7 ms·
“Interviews or exams” That you think interviews and exams are interchangeable concepts illustrates the problem. Nothing wrong with a rigorous filter at the gat
by closeparen 9y ago
“Interviews or exams”
That you think interviews and exams are interchangeable concepts illustrates the problem. Nothing wrong with a rigorous filter at the gates of the profession, but lawyers don’t need to spend months studying for each company’s half-assed version of the bar exam each time they change jobs. Our industry is dysfunctional because, unlike law and medicine, no one trusts the credentialing mechanisms.
- barry-cotter 9y agoWhat credentialing mechanisms? As we’re told over and over a CS degree is not a trade qualification. Having a CS degree is no guarantee of being able to program either. The example of Microsoft and Cisco qualifications is not stellar either. They’re often seen as a negative signal. And most working programmers don’t have a relevant credential unless you count a Bachelor’s degree which is more a certificate of middle class membership than necessary to work as a programmer.
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoOur industry also has quite a lot of self-taught professionals, who can perform as well as their college educated counterparts, which is something you won't really get in professions like Law or Medicine. I think that's a good thing, when it comes to software.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kramer1416 9y agoThat implies CS degree is a hoax, which is not. The bootcamp style of skilled labour generation is possible simply because of the demand-supply gap.
- sidlls 9y agoI'd make a different point: the CS degree isn't a hoax, but it's not strictly necessary for software engineering work. In a real world application systems very quickly escape the boundaries of undergrad CS facts.
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoI don't think so. Computers and software are simply more accessible for laymen to dig into and teach themselves something. You can't learn and practice surgery yourself. On the other hand, you can teach yourself software engineering. You can be practitioner with nothing more than a computer - and so many people are. That doesn't mean CS degrees are a hoax - it just means the field is more accessible to those without college degrees (though its definitely going to be a more difficult path).
- pjmlp 9y agoJust because in countries like US, one can call himself/herself engineer, without any actual meaning. At least in Europe things are a bit more strict.
- Tehnix 9y agoIt's an unfortunate situation honestly, because it pollutes the term "engineer" (at least for Europeans), when it's being conflated with "I just know how to code".
- Tehnix 9y agowhile it might to some seem slightly controversial, it would make more sense to argue against it instead of just down voting. Would you disagree if people from the US did not need to pass the bar to call themselves lawyers, or the equivalent for doctors? Is it just because I compared this specific thing from the US in a negative light compared to EU?
- walshemj 9y agoAnd which countries invented the computer pray? ok I know about Zuze but he was effectively ignored. In terms of PE / CENG status its more who you know that what you know :-)
- pjmlp 9y agoWell, computing has lots to thank to UK, Germany, Finland, France, Switzerland, Norway, Sweden and Denmark. Sorry if I forgot anything, fellow Europeans.
- walshemj 9y agoYou didn't get that I was hinting that countries that don't have strict rules about who can call themselves engineers invented the core tech behind computers ditto Ethernet which was US and UK.
- closeparen 9y agoA standardized credentialing exam doesn't have to require a college degree.
- sidlls 9y agoCredentialing isn't even the beginning: no one trusts other software companies, either, apparently. An engineer at Google will face a battery of asinine CS trivia when he interviews at FAAN, just the same as he faced interviewing at G. Hell, he might even face similar interviews if he applied at non-FAANG companies.
- ThrowawayR2 9y ago> Credentialing isn't even the beginning: no one trusts other software companies, either, apparently. Even the FAANG companies aren't immune from bad hires or people who burn out.