3 ms·
Theory turns out to be nowhere close to sufficient for defining musicality. If you write a rule-based counterpoint solver - this has been done, with varying le
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
Theory turns out to be nowhere close to sufficient for defining musicality.
If you write a rule-based counterpoint solver - this has been done, with varying levels of success - you'll find that not only do you have to include an extra set of rules that aren't defined in any of the standard texts, but that the best output you can expect is musically mediocre.
The other approach is to create a patchwork of idiomatic cliches. That usually sounds more convincing, but still isn't musically interesting. And you can usually hear where the edges are glued together.
It turns out that there is no theory of "good" music. It literally doesn't exist. All the standard texts for each style - and it doesn't matter which style you pick, from Palestrina to pop - are very incomplete guides that rely on human intelligence and creativity to fill in the gaps.
Throwing neural networks at this problem doesn't make it any easier, because no one knows what to look for.
Features in artistic style transfer are easy to parse - shape, texture, and that's pretty much it, all packaged in a ready-to-go 2D distribution.
What are the musical features that define not just one possible musical style, but all of them, and would allow anyone to morph smoothly from Wagner to Taylor Swift to Balinese Gamelan to DubStep?
- kastnerkyle 9y agoOn rule based solvers - this is true if you simply stop at "be within the rules" and do strict constraint solving ala the coloring problem. I think there is potential to do something by blending all 3 (rules and constraint checking, rewards (perhaps based on idioms, riffs, and cliches), and some additional discriminator/critic/metric learning) if you narrow the criteria sufficiently (3 voice counterpoint in the style of Josquin de Prez for example). I would really be pleased to see something that can fill out "theory 101" counterpoint worksheets against a cantus firmus, even if the results would be poorly graded on "style" it is someplace to start getting feedback and collecting data to try and quantify that it factor for a narrow narrow subsection of the wide world of music.