4 ms·
Just a clarification, there were not dozens of cities of refuge, only six on each side of the river (well, more after the return of the messiah), and they only
by QAPereo 9y ago
Just a clarification, there were not dozens of cities of refuge, only six on each side of the river (well, more after the return of the messiah), and they only applied to people who had been found guilty of accidental homicide (what we’d call manslaughter) and not murder. That ruling had to come from a Jewish “court” and the killer had to be outside of the extended family unit. The killers were not protected by city leaders, but by tradition and scripture, until the death of the high priest, after which they were free to leave unmolested.
Of course travel in those days, especially fleeing for your life, was hardly easy. Complicating matters for the killer, was the Go’El Haddam, “The Redeemer of Blood” who’s duty it was to kill you unless you were in a city of refuge.
Mind you, indefinite banishment would have been a slow death sentence for the average Sumerian or Cannanite Joe. Being cut off from friends, family, community and the ability to travel beyond the city is rough, but as you say, not jail. Remember though, that all of this is discussion of a form of religiously mandated execution.
Curse your parents? Dead.
Break the sabbath? Dead.
Plant the wrong crops? Dead.
Prisons came about because socieites started to offer something other than the need to flee, or die. Initially prisons were just pee-trial holding areas, but as more people lived together, that changed. As the expectation of s fair trial spread, jails which could safely hold people for more than the few days between their apprehension and execution became necessary.
Anyone who by violence causes a death must be put to death. If, however, he has not planned to do it but it comes from God by his hand, he can take refuge in a place which I shall appoint for you. But should any person dare to kill another with deliberate planning, you will take that person even from my altar to be put to death.. Exodus 21:12-13
http://www.agapebiblestudy.com/Joshua/Joshua_Lesson_9.htm http://www.agapebiblestudy.com/Joshua/Joshua_Lesson_9.htm
https://gradebuddy.com/doc/2330783/the-release-of-homicides-from-the-cities-of-refuge?full=1 https://gradebuddy.com/doc/2330783/the-release-of-homicides-...
- Xeoncross 9y agoThank you for clarifying the details. I suppose my original mention of cities of refuge was actually superfluous to the discussion anyway.
- QAPereo 9y agoWhat I really appreciate more than anything else about this site, is that all kinds of interesting things come up. Cities of refuge coming up in a discussion about contemporary society and jurisprudence strikes me as valuable, and I appreciate you raising the subject. Thanks for taking the time to read my ramble.