6 ms·
The Marriott Family's Civil War
- tomohawk 9y agoWhat's with the bouncing arrow?
- dexterdog 9y agoStrictly religious family turning its back on the child who sees the belief as nonsense. It's an old story.
- simula67 9y agoA reverse case : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_J._Murray https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_J._Murray > William J. Murray III was born in Ohio in 1946, the son of William J. Murray Jr. and Madalyn Murray O'Hair, an atheist activist > Murray became a Christian in 1980. Learning of his conversion, his mother commented: "One could call this a postnatal abortion on the part of a mother, I guess; I repudiate him entirely and completely for now and all times. He is beyond human forgiveness."
- dexterdog 9y agoThat is equally crappy. To me the great crime of most religions (those that are thought of traditionally as religions as well as just philosophies) is that they brainwash the young in the most deceitful manners who become members by the sheer chance that they were born to believers.
- jessaustin 9y agoThat isn't the reverse; it's just the same thing happening to someone else.
- cookiecaper 9y agoAbsolutely not what the article portrays. From my reading, it sounds like John's indiscretions, including stints in rehab for drug abuse, are tolerated (if not outright ignored) until he visits his parents to say he's getting a divorce. His parents then cut him off from the bulk of the family assets, but it sounds like his family is still in communication with him and tries to remain on good terms. Angry that his decision to indulge himself in a mid-life crisis and leave his wife and children cost him a lot of money, he is now filing a lawsuit claiming to be a victim. I doubt John actually expects this lawsuit to go anywhere, as the article doesn't seem to discuss any actual legal claim. It's probably more just about airing dirty laundry if they won't let him back in the bank account. And to their credit, it appears the Marriotts are holding their ground. As far as I'm concerned this article portrays 100% commendable behavior from the Marriott family (and religion is mentioned only in passing). If any of my children come and tell me that they're abandoning their spouse and children because they "fell in love with someone else", I hope that I can have similar resolve to cut off their access to anything substantial, because that is not OK, and a good parent will not pretend like it is. Abandoning your family is not an acceptable course of conduct, no matter how many times you cry because your dad picked someone else to become CEO, which is literally the story here.
- dcole2929 9y agoLeaving an apparently loveless marriage and getting a divorce doesn't mean abandoning your family. Most people who get divorced are still involved in their kids lives. My parents got divorced when I was 10 and my family was much happier for it. I don't feel any particular way about this man or his situation, but this idea that couples need to stay together for the kids or because that's what they promised 25 years ago is crazy. Not to mention that if this guy is 50 some years old his kids are likely adults by now or close enough.
- cookiecaper 9y ago> this idea that couples need to stay together for the kids or because that's what they promised 25 years ago is crazy. The entire concept of marriage is that you will "stay together ... because that's what you promised xx years ago". So it's definitely not crazy, though the conception of marriage as a significant or binding thing has lost popular appeal over the years. And that only means that the Marriotts deserve more admiration for their willingness to stick up for stable marriages and responsible fathers despite the peanut gallery giving them flak. There are times that divorce is justified, yes. But "I just don't love him/her anymore" is 1000% not one of them, and it's a relief to see people like the Marriotts unwilling to indulge their son's playboy fantasies.
- zajd 9y agoAm I supposed to feel bad for the tax evading repeat substance abuser who's still sitting on 8 figures but didn't get to cash in on the nepotism fueling his family's fortune? Everyone involved in this story sounds like a horrible person.
- erric 9y agoI can relate to being raised in the same wacky religion, and it does drive people to substance abuse, mental health issues, and inter-family rifts. From the purely human part, the Guys has lost his wife and kids and possibly his whole social circle. That can be very damaging, even to very well of people.
- saiya-jin 9y agoAgreed, very first world problems. Systematic substance abuser (I presume cocaine & prescription meds as is fashionable in these circles) and long-term alcoholic who cheats on his wife and leaves her, while still having at least tens of millions to fall back on. Poor guy resting out in Chamonix... I can understand that his childhood was much stricter than average, but so were of many others without mega wealth and they didn't ended up as pathetic amoral wrecks. And of course he wants to milk his family for more.
- narrator 9y agoRich people have four things that go wrong in their lives: Drugs, divorce, very bad investments and entourages. Entourages being ever larger numbers of people hanging on to them and getting their expenses paid for just being friends. Everything else pretty much takes care of itself and there are many trust funders who just live lives of little accomplishment and relative obscurity. This guy had most of those things go wrong, but he still made it out, the damage being he lost a zero or two from his wealth.
- fao_ 9y ago> Entourages being ever larger numbers of people hanging on to them and getting their expenses paid for just being friends. Given the size of the wealth, I don't know why these people get a negative connotation. It's the job of those with wealth to share with those who don't have. Moreso if it's inherited.
- AskewEgret 9y agoThis reminds me of how the family that owned the Hyatt hotels broke apart. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/05/andrews200305 https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/05/andrews200305
- walshemj 9y agoIts quite common for family owned firms to break up in this way most don't go beyond 3 generations.
- ww520 9y agoHope they don't screw up the SPG program over this.
- jessaustin 9y agoThe worst thing a father can do to a son without getting arrested, is to deprive him of his own name. It isn't as though "John Willard" is such a wonderful moniker that it must be inflicted upon the third and fourth generations.
- dumbfounder 9y agoYour dad was a dick. So what? That doesn't entitle you to his money. And guess what, you're a dick too.
- sctb 9y agoPlease comment civilly and substantively or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Osiris 9y agoAs a Mormon myself, I can sympathize with the son's anxiety over not meeting expectations. Religion, in general, is about helping individuals become "better" people. In the case of Christianity (including Mormonism), this comes down to encouraging the development of attributes like love, compassion, empathy, hope, virtue, integrity, honesty, knowledge, patience, humility, etc. One way to do that is to develop rules (or commandments) to help people identify actions that would help to develop those attributes. People can get so caught up in the "rules" that they miss the whole point, which is really just trying to be a better person. This causes people to judge others based on their adherence (or lack thereof) to the rules. Rather, what the religion is really trying to get us to do is to lift one another up because no one is perfect. The quote "rather he come home in a pine box than engage in premarital sex" is an example of this problem. You cannot help someone be better if you are always pushing them down. I have family members that don't practice the religion anymore, but no one in the family has any less love for them.
- erric 9y ago>Religion, in general, is about helping individuals become "better" people. Humans don’t need a religion to become better. Religions exist only to demand and collect money and to grow ever larger. >this comes down to encouraging the development of attributes like love, compassion, empathy, hope, virtue, integrity, honesty, knowledge, patience, humility, Religion has no monopoly in these attributes, and indeed isn’t the source of them either.