3 ms·
Such discussions reveal more about the practice of philosophy than they do about consciousness. The putative intelligence of coffee tables is much more likely t
by mannykannot 9y ago
Such discussions reveal more about the practice of philosophy than they do about consciousness. The putative intelligence of coffee tables is much more likely to be raised as a counter-argument that it is offered as a plausible deduction.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoIf you have a means of determining whether or not something is conscious or merely responding to stimuli, by all means please share. If your argument is that there is no difference, then you have to start adding a bunch of other rules to justify how you determine the moral worth of one class of things that respond to stimuli from others, which is beyond the original scope of discussion, I think.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe response of a coffee table when one bumps into it can be explained by Newton's laws alone, so by Occam's razor we can exclude the notion that consciousness is also involved.