3 ms·
"In the shorter term, the technology would enable scenarios like someone asking the TV what is in the refrigerator, then having it display a recipe then send th
by jerf 9y ago
"In the shorter term, the technology would enable scenarios like someone asking the TV what is in the refrigerator, then having it display a recipe then send that recipe to the stove."
From now on, I will interpret this being the first idea floated as the use for some IoT tech as "we have no f'ing clue what we're going to use this for".
Thirty years ago, this problem was perhaps unsolved. Now it's solved in at least two ways, with tablets and voice interactions, and those are better.
Sorry, Sony, Samsung, etc, there is no way my TV, which is in the ENTIRELY WRONG ROOM, is going to wedge its way into my recipe workflow, and if that is the best idea you have, as evidenced by it being the first idea mentioned in this article... you have no ideas. Note how even in the example I quote above, WTF is the TV doing in that interaction flow in the first place? What I should be "asking" what is in the fridge is my cell phone, and by extension since they share OSes, optionally a tablet.
(The core problem here is that Smart TVs are now mature. Ignoring surveillance and privacy issues, what we need are just more responsive UIs, and preferably, some sort of plan for how we're going to maintain these TVs in the future because especially at the high end these things are too expensive to be treated like cell phones that don't get updates after a year and a half. But that sure doesn't win any CES awards.)
- dfee 9y agoI just want the display, not the device. More and more it’s like Goodyear wants to sell me a car with the tires.
- Zenst 9y agoPrecisely that, be great if they were moremodular to a standard, but then, that's what PC's are, just not at the lego level for the common consumer. Then consumers wonder why due to software support obsolescence that their working TV becomes less functional after a few years. So it is like Goodyear selling you a car with the tyres that they stop supporting way before the tyre is even close to end of working life.
- arthurfm 9y ago> be great if they were more modular to a standard There is actually. The Open Pluggable Specification [1] which is primarily used for digital signage screens. It's a shame consumer TVs don't use this standard (or something similar). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Pluggable_Specification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Pluggable_Specification
- rdtsc 9y ago> I will interpret this being the first idea floated as the use for some IoT tech as "we have no f'ing clue what we're going to use this for". Refrigerator with a Twitter account is my personal favorite https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/21/samsungs-lcd-fridge-with-apps-is-a-fridge-that-has-an-lcd-and-apps/ https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/21/samsungs-lcd-fridge-with-a... It's like they have two wheels one with names of household appliances on it, the other with popular online services. Then they spin them and build the resulting combination: "toaster with a Facebook Account", "shredder that talks to Instagram", "lava lamp that posts to Reddit" etc.
- digi_owl 9y agoTheir basic "problem" is that existing products in the sector has long since reached saturation, so they are looking at anything that may entice a customer to replace their existing, fully working, product.