3 ms·
First of all, perhaps you want to use proper capitalization in your posts. It adds to the readability of your post. > blockchain has limited scalability, secon
by Fnoord 9y ago
First of all, perhaps you want to use proper capitalization in your posts. It adds to the readability of your post.
> blockchain has limited scalability, second layer doesn't. also blockchain transactions were never supposed to be instant.
Of course it wasn't supposed to be instant. That's why its a shit system to use as currency just like gold bars are a shit currency cause one has to drag them from the mine to the bank to the store. This Bitcoin thing was meant to be a currency, right?
I guess you're talking about Lightning Network though which Bitcoin evangelists appear to market as the Second Coming of Christ. Well, it isn't active yet, and it isn't part of Bitcoin ie. it isn't "Bitcoin". So... I was right.
> there are plenty
Not really. Many have been removed lately. There were Bitcoin debit cards. Well, they got revoked. Steam? Doesn't accept Bitcoins anymore due to high transaction costs. And those are just a few examples.
> in fact nothing is instant, check this thing called physics.
That's odd. I just put money on my debit card from my bank and it took like a minute. And I consider that slow! If I buy something from a store, which I did today, its instant enough that I can put my bank card in my wallet and move on. That's why I call it instant. The fact it isn't instant, is true, but it is nowhere near the latency of Bitcoin. And Bitcoin's latency is nowhere near my bank to debit card transaction. My statements regarding slow (and expensive) transactions were true.
> bitcoin is not even a blip in total world energy spending and less than that in total world energy production.
Yes, when it consumes more energy than my entire country, it is. Plus, when it is thin air we're discussing, it is.
> also if you check the dictionary for word sustainable:
How about you look up the word in your dictionary, called environment?
> bitcoin is sustainable by design.
Circulus in probando.
Wake me up when I can pay BTC at the same places where I can pay with EUR. I'll even do a concession! Wake me up when a United States resident can pay BTC at the same places they can pay with USD.
- keymone 9y agoYour post is very uninformed. Transaction speed is a function of timestamping mechanism of the consensus protocol. If that’s the only measure you decide whether the currency is shit - fair, don’t use it. FWIW cross-bank transfers aren’t instant too, shall I give you my credentials so you could promptly dispense of all the worthless shit money you have? Lightning network is active on mainnet, not sure what exactly batted that information from reaching you. Revokation of debit cards had nothing to do with bitcoin and there are plenty of companies that still offer them. That some merchants choose to drop support because low value transactions aren’t economical is unfortunate but also temporary. > when it consumes more energy than my entire country, it is Nope, still not a blip. So yourself a favor and spend more than 5 seconds to inform yourself on the topic. > How about you look up the word in your dictionary, called environment? You’re conflating energy use with energy source, nobody is burning oil to mine bitcoins - those guys are out of business. > wake me up when That explains everything - instead of informing yourself on the topic you just went to sleep. Bitcoin debit cards mostly cover those requirements btw.
- Fnoord 9y ago> If that’s the only measure you decide whether the currency is shit - fair, don’t use it. Reductio ad absurdum. I mentioned several reasons. > Lightning network is active on mainnet, not sure what exactly batted that information from reaching you. Why are Bitcoin transactions still slow? > Revokation of debit cards had nothing to do with bitcoin and there are plenty of companies that still offer them. Of course it is related to Bitcoin. Please link 5 of these currently valid Bitcoin debit card products. If they're so rampantly available, surely you can link 5 easily? > That some merchants choose to drop support because low value transactions aren’t economical is unfortunate but also temporary. Yeah, life is temporary as well rolleyes. This is a non-argument. You cannot tell when the problem is solved, and its a severe issue for adoption of Bitcoin. > Nope, still not a blip. So yourself a favor and spend more than 5 seconds to inform yourself on the topic. Yet, it is, and I can't be bothered to spend time to reply to the rest of your ad hominem. > You’re conflating energy use with energy source, nobody is burning oil to mine bitcoins - those guys are out of business. I didn't mention oil (ever heard of Co2?). I mentioned that power source has impact on the environment because that is reality 101. If I have 100 buckets of sustainable water, and I piss in 90 of them, then the rest of the world only got 10 buckets of sustainable water left for general consumption. Which is a loss of sustainable energy. So using unnecessarily vast amounts of energy is a loss for the environment. Of course this isn't in the interest of miners or Bitcoin evangelist like yourself. > That explains everything That explains nothing, its just one of your ad hominem fallacies which tells the reader something about you, not me. Instead, this explains everything: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-level_marketing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-level_marketing Dear reader, please don't fall for the Bitcoin scam. Read the above link instead, and notice the parallels with the Bitcoin/cryptocurrency mania. Specifically, the parallel with ICO and early adopters of cryptocurrencies.
- keymone 9y ago> I mentioned several reasons. "Of course it wasn't supposed to be instant. That's why its a shit system to use as currency" no you didn't. > Why are Bitcoin transactions still slow? that blanket statement is false and again illustrates how little you know about bitcoin. bitcoin transactions confirm within 10 minutes provided adequate fees. the lower fee you choose to pay the more you will have to wait until confirmation. speed is function of fees. if you intended to ask "why aren't all transactions on lightning and therefore instant?" then it's because lightning is still in very early stages and is only starting to get adoption. > Of course it is related to Bitcoin it was related to one visa card issuer (wavecrest) that decided to discontinue support without any explanation. debit card providers that didn't rely on wavecrest are doing fine (and those that did - are moving to new issuers). quick google shows a whole bunch: cryptopay.me, bitpay, spectrocoin, xapo, www.shiftpayments.com. there's 5 for you. > Yeah, life is temporary as well rolleyes. This is a non-argument. You cannot tell when the problem is solved, and its a severe issue for adoption of Bitcoin. this is possibly a non argument for you as a person who knows very little about the space. everybody is aware that issue exists and makes a lot of low value transactions on chain economically not viable, that is exactly why lightning was developed. > I can't be bothered to spend time to reply to the rest of your ad hominem. you sure can't be bothered to educate yourself on the topic. as it seems you're from netherlands, your country's total energy consumption in 2012 was 82 Mtoe, total world energy consumption was 9000 Mtoe and world energy production was 13300 Mtoe. as i said - not even a blip, just find some courage to admit you were wrong. alternatively you could of course start arguing that 0.9% is totally a blip, in which case i'm at least happy to leave you better informed. > If I have 100 buckets of sustainable water, and I piss in 90 of them, then the rest of the world only got 10 buckets of sustainable water left for general consumption it's called a free market. if it is economically viable for mining companies to spend energy at their location for the price at that location - not much you can do about it. > So using unnecessarily vast amounts of energy is a loss for the environment it's only unnecessary by your definition and understanding of bitcoin. > Dear reader, please don't fall for the Bitcoin scam. Read the above link instead, and notice the parallels with the Bitcoin/cryptocurrency mania. Specifically, the parallel with ICO and early adopters of cryptocurrencies. yeah, i totally agree about most altcoins and ICOs. the rest is just you being angry and extrapolating more than you should.
- bfuller 9y agoIf you live in a tech hub there are plenty of restaurants etc that will take crypto. There are dentists and doctors that take it now.
- Fnoord 9y agoWorld-wide? Can you state 10 of these tech hubs where Bitcoin is widespread? I haven't seen any place in Amsterdam Area (where I live, throughout Europe considered a tech hub) accepting Bitcoin. When I was in Berlin, saw zero Bitcoin as well. C-Base didn't accept it either. They did accept this currency called EUR, though. Bitcoin's slow transaction speed wouldn't be an issue for something like dentist/doctor. Those have your PII including your SSN (or well, the Dutch equiv here), and you got physical contact with them. The payment here even goes via insurance company. Have never heard of any Dutch insurance company accepting Bitcoin though.
- berkes 9y ago> I haven't seen any place in Amsterdam Area You haven't looked very hard, than. This is a "black swan" thing, by the way. So here's why you are entirely wrong: * thuisbezorgd.nl accepts Bitcoin. Has done that for years. You can order from any snackbar, febo, pizza-joint, sushi-bar and pay with Bitcoin. Literally thousands of places in Amsterdam. * mollie.com has offered a bitcoin-payment option for all their merchants to enable for years. Many webshops in the netherlands have enabled this (I use at least three on a monthly basis) who will then accept bitcoin. * At least two lodging/guesthouses in Amsterdam accept BTC to sleep there. * At least 8 coffee-shops (the ones selling actual coffee) and restaurants accept it. * A cinema (Filmhuis Cavia), a barber, a grocery-shop, a vegan restaurant, a lawyer (Plasman) and probaly many more. So, there you are: you were wrong: You can spend your BTC just fine in the fysical world. Even in the city you live in.
- Fnoord 9y agoOh I did look very hard. Thuisbezorgd.nl supports Bitcoin, that's not specific to Amsterdam Area though since it is nation-wide, and its a middleman not a local shop. So it isn't an argument for Amsterdam Area being a techhub for Bitcoin. Thuisbezorgd supporting Bitcoin payment is probably the flagship of Bitcoin support in The Netherlands and a solid example because it is basically the Dutch version of Uber Eats, and has a very strong market penetration in that field. Kudos for bringing it up. Mollie, OTOH, is just a niche. Now, let us discuss the amount of Thuisbezorgd transactions paid by means of Bitcoin. Paraphrasing their own words: "far less than 1%, and it hasn't increased over time" [1] (Nov 2017). They also convert the Bitcoin to EUR right away. That tells us something about the adoption of Bitcoin in the general public when your best example is this one. The elephant in the room is that paying with Bitcoin isn't feasible in this example due to the high transaction costs, and slow transaction speed. Apart from Thuisbezorgd all of these examples are just that, exceptions and niches. They don't paint a Bitcoin paradise where one can spend their Bitcoins. If I take public transport, I gotta pay with EUR. If I pay for my OV Chipkaart (NFC) then I gotta put the money on the card via... EUR. There's no alternative to that. If I then go to IKEA and buy a bank, I gotta pay with EUR. If I then ask PostNL to deliver it, I gotta pay with, you guessed it, EUR. And if we'd go for a quickie at my fav fast food restaurant, Maoz, well they don't accept Bitcoins either. Thuisbezorgd supports it (though I have no idea on the effect on delivery time, and transaction costs must be very high relative to the food. For one pizza that wouldn't be feasible) the rest is practically irrelevant. Take this for example: > At least two lodging/guesthouses in Amsterdam accept BTC to sleep there. Two, woah! Blimey the free market provides us two options! Which ones? Wake me up when its market penetration is above 50%. Same can be said about your 8 (!!!) coffee-shops/restaurants. Look, it is a given that with so many stores (thousands) in such a small area, a few shops are going to adopt it. There were also shops who committed to the tulip mania back in the days, there are people in Amsterdam who work in MLM scheme, there are criminals as well, there's illegal prostitution, and there's Scientologists as well. That doesn't mean its a tech hub who adopted Bitcoin, doesn't mean the entire city is criminal, doesn't mean the entire city is full with illegal prostitution, nor that the entire city believes in Xenu. A Bitcoin techhub or paradise would be a place where you can live your daily life by means of merely Bitcoins. We're not even remotely close to that in Amsterdam. I don't think it will ever happen. Although its in the interest of the Bitcoin facade to believe that, yes, Bitcoin can be easily used in the real world right now because you want to be able to cash out when the bubble busts (or right before that) your options are in practice severely limited. You cannot even remotely compare it to a strong currency like USD or EUR. Fuck me man, 8 cafetaria/restaurants to pick from in Amsterdam is seen as a techhub? A Pyrrhic victory, that's what that is. > You can spend your BTC just fine in the fysical world. Only at a very miniscule amount of stores. I wouldn't call this Amsterdam place "a techhub who adopted Bitcoin." [1] https://www.ad.nl/economie/thuisbezorgd-nl-is-voorzichtig-met-bitcoins-en-loopt-miljoenen-mis~a9b9b20c/ https://www.ad.nl/economie/thuisbezorgd-nl-is-voorzichtig-me...