5 ms·
Hopefully it would work out better than in Munich.
by dogma1138 9y ago
Hopefully it would work out better than in Munich.
- skc 9y agoI'm sure it's quite a lot more feasible now than it was when Munich embarked on their adventure. And one would also hope they have used Munich as a good case study.
- lunchladydoris 9y agoContext [0], for anyone interested. [0]: https://www.techrepublic.com/article/end-of-an-open-source-era-linux-pioneer-munich-confirms-switch-to-windows-10/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/end-of-an-open-source-e...
- kartan 9y agoThanks for the link. "Those supporting the move to Microsoft Office say staff using LibreOffice find it difficult to swap documents with external organizations, due to incompatibilities with Microsoft Office" This happens all around the industry. Once you are locked in there is no easy way to change. This renders the capitalist concept of competition obsolete. Everything becomes a monopoly. Intel, Nvidia, Facebook, Microsoft, Google... they amount of 90% of the market on their products. What was 20 years ago a dynamic fast changing industry, that feared anti-monopoly actions from the goverment, has become a short list of big companies with tight ties with politicians. Such lack of diversity opens the risk that a vulnerability is going to send all our IT into chaos, as Intel issues have showed up. It also hampers innovation and contributes to a world with less opportunities for new entrepreneurs, that are more focused in created something to sell to a big company than a long term viable business. So Munich decision is part of the problem, but just an small one. I hope that it works better for Barcelona.
- cies 9y agoI thought Munnich's decision was also in part because MSFT would consider Munnich as a location for an office based on their decision on using their product to do their work. The old "we have to serve the corps (and their owners) or they leave" argument.
- a254613e 9y agoMicrosoft decided to move their HQ to Munich years before this. In fact the year the construction of MS HQ started Munich voted to start planning the move to LiMux.
- deknos 9y agoah, so.. why then did the new mayor the last year have the need to meet with microsoft and prepare the move? Do you have data for your claim?
- a254613e 9y agoSure - one of many articles from 2013 announcing the move: http://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/neue-deutschland-zentrale-microsoft-zieht-nach-muenchen-1.1813100 http://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/neue-deutschland-zentral...
- yorwba 9y agoHN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13625508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13625508 mschuster91's first-hand experience: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13627452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13627452 Also, I read the underlying consultancy report, which did not appear to support the specific approach that was chosen: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13643182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13643182
- EspadaV9 9y agoMunich was pretty good. It's been deployed for 4+ years and won't be replaced until the end of 2020 (assuming everything goes to plan) so that will be at least 7 years of use. It seems that the reasons to move back to Windows weren't completely technical either.
- criddell 9y agoIt's hard to come up with technical reasons for picking one OS over another for general business use. All of the operating systems are good enough. They have been for a long time. What drives OS choice is (and always has been) application support and cost. Despite Linux being free, it can be expensive to support or even an impossible choice if you need, for example, Microsoft Office or Final Cut. More often than not, Linux wins on ideological grounds. There's nothing wrong with that, but you do need buy-in from your users.
- wastedhours 9y agoYou need to start in education - MS has had that locked down for decades. It'll be really interesting to see whether ChromeOS will have any impact in the future when an entire generation has been using it daily for schoolwork.
- leadingthenet 9y agoThat's only true in the US. Practically nobody in the EU has heard of / uses ChromeOS. Or maybe I'm just out of touch.
- saiya-jin 9y agonah, same here (IT person). it's that 'another' option when you actually are deciding between different 2, if deciding at all. and google's privacy approach has soured their portfolio for me a bit (albeit some of them are exceptionally well done and useful)
- pirocks 9y ago
- squarefoot 9y agoBe prepared to a subtle PR war from proprietary solutions vendors, not blatantly directed at software (eg. not like giving 10000 free copies of Windows + Office + this and that) but indirectly helping the city to gain public acceptance, say funding schools, hospitals, public infrastructures etc. then offering at the same time the option to local politicians to get their face associated with the events. What politician would refuse the opportunity to address a speech during the inauguration of say a new library/hospital/mall/police station/parking lot etc. built with money that did not came from taxing people? That would make a hell of an argument during election time, so you can consider him technically sold to whoever the money comes from, even though he didn't get a single dime in the process, which of course will mean that once he is in power he will use whatever software solution the founder is "suggesting" to keep his seat.
- cies 9y agoCame here to say this. It is hard to fight the lobby power of big corps. Though Spain has the case of Extremadura. I could not find a better article, I remember reading some that outlined then massive success that was achieved in Extremadura (one of the poorer regions of Spain). https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/2265108/spains-extremadura-government-switches-40-000-pcs-to-linux-and-open-source-software https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/2265108/spains-ext...
- icc97 9y agoIt actually gives strength to what Munich did. They proved that it was possible to swap. So Barcelona doesn't have such a political tricky situation as there is a pre-existing example. Let's hope that more follow Barcelona. Barcelona is possibly taking an easier approach. That is, replace the easier things like Office and IE. I've done similar things. So where as my software has to use IIS and Windows servers, I use Firefox, Thunderbird and Libre Office for everything with the odd exception. It means for me having a dual boot machine is fairly easy as all software usage is the same. You occasionally do have compatibility issues with Office but it doesn't have to. The more using it the better.
- luma 9y agoI'm not sure how Munich "proved it was possible". The user community disliked it so much they are now switching back. They proved that it cost the city a lot of money in the transition (both times), and those costs have nothing to do with licensing. "Free" is only "free" so long as you and your user's time carries no value.
- icc97 9y agoThey switched over for 7 years, they got the initial political support required to switch over, they created their own distribution. So I regard that as having shown that it is possible to switch. This is purely showing that getting over the first hurdle is possible. They then showed what to what lengths MS will go to lobby against it, so Barcelona can be better prepared for the next hurdle. These are all fairly massive achievements.
- deknos 9y agonot the users. the mayor and city council.
- snvzz 9y agoThere's the Munich experience and the Extremadura experience, so there's mistakes Barcelona can avoid. I hear they're using a popular distribution (Ubuntu) rather than trying to make and maintain a forked one. This is a very clever choice that will save a tremendous amount of pain.