5 ms·
What I don't get is that the US seems to be trying to push its political system to the absolute limit. Since I came to the US there is this constant push for im
by maxxxxx 9y ago
What I don't get is that the US seems to be trying to push its political system to the absolute limit. Since I came to the US there is this constant push for impeaching the sitting president, disputing election results, extreme gerrymandering and all the other nonsense going on. This is the climate that breeds a strongman dictator that "cleans up" all the mess.
Has it always been that way and will get worked out or is the US determined to destroy its institutions?
- nkozyra 9y agoIn theory much of the country is designed to be malleable and fault-tolerant. Checks and balances exist to prevent one branch from overpowering others, but the malleable nature of the country means there are mechanisms to push the dial of what powers each branch has. So the reality is at present a strongman wouldn't have the mechanisms to clean up the mess. Gridlock is - in a way - by design.
- gmiller123456 9y agoThis is really just the effect of the population (and by effect politicians) becoming more polarized. There has been a definite trend towards parties becoming more and more polarized ever since the end of WW II [1]. [1] https://legacy.voteview.com/political_polarization_2015.htm https://legacy.voteview.com/political_polarization_2015.htm
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat's kind of expected over time in a stable two-party system; the periods of declining polarization are actually the periods just before partisan realignments, where the divides underlying old coalitions are losing salience, so the major parties are less coherent. After WWII (or, really, FDR's first campaign) the party system entered a long realignment along what became the modern American left/right axis which was basically completed in the early 1990s. Which is why polarization increased throughout the post-WWII period, but also why it was turbocharged from the Clinton era on.
- lurr 9y agoNo. It's the republicans for the last couple decades. Institutionally things are starting to break down because of a combination of poor design and poor implementation. But there are so very many people who will argue that the current system is a feature not a bug.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoNo, it's both sides for the last three or four decades. The Democrats were unhappy with Reagan and Bush Sr. The Republicans were deeply unhappy with Clinton. The Democrats were on the border of being deranged by Bush Jr. The Republicans were deranged with Obama. Now the Democrats are absolutely insane about Trump. (I'll give you that Trump makes it easier than any of his predecessors. Still, this has been growing since 1980, on both sides.)
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt wasn't in the US back then but from Germany it looked like they lost their minds during the Clinton years. The Levinksy thing was just ridiculous.
- lurr 9y agoWell that was brought about because of a shift in republican politics that won them congress, but has lead them down a path to being a terrible party. Notice how people don't defend republican decisions, they just immediately go "BUT BOTH SIDES". When your only defense is whataboutism, maybe you need to stop and think for a bit.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI wasn't defending. When you're only attacking one side, maybe you need to stop and think for a bit.
- lurr 9y ago
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Has it always been that way Well, let's analyze each of your questions in turn. > Since I came to the US there is this constant push for impeaching the sitting president When did you come to the USA? There was a constant push to impeach Obama. There was a constant push to impeach Bush. The was a constant push to impeach Clinton. Clinton was elected in 1993, so there are a lot of adult Americans who were born in the USA and who can also say that "since I came to the US (aka was born), there has been this constant push for impeaching the sitting president". > extreme gerrymandering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering#Etymology > and all the other nonsense Congress seems to be more dysfunctional now than it was in the 80's and 90's. But there have been worse eras, too. At least the congressmen who've been shot lately weren't shot by other congressmen in duels, for example... :-\
- george3383 9y ago>[There is a constant push to impeach Trump.] There was a constant push to impeach Obama. There was a constant push to impeach Bush. The was a constant push to impeach Clinton. Is this considered normal? If so, why? It's like results of an election aren't final. A candidate wins yet people try to have him kicked out. :/
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Is this considered normal? I don't know if it is considered normal, but it is normal. > A candidate wins yet people try to have him kicked out. Impeachment is in the constitution for a reason. Winning an election is not a sufficient condition for maintaining a public office. So on face, there's nothing actually wrong with trying to use a constitutional tool to kick out an elected official. That said, > If so, why? You're kind of asking for a retrial of very polarizing figures from recent political history, a dangerous topic on hn, and I suppose that's the reason for the downvotes. I'm trying, here, to give an honest and historically accurate answer. Obama and Bush impeachment advocates were mostly unjustifiable partisans, in the sense that there were never serious, constitutionally plausible, and widely-believed-to-be-true justifications for impeachment. That's probably why neither person was ever actually impeached. Consider this "the system working mostly as intended" Clinton was justifiable, at least at one point in time, although we could fairly ask whether the same accusations would result in an impeachment today. Again, consider this "the system working as intended" Trump is an open case, and these things are hard to judge without the benefit of hindsight. But there are at least serious, plausible accusations of impeachable conduct. We'll see if those accusations are true, I guess. However, you'll note that in all of these cases except for Clinton, it was a minority of elected representatives from the opposition party calling for an actual impeachment. The vast majority of opposition representatives did always call for investigations. But that's a checks-and-balances system working as intended IMO.