2 ms·
This is an interesting philosophical point that I think needs to be debated and established in law. Stealing is based on natural law of depriving someone of a t
by prepend 9y ago
This is an interesting philosophical point that I think needs to be debated and established in law. Stealing is based on natural law of depriving someone of a thing.
If I make a copy you may value that, but the copy doesn’t deprive you of anything. What if you whistle a tune and I think about it? I’ve deprived you of value you by paying nothing but thinking of your whistled tune over and over.
I don’t think it’s an accepted truth that just because someone creates something that they must be compensated. Especially if it costs money for society to enforce.
There’s tons of these mental exercises. If I add a TOS to this comment saying it’s worth $1k and by reading, you must pay; do you owe? Did you steal my value without my consent?
That’s why stealing is based on clear harm through depriving of property. And fair use was established to allow reasonable noncommercial use.
My biggest complaint is that IP maximalism is not something society as a whole agreed to. It seems that IP holders just decided for society.