6 ms·
Even if we can't justify drawing a sharp line between humans and everything else, you get into very tricky ground if you do not. Ant colonies have a similar bi
by roenxi 9y ago
Even if we can't justify drawing a sharp line between humans and everything else, you get into very tricky ground if you do not.
Ant colonies have a similar biomass to humankind [1]. If humans aren't exceptional, do we acknowledge some sort of responsibility to provide for ants? Can they draw on welfare?
If we separate by intelligence ... humans are clearly quite exceptional. Even then though, if we reject human exceptionalism we will need convoluted definitions. Can a town itself sue you for leaving because the intelligence of the town itself decreases? Is a corporation a philosophical as well as legal entity? Can they feel pain? A corporation can 'speak'; to some extent independently of the people in it.
Humans may well not be exceptional in the harsh world of facts and science. We still have to act as though we are or we may as well give way to nihilism. The line has to be drawn somewhere.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomass_(ecology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomass_(ecology)
- circlefavshape 9y agoThe sum of the mass of all human approximately equals the sum of the mass of all ants ... and therefore if humans are not special ants we need to consider whether ants are entitled to welfare payments? What??
- EliRivers 9y agoIf we separate by intelligence ... humans are clearly quite exceptional. We can pick a great many animals, and say that if we separate by intelligence, they are expectional, doing things that other species can at best only crudely approximate. Human specialised intelligence is really good at doing human specialised things. I think I'd agree that humans do some things with their intelligence that might put them into a fresh category, but the point I'm suggesting is that humans are not the only creature with an exceptional intelligence.
- pc86 9y agoYes dolphins and octopuses (and others I'm forgetting, I'm sure) have intelligence far and above their peers. But human intelligence is clearly much greater, isn't it? If humans are at a 100 and "normal" animals are at a ~5, the fact that octopuses and dolphins are in the 25-30 range doesn't mean they're equivalent to humans, or that human intelligence is limited to "human specialised things," it just means they're smarter than birds or snakes or crocodiles.
- EliRivers 9y agoBut human intelligence is clearly much greater, isn't it? I think I'm going to say that "greater" doesn't really fit. Specialised in a different way, yes. I think that trying to apply a single value on a single scale simplifies it to a nonsense. How are you measuring this? How are you coming up with numbers? A Clark's Nutcracker can remember the location of tens of thousands of hidden pine seeds over a 15 mile radius and find them even though it's now a snowy winter and the seed was buried months previously. Clearly, this bird is smarter than pretty much every human I ever met. A chimp (at least one chimp) is better at remembering random numbers than a human (at least some humans, including a memory champion); https://www.sciencefriday.com/articles/are-humans-smarter-than-chimps-think-again/ https://www.sciencefriday.com/articles/are-humans-smarter-th... It's usually about this point the guy on HN who claims animals can't think because they have no formal spoken language turns up.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoI find that hard to believe. Does the nutcracker remember, or just get the same environmental cues each time they visit a location? Does it remember whether the seed is gone? Does it search locations that have no seeds? How could this feat even have been validated? Who recorded thousands of seed hiding actions, and monitored all winter over 15 square miles?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lukeschlather 9y agoYou can pick apart any feats of memory in this fashion. The fact is animal memory is not like computer memory. When we say a person or an animal "remembers where something is" we don't mean they have a detailed photo-realistic map in their head. We mean they've stored exactly enough information to allow them to navigate to the object.
- mrow84 9y ago> If humans aren't exceptional, do we acknowledge some sort of responsibility to provide for ants? Acknowledging human responsibility for non-human parts of reality is surely a legitimate moral position, whether or not it is one that you hold? My understanding is that some (or even many) societies have maintained more holistic moral positions, that don't elevate humans beyond other parts of the world, so it seems like a viewpoint people may even be predisposed to, given the right conditions.
- pc86 9y agoYou can have a position that doesn't elevate humans beyond other living things but still err on the side of human life/safety/progress/comfort over other living things, can't you?
- mrow84 9y agoMy main point was simply that moral positions that are not human-centric can and do exist. It strikes me that the difficulty with accepting the possibility of human responsibility for non-human parts of reality may simply be a consequence of the moral position that is currently quite widespread - something like the one you describe. That position requires a line to be drawn (as OP noted), or perhaps rather values to be assigned, to the human and non-human, but that valuation is impossible in practice, and so really it just allows us to accommodate our own interests whenever the need takes us, and ignore our hypothetical responsibilities. As to the specifics of your point, I think the answer has to be no: if your position is explicitly to not elevate humans over other living beings then surely it is a contradiction to err on one side or the other?
- bitcoinusername 9y agoThere's no need to define boundaries that give rise to bazillion exceptions. Nihilism isn't the ultimate end. I'd say that if you can choose between eating a fruit, and killing a bird and eating it's flesh, a virtuous agent would eat the fruit. It's unnecessary to go the utilitarian way of trying to draw the lines and meet every single exception to the rule. Acting in the world as a virtuous agent is a much more practical approach. Would you test and experiment on someone who has a nervous system capable of feeling pain and suffering, if it could save thousands or even millions of people? Given the data of the lack of success of a huge percentage of studies, you would, being virtuous, deduce that it's better to seek other means of testing instead of doing a hit and miss approach on animals. People don't behave as virtuous agents, and they do not act kindly. Especially not to those they deem less worthy than them. That's why stuff needs rethinking and regulation.
- Ntrails 9y agoWhere is it enshrined as truth that being virtuous (by the implied definition above) is important or even desirable as a trait in a species?
- hood_syntax 9y agoThis is the crux of the issue. What makes one moral framework "virtuous" and one not? It could be considered virtuous to ensure the dominance of the most competitive species (us in this case). Even if one, for the most part, cares for the world around them, is it virtuous to attempt to ensure the survival of a species like the panda? As a species it would vanish without any outside intervention.
- katzgrau 9y agoConsidering humans the most competitive species is also something that could be called into question. We certainly think we're special, but we're probably falling into Dunning-Kruger territory. I think the only obvious route is to treat other living things the way we would like to be treated - after all, we have a common ancestry and a case could be made that we're just one big multicellular organism
- wastewaste 9y agoIn my humble opinion, Nihilism is the philosophical base for everything else. "fall back on" would be suitable. Point in case, the empty set is the initial element of set theory, as zero is the first element of the natural numbers, the identity element of addition. Without it, there is no equallity, no half order (and thus no order?). Horror Vacuui is very real though (fear of emptiness), the zero set is isomorphic to the one-structure, the terminal structure of structural homomorphism (if I remember correctly) as in the null element of multiplication.
- mannykannot 9y agoOne does not give way to nihilism, one accepts it and carries on.
- dwaltrip 9y agoMeaning permeates my life, regardless of any pending heat death of the universe. I can't deny this. Nihilism thus loses its muster.
- freeflight 9y ago> If humans aren't exceptional, do we acknowledge some sort of responsibility to provide for ants? Not necessarily provide for them, but the opposite extreme (not caring if they exist) isn't all that much better and hubris born out of the notion that humans are so exceptional and at the center of everything. Because this ignores the fact that our habitat (Earth) doesn't just revolve around our existence, our existence is just a part in a vast ecosystem which can only work because life exists in all kinds of shapes and forms. Nature isn't optional, it's what allowed us to get where we are today, the more we forget this the more likely we are to make mistakes which can't be reversed and will ultimately lead to the destruction of our one and only habitat.
- kiliantics 9y agoThis is the way we should be looking at the situation. We should provide "welfare" for all living species whether or not we believe they meet some threshold of privilege within a moral framework. I would argue that the same point could be made for why we should provide all humans welfare but somehow even that is a radical proposition in our conservative moralising society.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago> If humans aren't exceptional, do we acknowledge some sort of responsibility to provide for ants? Can they draw on welfare? This is a funny statement, because it is prefaced with a pretense of abandoning human exceptionalism, and then goes on to ask a question with implicit human exceptionalism; As if the ants need humans to take care of them even though they've been around for ~92 million years.