7 ms·
Two suns? No, it's a supernova drawn 6,000 years ago, say scientists
- dogma1138 9y agoThat or it’s: no no no this isn’t how you draw a sun.... (grabs chisel) Now this is how you draw a sun! The scientists themselves say that there isn’t anywhere near the amount of evidence needed to back the theory, this looks to be the same as the “Viking bracelet with Islam written on it” only later when someone one actually looks into it we find out that those characters weren’t even used in Arabic at the time when that bracelet was made.
- kristianc 9y ago> That or it’s: no no no this isn’t how you draw a sun.... (grabs chisel) Now this is how you draw a sun! Wait, they invented pair programming too?
- sametmax 9y agoAnnnd the razor win again.
- jschwartzi 9y agoWe could just search the sky for nebulae in the vicinity of the given constellations. That would provide evidence for the authors' theory.
- davidcuddeback 9y agoThe article says they attributed it to HB9, which I was able to find in a catalog of supernova remnants (warning, PDF: http://www.mrao.cam.ac.uk/surveys/snrs/table-IV-l.pdf http://www.mrao.cam.ac.uk/surveys/snrs/table-IV-l.pdf). On page 63, it gives the coordinates for the remnant to be 5h01m, +46°40', which would put it right around the brightest star in Auriga in this sky chart: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Perseus_IAU.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Perseus_IAU.svg. The catalog gives the size as 140x120 arcmin (2.3x2.0°), which is huge and probably means its very faint by now, which explains why it wouldn't be included in the sky chart by S&T. Curious if any astrophotographers have managed to capture it, I searched astrobin.com and found one photo: https://www.astrobin.com/229090/B/ https://www.astrobin.com/229090/B/ (edit: and a second: https://www.astrobin.com/73794/B/ https://www.astrobin.com/73794/B/). Edit: Looks like another designation for HB9 is Sh2-221, which turns up much more results in a search engine.
- dogma1138 9y agoTo which constellations? That’s the problem a hunter isn’t necessarily Orion and even Orion isn’t always depicted with a bow the sword and lion’s head is more common.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoI'm just "average Joe" but my sitting-at-a-keyboard thought was that the two suns suggested an interval of or passage of time.
- posterboy 9y agoDisclaimer: Of course I should have read the article first. On the photograph of the stone, both features look exactly the same - like suns. My second guess was a bird, because it looks a lot like the birds as used in heraldic art from ancient Egypt to modern Germany[1]. That doesn't mean the bird can't be a sign for a super nova at the same time. But the bird theory is strong, because of the Egyptian root "hr" [2], which variously means "above" and the sky god Horus, which is depicted in hieroglyphs with ... an eagle. Whether that's by direct import into asia or by rediscovery is probably mere speculation. But the term Proto-afro-asiatic alone is pretty suggestive already, nevermind that one of the reconstructed roots pertains to this word [3], although, as far as I can tell, to the other, allegedly separate but obviously not all too distantly related meanings of hr. [1] for example https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/da/Coat_of_arms_of_Germany.svg/85px-Coat_of_arms_of_Germany.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/da/Co... [2] at time of writing under "etymology 2" down the page https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E1%B8%A5r https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E1%B8%A5r although I'm not convinced there is much of a distinction to be made. [3] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Reconstruction:Proto-Afro-Asiatic/%C4%A7%C9%99r https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Reconstruction:Proto-Afro-Asi...
- plopilop 9y agoSoooo... This 6000 years old carving depicts two suns and the constellations of Orion and Taurus. Yet these constellations were invented by the Greeks, inspired from the Egyptians, and should be at most 4000 years old. I'm not an astrophysicist but I'm pretty sure something is off. Edit: reread the article and the stone comes from Himalaya. Yet the Indians, the Chinese and, well, pretty much every civilization had their own constellation map, that did not include either Orion or Taurus.
- Amezarak 9y agoOrion and Taurus have been recognized as constellations for much, much longer than 4000 years, and are not Egyptian in origin. The zodiac originates with the babylonians, but some/most of the constellations were derived from even older sources, as many as 10k+ years old, according to wiki.
- azurezyq 9y agoFor example, Orion's belt in ancient China astronomy/astrology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Stars_(Chinese_constellation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Stars_(Chinese_constella... It's regarded as three generals, nowhere close to something related to "hunters".
- kijin 9y agoAncient mythology might not draw a clear distinction between hunters and generals. They're both warriors.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt does quite well, the geometrical constellation in Chinese astronomy is just the belt, whilst Hindu Astronomy constructs a Deer's head out of the Orions, the stars that make the bow and the drawing arm are not part of the Hindu constellation, hence no hunter. Constellations are very very specific to the culture and the time.
- 9y ago
- kule 9y agoInteresting - I wonder if this also fits with the binary research going on: http://binaryresearchinstitute.com/bri/ http://binaryresearchinstitute.com/bri/
- grkvlt 9y agoNo?
- foo101 9y agoI am curious why this kind of speculation is taken seriously. I mean it's just a sketch on a stone without any further documentation. Could it not be that these were just two kids playing and drawing something random on a stone?
- perseusprime11 9y agoOccam Razor!
- majewsky 9y agoI would guess that when kids draw something, they would use an easier method than carving into a stone with tools, e.g. draw with their finger in the sand/dirt. All those easier methods of drawing that I could think of do not produce artifacts that survive for millenia.
- d0mine 9y agograffiti can survive for millennia http://www.pompeiana.org/resources/ancient/graffiti%20from%20pompeii.htm http://www.pompeiana.org/resources/ancient/graffiti%20from%2...
- katzgrau 9y agoHonestly, I thought the same. We're drawing some pretty far out assumptions about ancient celestial knowledge based on a drawing on a rock. I can't imagine that everything we find is going to have some deep or scientific meaning. My great great grandfather carved his new into a rock in northern NJ back in the 1800s and through all of the years and weather, it's still there, totally intact. True story.
- fragsworth 9y agoIf we find a close enough supernova that would have been daytime-visible and it lines up with about the time this stone drawing was made, we do have ourselves a very interesting coincidence, don't we?
- stephen82 9y agoHave they thought the possibility that the people who draw this tried to tell a story that it took them a whole day (two suns) to kill their prey?
- morganvachon 9y agoThat was my first thought as well; this is depicting a hunting mission and their concept of the progression of time. While a supernova visible from Earth in daytime is not impossible (when Betelgeuse finally dies we'll likely see it during the day; SN 1006 was seen during the day and at night was about as bright as a quarter moon), it certainly wouldn't be bright enough to be considered a "second sun" unless it was close enough to irradiate us with gamma rays that could do vast damage to existing life.
- starchand 9y agoWhat about the flying dog?
- qbrass 9y agoThe guy on the right was throwing dogs into the air for the archer to shoot, the two suns are actually dog gibs. How shooting dogs with a bow caused them to explode is still a mystery, but the deer was trying to save the last dog by attacking the archer.
- intrasight 9y agoThe article says "drawings". How many such drawings were found they did not say.
- bluedevil2k 9y agoScientifically, how do we know there was a super nova in 4000 BC? Is there still star remnants to observe? How do we trace that back to a date?
- Finnucane 9y agoFrom the article: "They settled on Supernova HB9, a star that exploded around 4,600BC." It is possible from observed supernova remnants to have a pretty good estimate of when the star exploded, esp. when it is relatively 'recent', astronomically speaking.
- giarc 9y agoWould a supernova actually be visible like that? The article says it would have been brighter than the moon and visible during the day? How long would it have been visible for?
- ddebernardy 9y agoNo idea for how long this one was exactly (apart from short), but something brighter than the moon and visible during daytime is fairly plausible. Some stuff out there can end up brighter than the sun, too: https://youtu.be/FJB7gbjiJKw?t=4m13s https://youtu.be/FJB7gbjiJKw?t=4m13s
- delbel 9y agoI've seen two in my lifetime one in 2008 and one in 2013, both at night. they lasted about 3-5 seconds and both were at night
- giarc 9y agoWere you looking through a telescope or were they visible to the naked eye?
- delbel 9y agovisible to the naked eye
- lutorm 9y agoThose are not supernovae, which brighten and fade over a span of weeks. (The energy input of core-collapse supernovae is the radioactive decay of Nickel-56 (half life 6 days) and Cobalt-56 (77 days).) Edit: those may have been Iridium flares that you saw.
- kiliantics 9y agoYes, if it happened within our galaxy. It has happened other times too, like this example from more recently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SN_1054 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SN_1054
- michaelsbradley 9y agoIt's much more likely, I think, to have been a drawing of a high-current z-pinch aurora. See the meticulous research of Dr. Anthony Peratt: Characteristics for the Occurrence of a High-Current, Z-Pinch Aurora as Recorded in Antiquity http://plasmauniverse.info/downloadsCosmo/PerattTPSv31-2003clr.pdf http://plasmauniverse.info/downloadsCosmo/PerattTPSv31-2003c... Characteristics for the Occurrence of a High-Current Z-Pinch Aurora as Recorded in Antiquity Part II: Directionality and Source http://plasmauniverse.info/downloadsCosmo/Peratt,et,al,TPSv35n4-2007.pdf http://plasmauniverse.info/downloadsCosmo/Peratt,et,al,TPSv3... More... http://plasmauniverse.info/NearEarth.html http://plasmauniverse.info/NearEarth.html
- pvaldes 9y agoNew theory. Those are clearly the car lights of a Winnebago. Or maybe a careful plan for a hunt trip lasting for two whole days. Who knows?.