7 ms·
> Imagine we had a system that automatically rewarded cyclists, or people who just take a cold shower--any of the millions of small things--for curbing pollutio
by tzs 9y ago
> Imagine we had a system that automatically rewarded cyclists, or people who just take a cold shower--any of the millions of small things--for curbing pollution.
Several prominent conservative Republicans proposed about a year ago a system that would do that [1]. They were James Baker (Secretary of the Treasury under Reagan, Secretary of State under GHW Bush), Martin Feldstein (chairman of Reagan's Council of Economic Advisors), George Shultz (Secretary of State under Reagan), Henry Paulson, (GW Bush's Treasury Secretary), and N. Gregory Mankiw (chairman GW Bush's Council of Economic Advisers), and others.
Their proposal was for a revenue-neutral carbon tax starting at $40 per ton. It would be collected at the source (such as at oil refineries), and the money collected would be returned to to the taxpayers. They estimated that would be about $2000 back to a family of four.
If the rate is set right, it would be break even for a person who is carbon neutral. The tax would raise the prices on things they buy and use that produce carbon, but their share of the distribution should be about the same amount.
[1] http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/02/group-prominent-republicans-just-launched-longshot-bid-carbon-tax http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/02/group-prominent-repub...
- wallace_f 9y agoDismissing political affiliations I think people can agree this would be good public policy in the sense that it increases human welfare (for example, Mankiw influenced my economics education positively, even if I do dislike some of his politics. Another: Musk also supports a carbon tax, but is not politically affiliated with the GOP).
- stretchwithme 9y agoTaxing what you don't want makes sense if the market cannot solve a problem. It's more flexible than an outright ban, as it's easier to make trade offs. Cap and trade can also work.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoIf the rate is set right, it would be break even for a person who is carbon neutral. That doesn't sound right. Wouldn't it depend on using the average amount of carbon? If you're above average you pay out more than you get back, if you're below average you get more than you pay. Probably depends on the exact way the money is returned. I don't know about this particular scheme, but some use the proceeds to offset regressive taxes, making the scheme progressive overall.