3 ms·
Near as I can tell, the real question is "why has marriage/childbearing been delayed?" The answer is the sexual revolution and women's empowerment. Except durin
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Near as I can tell, the real question is "why has marriage/childbearing been delayed?" The answer is the sexual revolution and women's empowerment. Except during the 50's and 60's, I don't think it was ever that common to pick one job and stick with it until retirement on a defined-benefit pension. The 50's and 60's were exceptional.
I think the real issue here is that the baby boomers and later generations enjoy infantilizing their children. First they needed to protect their 10 year olds from nonexistent child predators, wifi and inorganic food. Then they needed to protect their 16 year olds from depraved newfangled sex ("rainbow parties", etc), completely unlike the sex they had during the 60's/70's. Now that their kids are grown up, they need a new reason to remain involved and treat them as infants.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoParagraph one is worth an upvote, but I don't think you need go so far as the pop psych of paragraph two. Paragraph one -- indeed, sentence one, which points out that marriage and childbearing are delayed in modern technological societies -- explains most everything else. Especially when combined with the key fact that in the USA all incomes except those of the rich have been declining in real terms for over a generation. And independence costs money. Kids stay involved with their parents longer because the marginal cost of the fourth bedroom in a four-bedroom house is a lot smaller than the cost of a one-bedroom apartment. The other thing I'd point out is that the "traditional American way" to run a nuclear family -- the one where kids hit age 18 and then move out on their own, sometimes to other states -- is (was?) actually a very specific pattern of life from a very specific time in a very specific culture. In many cultures, historically and around the world, households traditionally contained grandparents, parents, and children all living together. It would be considered alien for a child to desert the home of their parents unless they were explicitly married out to another family, in which case the child would be expected to live in the home of the spouse's parents. To strike out on your own would be crazy! What would your family say? (And one wonders if the nomads of the Tibetan plateau are sitting around reading Tibetan op-eds bemoaning the decline of the traditional Tibetan family: Some women are taking only one husband! What are his brothers supposed to do for a wife? [1]) Traditions can be pretty ephemeral. One of my favorite things to do is to find "ancient traditions" whose inventors are still living. --- [1] Note: I took Anthropology 101 from a world expert on polyandry -- one of the world's most unusual family patterns -- but I should note that I made up this particular example. I actually have no idea to what extent polyandry is in decline, or whether a family of Tibetan nomadic brothers and their wife are likely to read op-eds.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoEspecially when combined with the key fact that all incomes except those of the top quintile have been declining in real terms for over a generation. Although I hear this claim made often, I believe it to be untrue. People at all income quintiles have more and better stuff now than people at the same quintile at all periods in the past [1]. That would be impossible if real incomes really went down. [1] I'm assuming comparisons over at least 10 years, to avoid "during recession" vs "peak of bubble" comparisons.
- moultano 16y agoI'd compare it to the cost of housing/food, not the cost of stuff for the purposes of this article at least. "Stuff" always gets cheaper and cooler. The fundamental things you need for independence don't necessarily.
- watmough 16y agoThe claim is correct. The reason that people have more and better stuff is that women in extremely large numbers, have gone out and taken jobs in order to support families. Principally, the increase in costs to raise a family comes from large rises in the cost of housing and healthcare. Quote: "The crisis facing the middle class started more than a generation ago. Even as productivity rose, the wages of the average fully-employed male have been flat since the 1970s. But core expenses kept going up. By the early 2000s, families were spending twice as much (adjusted for inflation) on mortgages than they did a generation ago -- for a house that was, on average, only ten percent bigger and 25 years older. They also had to pay twice as much to hang on to their health insurance." http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-warren/america-without-a-middle_b_377829.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-warren/america-witho...
- yummyfajitas 16y agoDo you believe the average fully employed male today has fewer goods/services than in the past? If not, then my point stands. (Regarding Warren, see my other posts in this thread. Her data shows that a two-income couple of 2000 has more income and also consumes considerably more stuff than a single-earner in 1970. E.g., the 2000-era couple spends 55% more on 2 cars than the 1970-era couple spent on 1 car.)
- mbateman 16y agoThat last paragraph is one of the most incisive comments I've read on HN. I'll just add that there's a feedback loop. The more parents infantile their children, the longer the children tend to take to grow up, and the more the parents will feel like the children are infants.
- brc 16y agoI'll second this notion. I know of a grown family (youngest in early 40's) and without exception, they're all adult-children, incapable of forging ahead in this world. Their parents have continually bailed them out of bad decisions, bad marriages, bad businesses for 2 decades. The only problem is now the parents made some bad business decisions so the whole family unit is in big trouble. I've seen a grown man in his 40's crying to his Mum, who comforts him with the sorts of noises you would to soothe a 5 year old. I'm not talking about 'my friend died' here - I'm talking about 'my life sucks and I hate my job'
- andolanra 16y ago"In England between 1500 and 1700 the median age of first marriage for women was twenty-six." -Marriage: A History, Stephanie Coontz via Snopes. I haven't done independent fact-checking of this statement, but assuming it is true, and taking it in light of the numbers given in the article, it seems like the 1970s were the historical aberration where people married younger, instead of the present being the aberration for people marrying older. I think the biggest fault of the article is that it takes as its thesis, "Things aren't like when I grew up, and the way things were when I grew up is the natural order of things!"
- ALee 16y agoI've heard this is true as well. I wonder if this one point is because women were liberated from having to stay with their parents, but were still unable to truly support themselves given income discrepancies.
- ericb 16y agoYou have great points, except with regard to organic vs. inorganic food. Most web apps get more testing than the pesticides we ingest in our food supply.
- say_ 16y agoI think the real issue here is that the baby boomers and later generations enjoy infantilizing their children. First they needed to protect their 10 year olds from nonexistent child predators, wifi and inorganic food. Then they needed to protect their 16 year olds from depraved newfangled sex ("rainbow parties", etc), completely unlike the sex they had during the 60's/70's. Now that their kids are grown up, they need a new reason to remain involved and treat them as infants. Well, as long as we're shooting from the hip, I think there's a different reason behind delayed marriage and childbearing. Being constantly flooded with information allows people to form a better picture of where they fit in the world, and be generally more self aware of what they want out of life. That means that people can't live life on instinctual autopilot like they used to. Why spend some of the best years for taking a risk (not just startups, but things like taking a year off to backpack, etc.) doing the most staid and conservative thing a person can do--settle down and start a family? I could easily be wrong, but I seriously doubt that being coddled as kids has any bearing on the current state of adulthood. That's the kind of thing people have been saying forever.
- brc 16y agoI think you're wrong about being constantly flooded with information. If anything, it's having the opposite effect. I can do anything? Well, er, um, I don't know what to do. I'd cite the famous study that showed more choice equals less action with the jams in the supermarket if I could be bothered to look it up. I know it was much easier for me to make life choices once I had ruled out a massive amount of things. I also don't see backpacking as drawing out childhood - if anything, the opposite. Well travelled people used to adverse circumstance and problem solving make better adults. It's the ones who never leave home, never make any choices, never do anything that are the eternal kids.
- potatolicious 16y agoYou've good points - but I think you missed something. Marriage/childbearing has been delayed because we can't afford it. My father at 30 could afford a bungalow to raise his kids, and my mother could afford to be a housewife. Try doing that today. Where I grew up housing has inflated to the point where I'd have to be making the equivalent of 3-4x my father's old salary to even afford the mortgage. Keeping quality of life level, it's hard to imagine being able to own a home in a decent neighborhood, even if your partner works also (which, btw, makes childbearing even less attractive). IMHO it has less to do with sexual empowerment and more to do with the fact that the middle class is shrinking alarmingly quickly, and fairly soon will be all but a memory. The whole concept of the breadwinner feeding a caretaker and children in a home that he/she owns is practically impossible for most of America today.
- nollidge 16y agoAnecdotally, I know 4 or 5 couples who had kids and a mortgage before age 30 in the 2000's, probably two of them with only one income, the others with ~1.5 incomes. Not that your overall point is wrong, but depending on your location and education level it is completely financially feasible to purchase a home and afford kids on one income.
- akgerber 16y agoWithin three years of college, I could probably buy a house on my own in Pittsburgh or many other areas in America's vast middle, even putting 20% down. Heck, my friend bought a house in Seattle within six months of graduating. He's leveraged as hell, but has a job at Amazon and is renting rooms to friends.