3 ms·
The correct approach to this is to sort the causes of death by number of incidents and then look at those causes with the highest number of incidents that also
by jandrewrogers 9y ago
The correct approach to this is to sort the causes of death by number of incidents and then look at those causes with the highest number of incidents that also have an anomalously high incident rate. This article studiously avoided that and was obviously an exercise in narrative construction.
The leading causes of child death in the US are somewhat uniquely American things like automobile accidents (Americans children spend much more time in cars) and drowning (the prevalence of swimming pools in many parts of the US is a well-known major risk factor for younger children). These things are endemic to the American landscape but few people are calling for a dramatic reduction in driving or swimming pools, even though these are among the most effective things you could do. Except for the first year of birth, where medical causes of death dominate, the rest of childhood is dominated by unintentional injury. Even during the peak years for homicide (the 20s), unintentional injuries still dominate the statistics.
The "teenagers 82 times more likely to die from gun homicide" is a meaningless number. The suicide rate in the US is average -- that they sometimes use guns as opposed to whatever they do in countries with higher rates of suicide and fewer guns is largely immaterial. The criminal activity that accounts for most gun homicide is a problem but it is also extremely concentrated in a few areas where the murder rate from all causes is anomalously high. The number of children that die merely from proximity to guns (accidents in the home, stray bullets during gang warfare, etc) is below the noise floor of many other causes. Guns per se, and there are at least as many guns as people in the US, have little to do with it.
The "Congress isn't funding kids health insurance" is disingenuous. Whether or not the funding changes are a good idea, for most analysts this has more to do with which bucket money comes from than whether or not there is access to healthcare. And in terms of child mortality, programs called out like CHIP have almost zero statistical impact generally, so it is unclear why they are relevant to the headline.
And as others have pointed out, infant mortality statistics (first year of birth) are not easy to compare across countries due to widely varying local standards. In a few parts of the US, such as the poor rural areas, the child mortality rates are legitimately quite high and geographically you are a long distance from good medical care. (I grew up in these areas -- there might be one doctor for all the communities spread across a wide geographic area, in large part because there is not a population dense enough to support more than that.) Not sure what to do about that though.
In short, this is uninformative clickbait.