3 ms·
I, and many others, don't care about "native". I've used Java applications and I will keep using them when they're useful. And regarding Java application speed
by oblio 9y ago
I, and many others, don't care about "native". I've used Java applications and I will keep using them when they're useful.
And regarding Java application speed, IntelliJ is pretty much comparable with the "native" Visual Studio.
About the looks, I'm using right now Vim (GTK), Skype (I don't even know what toolkit it's using, but I'm pretty sure it's not native), Eclipse (SWT - sort of native), Pidgin (GTK), Firefox (XUL? I'm not 100% sure after 57), Chrome (Skia?), etc.
Users don't really care as long as the applications are useful and developed properly. I've used many crap and butt-ugly "native" apps...
I don't even use Atom, but this vitriol annoys me.
- c_shu 9y agoTrue. jEdit is one of the best editors i have used. Not my default editor but i use it from time to time and install it everywhere.
- frik 9y agoSkype Win32 GUI is written in Delphi, remember Skype is old, used to be P2P, and got bought. Firefox 57 still uses XUL for the GUI, only XUL-addons got deactivated. The long term vision is to remove XUL and xpcom, from what I heard. They will have to rewrite the GUI completely in HTML5 (not just small parts like the settings page) like Vivaldi and Brave browser. DotNet UI isn't native either (WinForms, WCF, render their own custom controls). Office applications incl Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook aren't using the native UI either, they use a custom UI framework ever since, the first weird UI features were introduced with version 1995 with the italic window title, and 1997 had custom drawn elements all over the place. Visual Basic 4-6 had custom UI elements too. Windows XP software panel, part of the new control panel and help system use a custom UI too. They were fined by EU from not releasing the API documentation, giving them a leading edge. WinVista and onwards uses this custom drawn UI elements also in the copy-dialog.
- Khaine 9y agoLook, I was being a bit snarky. I think all apps that are not native, or don't follow system convention, create an impedance in that they don't always follow system conventions, or something about them doesn't work exactly as it would in a native app. This can cause confusion in users. The level of impedance depends on the user skill, experience and expectations. I know traditionally, Mac users have cared a lot about consistency and following the HIG, whereas Linux users are more likely to pick the application they prefer and not care whether it is GTK or QT. If you are someone who jumps between Windows, Linux and macOS using the same app then consistency in how the app works is a big gain for you, and then the impedance comes from the system you are using. I didn't mean to imply that Java apps are bad, far from it. Many java apps are good, they just stick out like the proverbial, and performance historically was not as good as native apps. There was a time when the go to torrent application was java based and Netbeans and Eclipse were the IDEs of choice. But they made trade-offs, and two of the key ones are performance and consistent UX with the operating system. For many applications / users, this is a fine trade off to make. But Atom made a similar trade off and then the developers have spent all this time and effort trying to improve performance, and that is what I was trying to be snarky at, that its obvious why performance will always lag.