3 ms·
I don't really understand how this is supposed to help. If I'm an advertiser/tracker/etc, what keeps me from adding the policy file to my website - so adblock,
by xg15 9y ago
I don't really understand how this is supposed to help. If I'm an advertiser/tracker/etc, what keeps me from adding the policy file to my website - so adblock, duckduckgo etc. are happy - and then blatantly violating it?
The "policy" doesn't seem to be legally binding in any way, there is no way to even detect violations and the EFF itself writes that it can't enforce it:
> Posting the dnt-policy.txt file makes a promise to the users who interact with their domain. We believe it would be a false and misleading trade practice to post the policy without the intent to comply in good faith. However, EFF is not in a position to enforce this promise or monitor compliance. [1]
So what's the point?
[1] https://www.eff.org/dnt-policy#faq-What-does-the-dnt-policy.txt-promise-mean https://www.eff.org/dnt-policy#faq-What-does-the-dnt-policy....?
- greglindahl 9y agoIf you're a US company and you lie to your customers about what your policies are, the FTC may well sue you. They do it all of the time over privacy policies.
- lotu 9y agoThis is trying to create a way for publisher to say, "I don't want to track users" and have it be understood by software. Right now no such system exists. You could see organizations doing testing to see if tracking happens but they need to know what the publisher say they will or won't do. It still might not get adoption but it isn't nothing.
- eli 9y agoThis is basically what happened to P3P, an earlier attempt to regulate privacy rules with a machine-readable policy. Microsoft set IE to reject cookies by default if a site didn't have 1) a P3P header that 2) met certain requirements. It wasn't very well thought out and, in practice, required a bunch of sites to create a bogus P3P header or core functionality like "logging in" was broken for many IE users.