4 ms·
It was found, along with all of the compounds that it contains, in western Egypt. Which, last I checked, is in the Solar System.
by taneq 9y ago
It was found, along with all of the compounds that it contains, in western Egypt. Which, last I checked, is in the Solar System.
- pavlov 9y agoNot according to Dan Quayle...
- simonh 9y agoThe idiom used in the title has a commonly well understood meaning in English. It basically means ‘here is a thing found in this context that is usually not found in that context and therefore probably came from somewhere else’. I can see that technically it’s incorrect, but pretty much any native English speaker would understand what is meant. The contention is that the stone is not composed of material from the cloud of dust and gas which formed our solar system, and therefore does not share that common origin with the other material in our solar system we are familiar with.
- cmroanirgo 9y agoIt's incorrect everywhere, except for click-bait purposes. A compound in Egypt clearly places it in the solar system.
- taneq 9y agoIt's been interesting watching the score on my original comment, which was (I thought) pretty clearly tongue-in-cheek. It first got quite a few upvotes, and now is well on its way to being buried - I'm not sure if that's just noise, or if it indicates changing demographics (with different attitudes towards flippancy) reading HN at different times of day. Anyway, yeah, it's not hard to figure out what the title meant.
- Gravityloss 9y agoUsually jokes don't get better by explaining, but this was an exception.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoInterestingly, everything found in the solar system is simulatneously both from the solar system AND is ultimately of extrasolar origins, since the solar system can from gas and dust from elsewhere when it was created.
- posterboy 9y agoYou need to start thinking in 4D