8 ms·
Why dolphins are deep thinkers (2003)
- drKarl 9y agoSo long, and thanks for all the fish!
- okket 9y agoSee also discussion from 8 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=917128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=917128 (28 comments)
- delinka 9y agoSince we can't continue the older discussion, I'd like to comment here on the new thread. I'm discouraged by the topmost thread. In every case of (anecdotal?) experiments, the researcher was attempting repeatability with the same group of dolphins. I'd like to suggest that, given the 'negative' results and the predictions of dolphin keepers, repeatability should be attempted with a different group of dolphins.
- intrasight 9y agoDolphins are expensive. I assume it was due to insufficient research funding.
- astrodust 9y agoYeah, you can't just grab a dolphin from the sea, chuck them in a tank, and run experiments on them. You'll have to build a rapport with the dolphins to get any meaningful data. There should be better ways of studying them, like passive observation in the sea, or by making a mecha-dolphin that can follow them without interfering too much.
- gerbilly 9y agoThe other implication of testing this on "another group of dolphin" is the ethical dimension. Some people believe it's unethical to imprison dolphins in a small pool. I'd argue we certainly don't need to capture more dolphins to 'prove' they are intelligent. I also never understood why the barrier is set so high for giving any other species but ourselves credit for being intelligent.
- godelski 9y agoCould you not train wild dolphins though? It seems like they are quick learners, so even though you might not have as quick and easy access, it shouldn't take substantially longer. Assuming the dolphins want to play along.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> I also never understood why the barrier is set so high for giving any other species but ourselves credit for being intelligent. It is our tendency to believe things that we want to believe, and we want to believe things that align with our self interest. Since human moral understanding has come around to the concept that all human beings have inherent value, so therefore we can't just torture and kill them because they're not part of the tribe, we've had to keep inventing reasons why that same behavior is acceptable towards animals. If we were to decide that animals deserve the same moral considerations as ourselves, then we have to accept that many of the foundations for our comfortable lifestyles are immoral, and if we did that we'd have to consider giving them up.
- flavor8 9y ago> we'd have to consider giving them up. Just this week there's been a round of articles on the scientific consensus that fish feel pain. Read https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/fish-feel-pain-180967764/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/fish-feel-pain..., for example, and see if the final third of the article leaves you comfortable about eating fish. I've always thought the "catch and release" practice (and the accompanying justification that fish don't feel pain, so that it's harmless sportsmanlike fun) to be bewilderingly shallow thinking - but despite that fish is a much more significant part of my diet than avian or mammal meat. I'm also deeply hypocritical about mammal meat eating; every time I go to an Indian restaurant (but never otherwise) for example, I'll order lamb, just because it's tastier than saag or tofu. As another example, I don't eat pork, with the notable exception of cured meats, which are also too damned tasty. I probably could go wholesale vegan, especially with some of the better fake-meat protein sources, and yet perhaps I don't want to enough, and/or I enjoy eating meat a few times a month too much to do so. That's hardly a well justified moral position to take, and yet I suspect it's not uncommon. [Also, the dividing line between animals and plants - while of course clearly defined - may be softer than we've assumed. (https://www.pri.org/stories/2014-01-09/new-research-plant-intelligence-may-forever-change-how-you-think-about-plants https://www.pri.org/stories/2014-01-09/new-research-plant-in...). In 25 years will we talking about eating lab grown food only instead of farmed plants?] I suspect our moral systems are still reeling from 1000+ years of Christianity completely dominating our societal thinking - even if your parents weren't religious, or theirs, their inherited "firmware" (societal norms picked up in early years of learning) probably has a lot of irrationally derived foundations. Our attempts at scientific derived moral systems haven't had particularly great results so far, but perhaps we'll get there in time.
- cetalingua 9y agoOne of the most fascinating experiments was done by Bastian in 1960s (our first podcast will be about it once the site goes live). It remains highly controversial but has also been replicated by others. In 2016 one Russian scientist claimed to replicate it and it resulted in huge storm and controversy. Basically it involved 2 dolphins separated visually but not acoustically. One dolphin was shown what action the second dolphins should perform so both can get a fish. It appeared that dolphins did communicate and performed above the chance level.
- hencq 9y agoA long time ago I came across this question [1] (probably through Hackernews): "What do you believe is true even though you cannot prove it." I found the question hugely fascinating. For me one answer is that some attributes which we think of as uniquely human, such as intelligence or consciousness, aren't actually so unique. I believe at least many mammals and possibly other animals (birds? some fish?) have some form of (perhaps basic) intelligence. Of course there is always a big risk in anthropomorphizing behavior and there are huge challenges in designing replicable experiments. However, ultimately humans are just apes so it shouldn't be too surprising if some of our human attributes actually evolved much earlier. In any case I find research like that mentioned in the article immensely interesting. There is still so much we can learn on this front. [1] https://www.edge.org/annual-question/what-do-you-believe-is-true-even-though-you-cannot-prove-it https://www.edge.org/annual-question/what-do-you-believe-is-...
- jacquesm 9y agoHumans are pretty good at pretending other humans aren't human, it should be no surprise that we find it easy to ignore traits that we consider human in other species.
- andai 9y agoSavage
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoYou can go deeper than this. Attempt to define "intelligence" in any philosophically meaningful way and you might find that it isn't clear that a coffee table isn't intelligent on some level, or alternatively that a human being isn't just a sufficiently complicated coffee table. "Consciousness", in the philosophical meaning, is even more interesting because it is entirely non-empirical; it can't be measured in any objective sense. Any deeper implications of this are left as an exercise for the reader.
- allenz 9y agoI don't think that there is any philosophical difficulty in distinguishing an animal from a coffee table. Intelligence is a broad concept which can be defined or measured in several ways. One definition is the ability to act upon the environment to achieve one's goals. In contrast, there is an epistemic problem about whether other minds exist: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/other-minds/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/other-minds/
- cobbzilla 9y agoFrom an economic perspective: "The dolphins are not only gaming the system they are saving and using a capital structure to increase total output." [1] [1] http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/01/dolphin-capital-theory.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/01/dol...
- santoshalper 9y agoSo they are as smart as finance guys now. One day, they might aspire to be as smart as engineers.
- ncmncm 9y agoNot to take anything away from cetaceans, but this article slights elephants and crows. Both recognize themselves in mirrors, and invent tools.
- fenwick67 9y agoPigeons do this too, believe it or not. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/212/4495/695 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/212/4495/695
- fallingfrog 9y agoLet's reverse the question. It's very enticing to believe that dolphins might be sentient. But what's the evidence to the contrary? There must be some.
- cetalingua 9y agoWell, they seem to not understand that they can jump over the net and escape the capture. They (wild cetaceans especially) are not very interested in establishing contact with another sentient species ( us). In all experiments on non-human intelligence, only Alex, the grey parrot, actually asked the question. Having said that, we need to realize that we still do not have sufficient knowledge to argue either way. We are dealing with species who rely on sound more than humans ever would. We still do not fully understand what is going on there, echolocation has been studied for 60 years, last year new echolocation clicks types were discovered. Do not also forget that our knowledge is mostly about bottlenose dolphins, but there are many other species. Last year it was also reported that humble harbor porpoises are not as asocial as they thought to be, and in fact, communicate with each other via pulsed signals produced at higher frequencies not audible to their predators.
- earenndil 9y ago> In all experiments on non-human intelligence, only Alex, the grey parrot, actually asked the question Is it possible that they asked questions of each other, in their own tongue, but did not know how to ask humans questions?
- fallingfrog 9y agoI suppose that if the situation were reversed and I was in a cage surrounded by dolphins, I'd probably spend most of my time trying to communicate, imitating the sounds they made, trying to establish vocabulary.. and if I worked out that I wouldn't be punished, I'd probably refuse to perform tricks until they reciprocated. So, if they are intelligent they're very different behaviorally from us.
- cetalingua 9y agoDolphins are truly fascinating creatures. They have extremely sophisticated brain architecture that definitely supports at least some degree of sentience. Some species like humpback whales, orcas (but curiously not Tursiops) have von Economo neurons (VENs)that have been connected to vocal learning, language and even theory of mind.Cetacean cortical surface area is quite large (https://twitter.com/Cetalingua/status/932631255165886464?ref_src=twcamp%5Eshare%7Ctwsrc%5Em5%7Ctwgr%5Eemail%7Ctwcon%5E7046%7Ctwterm%5E0 https://twitter.com/Cetalingua/status/932631255165886464?ref... and brain architecture in general is amazing, like visual cortex being next to the auditory cortex (https://twitter.com/Cetalingua/status/901590689091387393?ref_src=twcamp%5Eshare%7Ctwsrc%5Em5%7Ctwgr%5Eemail%7Ctwcon%5E7046%7Ctwterm%5E0 https://twitter.com/Cetalingua/status/901590689091387393?ref...) Add to that conscious breathing, unihemispheric sleep, cognitive preparation and fully conscious control of cardiovascular system, conscious planning and preparation for dives. Some species (pygmy sperm whales) have magnetite crystals in their brains and probably have some sort of magnetoreception for navigation, and the list goes on and on. Our challenge is to make sense of it all, and how can we even do it, our auditory cortex is nowhere near our visual cortex.
- gech 9y agoAt what point in embryonic development are these magnetite crystals formed, and how? Amazing
- cetalingua 9y agoIn pygmy sperm whales, magnetite crystals appear to be concentrated in the rostroventral dura, but we know next to nothing about how they function or are used, let alone about how they are being formed.
- debt 9y agoI feel bad for Dolphins. They evolved from land animals and seemingly got much smarter underwater; only by the time their brains came online, they were, like, stuck underwater. And then us land mammals evolved to hunt them and accidentally destroy the oceans. That sucks. They seem like a really chill species that we seem to have a lot in common with. They have language and stuff.
- PinkMilkshake 9y agoI recommend the latest episode of Sam Harris' podcast Waking Up. It's a 3 hour discussion about consciousness between him and Anil Seth, it's quite good and probably warrants multiple playbacks.
- vadimberman 9y agoMore examples of cetacean intelligence here in the last section: https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/31/reverse-engineering-the-universal-translator/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/31/reverse-engineering-the-un... Apparently, dolphins have an equivalent of names and the entropy of their communication is similar to that of the human speech.
- msiyer 9y agoAny species that has survived for a considerable period has to be intelligent.