9 ms·
What would be the point of arming SK over having a nuclear sub in the area? Would anyone really believe SK could launch them of their own volition? Surely they
by icebraining 9y ago
What would be the point of arming SK over having a nuclear sub in the area? Would anyone really believe SK could launch them of their own volition? Surely they would be nothing more than US bombs in SK soil.
- ScottBurson 9y agoSeems to me that if Kim thought there was even a possibility that South Korea could retaliate on its own, with nukes, it would make him less likely to launch an offensive attack. But you're right. We don't really want to put nukes under the control of the South Korean government. Convincing the Chinese and Russians that yes, we really will do that if we see no alternative, wouldn't be easy.
- Spooky23 9y agoIt controls the political risk of a rift in the alliance or cold feet on behalf of the United States. The situation you see playing out in Europe, where Trump’s affinity for Russia puts NATO’s integrity in question is an example of why a smaller party like South Korea would want an independent deterrent.
- icebraining 9y agoNo, I get why SK would want them; my question is about the US giving them nukes - more specifically, why would anyone believe that those nukes, even if the US did put them in SK, could actually be fired by the Koreans independently. I don't think the US can convince anyone that they would really unconditionally give nukes to SK to do whatever they wanted with them.
- Spooky23 9y agoI misunderstood. My assumption is that they would obtain them in a manner similar to Israel, and not acknowledge their existence officially.