3 ms·
Wow, I knew it was a limited beta, but I didn't know it was that limited. As one of the lucky few that had it, I now feel both special and sad that it's gone.
by jedberg 9y ago
Wow, I knew it was a limited beta, but I didn't know it was that limited. As one of the lucky few that had it, I now feel both special and sad that it's gone.
But not that sad -- I didn't use it once after a few easy questions the first day I got access. It would occasionally pop up some suggestions as I was typing messages, but I would always ignore them as they were irrelevant.
I think the biggest issue is that they weren't up front about it. They tried to make it seem like it was an AI doing all the work.
I think if they had straight up said, "this is a human and we're training an AI", it would have been a lot better. It would have allowed them to do things to get stronger feedback, like asking, "was this the right suggestion?" Then when I got irrelevant suggestions, I could give them feedback as to what was wrong and why. But it never asked me for that so I never gave any feedback.
I thought I was just one of millions training the AI and that they would get plenty of signal with all those users. I had no idea it was so limited -- I definitely would have been much more active in giving feedback had I known.
- dwwoelfel 9y agoIt sounds like you're talking about M suggestions, which are still going strong and have AI doing all of the work. The article is talking about a different aspect of M, the text-based virtual assistant, which you could ask anything and was backed by humans. The verge did a better job of explaining what was actually going away: https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/8/16856654/facebook-m-shutdown-bots-ai https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/8/16856654/facebook-m-shutdo...
- jedberg 9y agoAh, I didn't realize those were separate. I actually have both. But in that case, most of what I said still applies!
- freeone3000 9y agoThe idea behind training like this is a reverse turing test. People speak differently to humans than they do to computers. If the users think they're talking to a machine, they'll talk to the human like they talk to a machine - which gives the training data that is needed for when it is a machine.