3 ms·
>crumbling walls, old textbooks and unqualified teachers From what I understand having worked with educators the 3rd is the only problem that really impacts re
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
>crumbling walls, old textbooks and unqualified teachers
From what I understand having worked with educators the 3rd is the only problem that really impacts results. You don't need a new textbook to study anything about physics math or history below the college level (with the possible exception of certain history topics but even that can be a lesson about history if you want it to be one). They also complained about how administrative decisions made for political reasons (e.g. "We need to be seen using our money on something quantifiable so you're getting new desks" or "We need to look up to date, force technology into your lessons, I don't care how") forced good teachers to perform at a lower level.
Which the article does get around to in the last sentence:
"Increasing the salaries of all teachers in a high-need school district won’t have as much of an impact as identifying high-performing teachers and increasing their salaries."
Good teachers teaching in bad schools get some experience on their resume and jump ship to somewhere better. Wash rinse repeat. If you're good at your job of course you work your way up to some rich district where resources aren't a problem.
- indubitable 9y ago> You don't need a new textbook to study anything about physics math or history below the college level In general this is true, but there are some major exceptions. Math is now taught vastly differently than when I learned it. The interesting thing is I did not learn it how it was taught, but internalized it differently and ended up competing in Math Olympiads / number sense and all that fun stuff very successfully. The very cool thing is that math textbooks now teach it in a way closely resembling to how I internalized it. For instance adding by powers of ten and the nearest ten. What is 29 + 77? You can just change that to 30 + 77 (remembering you now 'owe' one) which can then be changed to 30 + 70 + 7. So we end up with 107 - 1 which is 106. Lots of words, but it's a process that lets you solve most any problem more or less instantly, in your head. It also helps for understanding. Similarly for multiplication. What's 17 x 19? We can borrow 17 and change that to 17 x 20 which can be recognized as 17 x 2 x 10 which is clearly 340. Since we borrowed 17 we subtract it again using a basic strategy of 340 - 10 - 7 = 323. These sort of thought processes I think also help make math more fun since it's more of a puzzle that a grind. And the logical but abstract thinking involved in figuring out the quickest way to solve the problems also mirrors more the much more advanced mathematics that they will get into in college.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoWhile I agree to some extent the "old methods" of teaching still work. They may be slightly less efficient or effective but they do work. IMO having the same approach for every grade matters more than the approach itself. It's perfectly possible for a school to teach new math with old books. Books are just a source for example problems. There's no reason you can't skip around to fit your curriculum. What's your describing is having a good understanding of how to play tricks with numbers to make problems line up with your strengths and preferences. Teaching students that notation and "how" you attack a problem is arbitrary and they can do whatever they want with the numbers as long as they can clean up the mess and get the right answer is far more teacher dependent than curriculum structure dependent.
- bluedino 9y ago>> You don't need a new textbook to study anything about physics math or history below the college level You need iPads or Chromebooks or whatever they're pushing now