4 ms·
> Microsoft, for marketing purposes If Microsoft does something in the interest of their users it is suddenly "for marketing purposes"? > While I applaud the
by Fnoord 9y ago
> Microsoft, for marketing purposes
If Microsoft does something in the interest of their users it is suddenly "for marketing purposes"?
> While I applaud the goal of assuming people don't want tracking
Of course people don't want tracking. I'm not going to argue everyone agrees with GDPR, but that sets the trend further.
> Because many users showing DNT settings had not explicitly meant to do so.
Just because someone doesn't explicitly agree with something, doesn't mean they disagree with that.
- manigandham 9y agoThe correct answer is giving the user choice and education. Unilaterally choosing for them (either pro or con) by any large company is almost always worse.
- Fnoord 9y agoWho wants to get asked a bunch of annoying questions every time they fire up an OS or piece of software? Nobody. Software should pick sane default settings which are in the interest of its users. Not everyone is informed well enough to make an informed choice, and tracking is not in the interest of the user anyway, so the default being blocking (DNT) is sane. Obviously it isn't in the interest of Google, and Chrome serves Google first, and its users secondary. Education is the long term solution to just about anything and I'm all for that (I can recommend a visit to Berlin-Hohenschoenhausen Memorial [1]) but the truth is that some people are just not going to be interested in certain topics. Case in point: back in the days, everyone received snail mail spam. At some point, civilians were able to put a standardized sticker on their postbox saying yes/no or no/no (one being more strict than the other). They'd need to pick such sticker up at the city council. Just now in start of 2018, if you live in Amsterdam, you need a yes/yes sticker to receive spam. Is that wrong as well? Even though the spam is bad for the environment (goes to bin right away), we're living in a digital age, and postboxes in flats and such pile up gigantically? Should we've educated people better instead of making this the default? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin-Hohensch%C3%B6nhausen_Memorial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin-Hohensch%C3%B6nhausen_M...
- quadrangle 9y agoSo, users should decide every parameter before they use any technology? Where does it end?
- burgerdev 9y agoWith software that respects the users' freedoms? With users empowered to make the tradeoffs they prefer regarding privacy?
- mynameisvlad 9y agoNo, more realistically it results in the device being thrown out for one that doesn't ask the user a million questions at startup. Sane defaults should be used because they enhance the user experience tremendously. Nobody buys a gadget for its setup, they buy it to use it, and delaying the user from that end goal is not going to do anything but annoy the end user and ultimately harm the manufacturer's bottom lines.
- belorn 9y agoI suspect there is more people in the world that have built their own cpu and hardware from scratch than there is people that operate computers where they have made informed decision about every parameter for every default variable on all software that they use. Even if we limit our self to just security defaults, what linux system don't have default ulimits? There is tradeoffs naturally in every number, but I would assume even linux from scratch users don't need to explicitly set each and every number. If a user prefer making different tradeoffs they can opt-in to make changes, but even a operative system that is designed to be built by hand by the user carries with it some defaults.
- lurr 9y ago12 hour setup times and a 600 page manual should be standard, obviously.
- nteu09is34 9y agoYou mean like the advertising companies do with tracking you? The hypocrisy here is thick.
- treve 9y agoEven though it might in theory have been the best default for end-users, in practice they made DNT fail as a result because advertisers wanted users to make an explicit choice instead of getting opted out by default. It's easy to blame the advertisers here, and sure.. you can argue that in this scenario they were the 'more evil' ones, but had Microsoft not made this choice, we ultimately could have ended up with a respected DNT header, which later on could have become a default anyway. So I don't disagree that the decision might have come from a good place, but the end-result was not hard to predict and was ultimately not in the interest of users. It was incredibly dumb.
- Fnoord 9y agoI put my money on that being an excuse and ultimately a fallacy by the advertisers. There are a lot of things in life which you don't get to choose, and only get informed about when you look into them. There's much worse examples which are far more nefarious for end users. EULAs come to mind!! Contracts in general as well because they're so complex, you need a lawyer(bot) to understand.
- hobs 9y agoThis is a completely an excuse - advertisers would have looked to anything to disable and ignore DNT - "oh, not enough users use it for us to justify enabling it" etc. The end result of DNT was never going to be "advertisers were going to less ruthlessly track you" - that's a fantasy.
- belorn 9y agoThe advertisers chosen to ignore DNT. It don't matter if they decided to do so because they disliked the concept of DNT or if they did so because the OS manufactorers decided to change the opt-in to opt-out. The decision was made solely by the advertisers, and there the blame resides. If Microsoft had not made this choice then the advertisers could still have made the same decision. We will never know, and it doesn't really matter. Its a "what if" situation, and like many such "what if"s we are simply speculating about motives while not looking at the billions of dollar worth of obvious reasons why the advertisers wanted to ignore DNT.
- lurr 9y ago
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoWell, to be clear, this was done during the height of Microsoft's "Scroogled" campaign. This was an intended to be very visible way to claim to be better at respecting privacy than Google. I would agree that Microsoft is much better at respecting privacy than Google, though this change was poorly considered and led to a bad result (i.e. DNT failing as a marker of explicit user intent). I probably have a much more favorable view of Microsoft than the average here, and my comment history contains a storied history of me pointing out how Google has cast anticompetitive and profit-motivated decisions as "good for users". ;)
- craftyguy 9y ago> If Microsoft does something in the interest of their users it is suddenly "for marketing purposes"? Yes, it's for marketing purposes, because if there were any sincerity about it then they would not also be tacking their users at the same time they enabled DNT. They don't like competition.
- us0r 9y ago> If Microsoft does something in the interest of their users it is suddenly "for marketing purposes"? If Microsoft gave a shit about its users it wouldn't put key loggers in its products, explicitly state that spell check in your word documents is being done in the "cloud" and we are reading it, let you disable stupid cortona who is slurping up hell knows what, etc. They are so obsessed with tracking you that if you surf their sites long enough you end up with a HTTP 400 - Bad Request (Request header too long) error message. I just pulled up MSDN look at the scroll bar on the right https://i.imgur.com/wlYqVIo.png https://i.imgur.com/wlYqVIo.png. No they don't care about users.
- Fnoord 9y ago> If Microsoft gave a shit about its users [...] While I like that you're mentioning examples and welcome such, it is never this black-and-white. All these big corps do things which aren't in the best interest of the general public, or in the best interest of their users. Microsoft is no exception to that (I am well aware of the Halloween documents and hated that company to no ends), but 1) neither are Google and Facebook 2) they've broadened from a proprietary software company. The open source community seemed to be pretty happy with pro-FOSS companies such as Google and Facebook getting more popular and powerful. Free as in beer seems like a great deal, but you're always paying somehow. In this case you pay with your privacy. Companies like Google and Facebook do a lot of Good Things (tm) for the FOSS community, but in this specific case they're on the bad side of the moral compass because it hurts a major source of their income.
- cpeterso 9y agoApache countered Microsoft's DNT=1 default by ignoring the DNT header for IE10 users. Advertisers could have similarly ignored Microsoft and honored non-IE users' DNT headers. https://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10-do-not-track-setting/ https://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10...
- lurr 9y agoWow, fuck apache.
- user5994461 9y ago"Roy Fielding, an author of the Do Not Track (DNT) standard and principal scientist at Adobe Systems, wrote a patch for Apache" Nothing to do with apache whatsoever.
- iand 9y agoHopefully that was sarcasm and you knew that Roy Fielding co-wrote the first version of Apache
- user5994461 9y agoThe first version was in 1993, he switched to working for advertisers since.
- lurr 9y agoYeah, because Microsoft is incapable of doing something for good reasons obviously. Don't you dare give the ad companies shit for ignoring DNT though.
- GuB-42 9y agoThe entire point of DNT is to relay an explicit user decision to a website. It has no other meaning. While there is a candidate recommendation, in reality, the decision about what to do with it is entirely up to the website. Faking it like Microsoft does makes DNT loses its meaning entirely. Note that there are 3 values to DNT: null (no explicit decision), 1 (do not track), 0 (track).
- belorn 9y agoIf you continue to use a product then you are giving explicit consent according to multiple lawyers, including I think the very companies that ignores the DNT header. If it is considered by them as good enough to legally bind someone to a contract, surely they don't claim that the consent was given without a explicit decision by the user. When it came to the cookie law those companies had one view in regard to defaults. With the DNT header, the opposite view.
- lozenge 9y agoIt was clear to everyone at the time that Dnt had to be an explicit opt in and advertisers would ignore it if it was set by default. Microsoft persisted and therefore undermined the spec. Here's an article from the time: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/08/microsoft-sticks-to-its-guns-keeps-do-not-track-on-by-default-in-ie10/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/08/micro...
- flukus 9y agoSo advertisers only agreed to it because they thought it wouldn't work?