4 ms·
No language that "compiles to javascript" really creates new language primitives - it would have to rewrite the interpreter to do that. What it does do - simula
by krapp 9y ago
No language that "compiles to javascript" really creates new language primitives - it would have to rewrite the interpreter to do that. What it does do - simulating new language features in javascript - could theoretically be done with a framework as well.
- jstanley 9y agoWell then do you think no language that "compiles to machine code" really creates new language primitives, either? The compiler can do compile-time checks that wouldn't be possible if it were implemented as a library instead.
- krapp 9y ago> Well then do you think no language that "compiles to machine code" really creates new language primitives, either? No, because javascript isn't machine code, it's a high-level interpreted language. The metaphor of javascript as "bytecode" is just that - a metaphor. >The compiler can do compile-time checks that wouldn't be possible if it were implemented as a library instead. Fair enough, but it doesn't actually change the grammar of the language, because those new "primitives" have to be implemented in, and interpreted as, javascript.
- nothrabannosir 9y ago> No, because javascript isn't machine code, it's a high-level interpreted language. The metaphor of javascript as "bytecode" is just that - a metaphor. This is a psychological distinction, not a technical one. There is no fundamental difference between machine code, byte code, or a “real” programming language. There were machines that executed lisp, and at the dawn of time people programmed in assembly. Heck, people programmed in machine code (punch cards) and assembly was a programming language! Scala introduces a hell of a lot of “new primitives” over jvm bytecode, and type erasure compiles it all down to the jvm anyway. Or JavaScript, if you use scala.js. This is, in fact, precisely what compilers do (or transpilers—again: psychological distinction, technically the same thing). That is their job, their function: translating from one language into another. As long as both are Turing complete, you can do anything.
- z3t4 9y agoIt's funny when languages like C where you have to baby-sit the memory handler "compiles" to JavaScript, where all memory handling is completely abstracted.
- krapp 9y agoTen hours later and it's obvious from the all but unanimous negativity that I'm wrong about something. But, I don't think the distinction is entirely psychological. Every numeric type is implemented in javascript as a floating point Number, that's all javascript has. New types aren't added to javascript when other languages compile to it, they're compensated for within the limits of what a javascript parser considers valid code, either through existing javascript types or facades which imitate types. Whatever Scala or any other language considers an Int, BigInt, Double, etc. must still be implemented as a Number when compiled to javascript, or some object which imitates the semantics of the original language. But an Int() object in javascript is still not an integer. It doesn't make sense to say that languages which compile to javascript add anything to the language. Or maybe I just don't understand types, and they really do, and it really doesn't matter. But to me, the distinction seems to matter. I should probably stop tilting at this particular windmill, though.
- jstanley 9y ago> it doesn't actually change the grammar of the language Yes it does! That's the entire point. It doesn't change the grammar of the language that the generated code is using, but you don't care, because you're not writing in that language.
- krapp 9y ago>It doesn't change the grammar of the language that the generated code is using, but you don't care, because you're not writing in that language. But that's the grammar I was talking about, so no it doesn't.
- wehere111 9y agorelevant username!
- wereHamster 9y agoJust like no language that compiles to machine code can create new x86 assembler instructions. So sure, what Elm gives you can be done with just a framework, but it wouldn't be very productive. There is a reason why hardly anybody programs in assembler anymore (unless they have a good reason). Higher-level languages provide better abstractions, allow you to write more expressive code, are safer etc.
- cube2222 9y agoNo, you wouldn't get the required compile time checks. (Transpile time checks in exact)
- reificator 9y agoA compiler takes input in one language and converts it to another language. That the web community has a fundamental misunderstanding of this and created a derivative word with the same meaning is unfortunate. That it is now being used in misguided pedantic arguments reflects poorly on our community.
- cube2222 9y agoThe transpiler add-on in the comment wasn't meant to be meaningful anyhow. The main point were the compile time checks, which aren't to be achieved when using a library. Thanks for the correction though!
- z5h 9y agoYou don't know what you're talking about.