5 ms·
Why Uber Can Find You but 911 Can’t
- leeoniya 9y agopaywall, so cannot read. i assume it's because you volunteer your location to uber, whereas you don't to gov't (and something about warrant-less surveillance/wiretapping laws). there should be an easy way built into Android/iOS to transmit your location during a phone call to the other end. it would not just solve the 911 use case but a lot of other non-emergency uses. EDIT: i'm also very interested why this comment is garnering downvotes.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> i'm also very interested why this comment is garnering downvotes. Your comment about the paywall is explicitly off-topic, and then you've commented without reading the article. And now you're posting about being downvoted, which is likely to attract further downvotes.
- rabidonrails 9y ago>>Your comment about the paywall is explicitly off-topic That seems harsh. If there's a paywalled article posted then it's fair of him to say that he can't access it because it's paywalled. If you have an issue with that then you should have (an issue with the HN rules and whether they should or) shouldn't allow paywalled sites/articles to be posted.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoI think it is a bit harsh. Most of the initial commenters couldn't read the article due to paywall, that seems very on-topic. http://archive.is/l5uLn http://archive.is/l5uLn works well to paywall-bypass. > If you have an issue with that then you should have HN shouldn't allow paywalled sites/articles to be posted. I'm a bit torn about that. These are good articles, they should be posted/discussed. You could link to things like the paywall bypass link I sent instead, but, there are infinite variations of those so you could end up with infinite threads about the same article which seems like a poor solution.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rabidonrails 9y agoI'm not sure you read my comment...we are saying the same thing.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoI was trying to agree with you :)
- chrisseaton 9y ago> That seems harsh. I'm not giving my opinion on it - I'm telling they why they've been down voted, and this is it. > If there's a paywalled article posted then it's fair of him to say that he can't access it because it's paywalled. But the HN rules say that it isn't ok for them to post a comment saying that. > If you have an issue with that then you should have HN shouldn't allow paywalled sites/articles to be posted. No the HN rules say it's ok to post paywalled articles. They then also say it's not ok to post comments complaining about it. I think you're confusing that I'm telling you my personal opinion. I'm not - I'm quoting the HN rules.
- 35bge57dtjku 9y agoHow is what you're saying any more on topic (the original topic)?
- chrisseaton 9y agoLook I haven't downvoted them! They asked why they may have been downvoted, and I'm explaining why people may have done that so they know how the site works. We're not supposed to comment about comment voting at all, but if nobody explained that nobody would know!
- chrisseaton 9y ago> (this comment was a reponse to the initial comment by chrisseaton which has since been removed.) I haven't removed any comment at all. The quote you're replying to is still in my comment. And I can't have edited after you posted that comment, because HN doesn't apply comments that have been replied to to be edited.
- rabidonrails 9y agomy fault, un-edited.
- Stratoscope 9y ago> I can't have edited after you posted that comment, because HN doesn't apply [allow?] comments that have been replied to to be edited. Is that true? I'm pretty sure I have edited comments after they have been replied to, as long as it was within the two-hour edit window. But I could be remembering wrong. Want to try editing your comment now that it has one or more replies and see what happens? Edit: Testing an edit after this comment has been replied to. Indeed it can be edited.
- chrisseaton 9y agoWell whatever I don't edit my comments after they've been replied to. And it wouldn't make sense to have edited because I've repeated the same information several times in replies to my replies.
- Stratoscope 9y agoI wasn't suggesting that you should edit your comments (except for that one as a test). :-) Your note about HN not allowing edits got me wondering, so I was curious to verify it one way or another. Since you replied to my previous comment, I did a test edit on it and indeed editing was allowed. Mystery solved!
- chrisseaton 9y agoMaybe I was thinking of the rules for deletion.
- deadmetheny 9y agoPeople are going to complain about paywalls as long as people keep linking to articles with paywalls, and no amount of rules is going to stop that. Either that needs to be accepted or HN needs to stop allowing paywalled articles to hit the main page.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoI posted an archive.is link that you can use to read it. I only skimmed the article, but, a lot of this sounds like signaling issues. > transmit your location during a phone call Transmit how? Send an SMS to 911? Some kind of HTTP/API call? Some kind of encoded audio signal?
- mindcrime 9y agoProbably using the SS7[1] network. This is mainly how "out of band" signalling is done on telecom networks. The problem is, there are already notorious security issues[2] with SS7 and exposing any more functionality "up the stack" might be deemed to risky. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_System_No._7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_System_No._7 [2]: https://www.wired.com/2017/05/fix-ss7-two-factor-authentication-bank-accounts/ https://www.wired.com/2017/05/fix-ss7-two-factor-authenticat...
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoExtending SS7 to your phone seems... complex. The more I think about it, having your phone send an SMS to 911 with your location as soon as you dial 911 seems really simple. SMS to 911, where supported, must already be special-cased. Carriers can each deal with that and communicate that back to the 911 call center in their own way (obviously negotiated with the 911 agencies) and phone manufacturers need only do a single (simple) thing. There would be a lot of flexibility there too. Your phone could choose to update the location as it changed (moving vehicle) or as precision increased.
- ratboy666 9y agoSince I wrote the software for a 911 CAD (computer aided dispatch) used by a primary PSAP (public safety access point) -- yes. But... The 911 operator has to initiate the SMS exchange. Kind of strange. I believe that, in certain jurisdictions, TDD service for the deaf was a revenue stream for the incumbent telcom carrier. So, cell phones are specified to have to be "registered" to allow 911 SMS (this is just my speculation). The 911 operator has to initiate the exchange (in the areas that the system I work on is used). Incoming 911 data already contains location data (from tower triangulation, etc.). More interesting is that the 911 operator must manually request location updates (secondary reports) and that these cannot be requested more frequently than 35 seconds apart (again, these regulations apply in my area). Again, stinking regulations. Anyway, the data available (formats) are documented by NENA (National Emergency Number Association). www.nena.org. But... carriers (Bell, Telus here) use supersets of those formats. The problem is not flexibility -- the systems are in place, and must inter-operate. IP networking for these systems is not completely in place (some use serial communications). The cut-over to IP networking is still on-going, and some places use parallel serial and IP networking. And, of course, 911 operators get ANI/ALI (automatic number identification, automatic location identification) data for home phones (ALI by database, usually), and the mobile needs to be incorporated in such a way as not to confuse the dispatch operators.
- pje 9y ago"Hey folks, didn't read the article! But here are some of my assumptions that the headline reminded me of. Also here's this sweeping thing I think both major mobile platforms should implement for some reason. Now to send the comment and rack up those upvotes!"
- cryptoz 9y agoAlso unable to read the article no matter what tricks I use, but I'll add this nugget of info for E911 requirements. I believe we are coming up on the deadline years for when telcos must incorporate barometric measurements from barometer-carrying phones into altitude calculations so that 911 emergency response can get an altitude clue from the moment you ring. Edit: PDF source https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-15-9A1.pdf https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-15-9A1.pdf And edit: This is a tricky situation, because the barometer does not provide real altitude data, and if the math is done incorrectly or there is some interference, the 911 response could be sent to the wrong altitude. Perhaps there are delays with that because extracting the correct altitude from the data is extremely difficult to do with only a single phone to use a source.
- chipperyman573 9y agohttps://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-uber-can-find-you-but-911-cant-1515326400 https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https://www.wsj.com/articles/... will let you read it :)
- cryptoz 9y agoGood trick, thanks! Reading now. Super interesting.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agohttp://archive.is/l5uLn http://archive.is/l5uLn
- withdavidli 9y agoJohn Oliver covered this topic back in 2016: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-XlyB_QQYs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-XlyB_QQYs
- jamra 9y agoIf calling 911 can automatically send your location based on your mobile phone, you'd be able to save a lot of time for the operators, but I wonder how many lives would be saved from faster responses. Even better, if they created some app that would speed up the 911 process.
- markvdb 9y agoAs countless other countries have been doing for ages. Even Belgium does it: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=be.Nextel.EmergencyApp112&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=be.Nextel.Emer...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- madcow2011 9y agoTo bypass the paywall, try going to Google and typing in the name of the article ("Why Uber Can Find You but 911 Can’t"). That worked for me.
- thangngoc89 9y agoOh thank you. They must have check for referer. Because the google's link is exactly the same with HN's link
- sirsuki 9y agoI always wondered why the Phone app didn't have location services on and a big button that when the user presses it would grab the GPS coordinates and reverse geocoded address then have Siri read those over the phone line. That way no 911 center needs to upgrade and no telcos need to change infrastructure. A simple button right there on the phone that sends the following sound (in best Siri Voice imitation): "This phone is likely located near 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue North West, Washington DC, Latitude North 38° 53.8258', Longitude West 77° 2.1927' admire.admit.hulk" (last words intentional: http://what3words.com/ http://what3words.com/)
- joering2 9y agoHere is your answer: > That way no 911 center needs to upgrade and no telcos need to change infrastructure. If you ever touched upon how government bureaucracy works you will immediately realize the more taxpayers money spent the "better". Of course Im not for it, I'm just playing devil's advocate.
- passivepinetree 9y agoI had never heard of what3words before. It's a super cool and potentially incredibly useful idea. I wonder how they manage altitude (would a cave underground have the same 3 words as the patch of surface above it?). I also wonder how this is a monetizable product that warrants a company behind it. It seems like it'd be a perfect fit for open source work. Thanks for letting me know!
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoIndeed, it's entirely proprietary. Being able to get deliveries to your house shouldn't be dependent on someone paying a royalty to a startup.
- stevefeinstein 9y ago> potentially incredibly useful idea Do you really want to depend on a startup's ability to keep their service running and well funded to the location needs of emergency services? Unless they donate the grid and word associations to the public domain, it's a bad idea to use proprietary data sources for emergency services especially since there's nothing wrong with longitude and latitude, and humans really don't need to be able to read it, computers do just fine with it.
- halukakin 9y agoThere was a tv show called APB about this app/911 idea. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5542294/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5542294/
- geococcyxc 9y agoNo need for an app even, I read that (some?) german emergency call centers use a service that will send the caller a text with a link to a website that will then use the browser's geolocation API.
- jpalomaki 9y agoIn Finland we have an official 112 (that’s our 911) app which you can use to make the call and pass location info. The app will send the phone number and coordinates and then initiate a normal call. Officials can see the calling phone number and connect that to received location.
- larrik 9y agoNot as serious as the article, but I still don't understand why Find My Phone can almost tell me what room in the house each device is, but the (built-in) weather app tells me I'm 2 towns away...
- api_or_ipa 9y agoNot sure how far away towns are around you, but around the Bay Area at least, 2 towns don't stretch more than ~5 miles. Weather usually doesn't change that fast so its not a smart power move to thrash your battery querying for the most accurate weather data. Find My Phone, on the other hand, is probably a way more pressing issue and worthy of more resources spent achieving the best accuracy possible. Just my 2 cents, not a iOS engineer or anything.
- timack 9y agoJust before Christmas I spent an hour in a ditch with a broken hip after cycling into a a sheep (I'm from New Zealand and they crowd all our roads and are a frequent hazard). I was in a rural location so I had to spend quite a bit of time on the phone with the emergency dispatcher, while in a not insignificant amount of pain, trying to describe my location in relation to various landmarks. The dispatcher was in a different part of the country and was unfamiliar with local landmarks so this was very frustrating. I found out later that there is a increased probability of complications (avascular necrosis) if there is a delay having surgery following this type of injury (I'll know in a few month if I need to go back for a hip replacement). Not sure if an extra 10 - 15 minutes it took to get a ambo to me would have helped, but I'd prefer the odds my way where possible! My parents were confused by how I wasn't able to send the dispatcher my exactly location over the phone. Me after being picked up by ambos -> https://imgur.com/a/HJKWo https://imgur.com/a/HJKWo