to date that's unlikely to last. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/10/us/leonard-perroots-dead.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/10/us/leonard-perroots-dead.... [1] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/politics/the-nine-countries-that-have-nuclear-weapons-a6798756.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/politics/the-nine-co...
- jacquesm 9y ago> To sum up the reason we have not seen use of weapons to-date is we've been incredibly lucky. That, imo is the only correct conclusion. Anybody that wants to sell mutually assured destruction as a long term solution is missing the point that in the long term your luck will some day run out. That, besides obvious de-railings of the principle due to a lack of mental stability in leadership.
- asdfologist 9y agoI don't understand your point #2. Our president has reassured us that he is a stable genius.
- trumpsamerica 9y agoDo you have any arguments about 2 except the hair color and surname? Also try not to give me things that cnn has told you you should be outraged about
- thansz 9y agoThis is a very interesting topic to me, so much so I wrote a small sci-fi novella called Assiyah Rising that addresses this very topic. It's set in the modern day, but it contains historical flashbacks to Vasili Arkhipov and Stanislav Petrov, two men who prevented large scale nuclear wars. Disturbingly, those were just two instances in a long list of near nuclear disasters that happened during the short period of time we have had nuclear weapons. If anyone is interested, you can get the book on Amazon for a buck or you can download for free on Smashwords. It should be a quick and easy read. https://www.amazon.com/Assiyah-Rising-Part-T-H-Ansz-ebook/dp/B0737ZTBPJ https://www.amazon.com/Assiyah-Rising-Part-T-H-Ansz-ebook/dp... https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/759765 https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/759765
- jlebrech 9y ago"the world" a euphemism for humanity. the world would last a lot long after a nuclear war than with continued human abuse.
- wizardforhire 9y agoThere isn't a simple answer. The history of nuclear weapons is littered with near misses. The number is staggering! If I am to infer a reason for the lack of our destruction I can think of three things that seem invariant from history. 1) we've been really lucky 2) we've been lucky because nuclear weapons are extremely difficult to detonate 3) it would seem that the raw power of nuclear weapons paradoxically has a sobering effect on those who wield them. In that no one who has them seems to actually want to use them this especially goes for those in the command chain responsible for firing them. Not to say at times there haven't been people who would or want to use them, just that nobody yet has.
- fullshark 9y agoWell this was an unpleasant read with an unsatisfying conclusion
- mtgx 9y agoWe're getting there: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/09/us-to-loosen-nuclear-weapons-policy-and-develop-more-usable-warheads https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/09/us-to-loosen...
- MollyR 9y agoOne of my big concerns about the future is nuclear war being triggered by a new plague. My concern is that an huge population allow for "parallel processing" for pathogenic evolution to find weak vectors in humans, and this will be mistaken as a nation-state attack leading to a nuclear war.
- matte_black 9y agoWhat is the safest place to live to survive a nuclear war?
- mrgleeco 9y agorelated & timely: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/01/18/daniel-ellsberg-nuclear-worrier/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/01/18/daniel-ellsberg-n...