You are incorrect, sir. The judge decides all questions of law, and the jury may not do so. That is why juries are given jury instructions by the judge. Jury nu

You are incorrect, sir. The judge decides all questions of law, and the jury may not do so. That is why juries are given jury instructions by the judge. Jury nullification in a criminal case is an oddity, but that is not a decision about the law (and is not binding in future cases), nor is it applicable in the civil context we are discussing.