3 ms·
A counterpoint here: Consider American subpoenas, court order, FISA warrants and the like. Remember that FISA warrants are secret! Having the data managed by a
by klodolph 9y ago
A counterpoint here: Consider American subpoenas, court order, FISA warrants and the like. Remember that FISA warrants are secret! Having the data managed by a US company has these consequences. Perhaps you trust the US government more than you trust the Chinese government... that is very reasonable, to be sure. But it makes so much more sense that your data is subject to the law in the country you reside in, rather than the laws of a foreign power.
This is not even remotely hypothetical. Making everyone's data accessible to organizations and people subject to US court orders is bad for privacy.
This kind of thing will be happening more and more, and not just China and Russia, but also the EU. So it won't just be that Chinese users can be spied upon by the Chinese government. It will also be true that it will be more difficult for the US to spy on citizens of other countries.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoIf that's a counterpoint, my point must have been unclear. I think we're in agreement.
- klodolph 9y agoI think I did not read your original comment very well.
- jstanley 9y agoIn some respects I'd rather have my data managed by a Chinese company than a British one. It's exponentially more difficult for the Chinese government to wield data against me than it is for the British government, as I do not live somewhere where the Chinese government has any power over me.
- stcredzero 9y agoIt's exponentially more difficult for the Chinese government to wield data against me than it is for the British government, as I do not live somewhere where the Chinese government has any power over me. It depends mostly on the nature of the data, and how much interest they have in you. If the data is damning enough, and they would find value in using it against you, then the Chinese government is perfectly able to hire someone to do so. Anyone in China who is significantly wealthy is effectively involved in politics, with potentially life and death consequences. To stay under the radar, you have to stay at the level of inconsequential small fry.
- jstanley 9y agoRight, but if you're not in China at all, the Chinese government don't care about you. So it's (in some respects) safer to have your data managed in a foreign country than in the country you live in, as a counterpoint to the claim that "it makes so much more sense that your data is subject to the law in the country you reside in".
- stcredzero 9y agoRight, but if you're not in China at all, the Chinese government don't care about you. In the vast majority of cases, yes. In an absolute sense, no. So it's (in some respects) safer to have your data managed in a foreign country than in the country you live in, as a counterpoint to the claim that "it makes so much more sense that your data is subject to the law in the country you reside in". There is a point to that.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Right, but if you're not in China at all, the Chinese government don't care about you. That’s ,at best, less than clear, considering the actions attributed to PLA Unit 61398.
- klodolph 9y ago> So it's (in some respects) safer to have your data managed in a foreign country than in the country you live in, as a counterpoint to the claim that "it makes so much more sense that your data is subject to the law in the country you reside in". To clarify, I'm saying it makes sense from a legal and societal perspective, not from a personal privacy perspective.
- kobayashi 9y agoHow privileged you are, then, not to live under the Chinese regime.
- jstanley 9y agoThe point was that sometimes it's better to have your data managed by a foreign government. Not that the Chinese government is somehow better than any other arbitrary government. If you live in China, feel free to mentally switch "Chinese" and "British".
- vatueil 9y agoPerhaps on an individual level it's true that moving accounts off-shore can be advantageous (although the flip side of ceding your data to a regime that isn't responsible to you in the slightest is that they have even less reason not to misuse it if it ever benefits them). But on a societal level if everyone followed this tactic we would all be worse off, especially if the foreign government is not a liberal democracy or otherwise at odds with your home country.