5 ms·
There's been a marked tendency to replace intersections with roundabouts and shared spaces (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shared_space https://en.wikipedia.org/
by rcarmo 9y ago
There's been a marked tendency to replace intersections with roundabouts and shared spaces (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shared_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shared_space) in many places, including the outskirts of Lisbon (as well as a few legendary mazes in Britain).
There was even a BBC report on the latter (which I can't find right now, as usual, only a follow-up: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-33303031 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-33303031).
Drawing a (admittedly inaccurate) parallel with shared spaces (which are harder to navigate by sensory deprived humans than standard intersections), I'd say roundabouts (which preserve crossings) would be a more sensible short-term approach overall -- especially considering the remaining human drivers.
Full disclosure: I don't drive anymore. Gave it up decades ago because I prefer to do something useful with my commute times, and resort to public transportation or Uber whenever possible, which (ironically) allows me to arrive earlier to meetings than most of my colleagues (who need to hunt down a parking space).
- ColanR 9y agore shared spaces, from the wikipedia: > Hans Monderman and others have suggested that, by creating a greater sense of uncertainty and making it unclear who has priority, drivers will reduce their speed, in turn reducing the dominance of vehicles, reducing road casualty rates, and improving safety for other road users. clearly, Hans Monderman has never driven in Mumbai, India.
- rcarmo 9y agoI think that shared spaces make sense in small towns, university campuses, and other contexts where traffic flow is low due to the inherent context (and, above all, where pedestrians can support each other). But for modest to high volume traffic, roundabouts are better (although if the traffic flow is constant, you usually have to place the crossings a bit further away from the center of the roundabout, which makes it a little harder on elderly pedestrians to go fully "across" since they have to walk the extra distance).
- ryth_ 9y agoThey actually introduced a shared space at Amsterdam Central Station about 1-2 years ago that I cross daily. The shared space is right next to the incredibly busy ferries and perpendicular to what used to be a bicycle lane. It's now one big square shared by bicycles, pedestrians and scooters. It does work incredibly well and there are rarely any accidents. The downside however is that it's quite a struggle to cross. It makes me dread to leave the ferry and enter the warzone once again every morning. I understand that it is designed to make me uncomfortable, but it is taken to such an extend that I don't even really want to walk there.
- danmaz74 9y ago> one big square shared by bicycles, pedestrians and scooters You mean, no cars?
- burfog 9y agoFor high traffic, a roundabout would have to be truly huge. It isn't viable unless land is practically free. You need something more like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Five_Interchange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Five_Interchange That crosses 16 lanes with 14 lanes. (3,5,5,3 with 3,4,4,3)
- danmaz74 9y ago> clearly, Hans Monderman has never driven in Mumbai, India. Or Naples, Italy.
- lsc 9y ago>clearly, Hans Monderman has never driven in Mumbai, India. I'm reminded of my time in Berkeley. Now, in spite of what Fox News might tell you, Berkeley is one of the most ridiculously upper class places possible. But, it's right next to Oakland, a place that... isn't. In Berkeley? If you even look like you were about to step out into the road in the middle of the street, people would stop for you. Over in El Cerrito or Oakland? you could be in the crosswalk, and nobody even slows down.
- avip 9y agoRoundabout throughput drops when traffic load increases. They are useful (and great) for low volume traffic/suburbs.
- rcarmo 9y agoMany towns add them precisely because it regulates traffic flow near homes.
- icebraining 9y agoIf you have such a high-traffic road, shouldn't you use interchanges instead anyway?
- rahimnathwani 9y agoEven for large roundabouts with traffic lights?
- Retric 9y agoYes, large roundabouts have horrible throughput vs the space they take up.
- partycoder 9y agoIn Barcelona they have "Superblocks" https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/may/17/superblocks-rescue-barcelona-spain-plan-give-streets-back-residents#img-2 https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/may/17/superblocks-r...
- tomxor 9y ago> Drawing a (admittedly inaccurate) parallel with shared spaces (which are harder to navigate by sensory deprived humans than standard intersections), I'd say roundabouts (which preserve crossings) would be a more sensible short-term approach overall -- especially considering the remaining human drivers. I actually find roundabouts easier to navigate than large crossroads, I think this is partly because they actually are objectively easier and safer to navigate (one stream of traffic) and partly (but mostly) because they are dominant in the UK. But for the same reason (familiarity) I expect many in the US would find roundabouts hard to navigate (and maybe unsafe as a result?), it's more about what you are used to and what you had to learn as part of your driving test. Are roundabouts part of driving tests in the US?
- nsp 9y agon=1, but roundabouts we’re not a part of my driving test in Texas. That said, driving tests are done at the state level, not nationally.
- sndean 9y agoIt wasn't part of my driving test in Virginia, at least when I took it. I'm guessing if your state has a low number of roundabouts [0] then it's pretty unlikely you'll be tested on it. I'd be interested to hear if Marylanders (#1 in roundabouts:intersections) have it on their test. Personally, I freak out when I see a roundabout coming up, and slow down dramatically. Or, I completely avoid them. [0] https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2016/03/america-traffic-roundabouts-street-map/408598/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2016/03/america-traff...
- rtpg 9y agoIt's possible that even when slowing down the roundabout still ends up being more efficient, since you don't have as much "stop/go" action going on
- tomxor 9y agoThis is generally how it works in the UK, except for newbies who tend to always stop completely rather than try to time the merge where possible... I've heard that this is actually taught in advanced driving in the UK (to maintain flow when possible, time merges etc). Frankly there are some roundabouts in cities at rush hour which are frightening for new drivers and you just can't join unless you have good timing and can get up to speed quickly (or get a lucky smooth merge).
- chrisper 9y agoI don't think roundabouts would work in the Bay area because it requires that people know how to use turn signals.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y agoSo the solution is a full switch to autonomous vehicles and a ban of all manually driven vehicles? People will learn to use turn signals quickly if they are fined.
- chrisper 9y agoI think for now increasing the requirements to get a driver's license Should help. Works well in Europe. Though I can understand why this wouldn't work in the US.
- shostack 9y agoHow has life been with transportation abstracted away into an app? Any unintended consequences?
- jakecopp 9y agoI grew up in Canberra, known as the roundabout capital of Australia [1] as well as being the actual capital of Australia. It has a population of ~350,000, 406 roundabouts and 276 traffic lights. In my experience they keep traffic moving really well, as long as the traffic load into each entrance is roughly equal - otherwise it's hard to enter the roundabout from a lesser used entrance. They take up more space than traffic lights in most situations, however Canberra is a planned suburbia so that wasn't an issue there. [1]: http://www.abc.net.au/news/specials/curious-canberra/2016-12-05/is-canberra-the-roundabout-capital-of-australia/8075412 http://www.abc.net.au/news/specials/curious-canberra/2016-12...