3 ms·
Why is this voted down?
by roel_v 16y ago
Why is this voted down?
- jrockway 16y agoBecause in other news, this is not Reddit.
- roel_v 16y agoColor me daft but I don't get it. What does Reddit have to do with it? Is it because 'in other news' is used on that site often (I don't if it is, I don't visit it)? That's an idiom that has been around since before internet let alone some website...
- user24 16y agoprobably downvoted because of the off-the-cuff attitude rather than 'serious thought provoking commentary and insight' that HN prefers. OP does have a point, but could probably do with qualifying it with some discussion rather than just leaving it as a comic one-liner.
- icey 16y agoIt wasn't intended to be a comic one-liner. I think it's idiotic that someone is surprised that they went into a dormitory carrying something that looked like a samurai sword strapped to their back and the cops got called. Was it a women's dorm? What would the story look like if it was an actually sword wielding maniac and they only sent 2 rent-a-cops? I don't know what sort of thought-provoking commentary there is to provide around what's essentially an irresponsible advertisement for a thinkgeek product.
- daten 16y agoI think the discussion of fear in society and overreactions by the police is interesting. I have owned one of these umbrellas for about a year and regularly carry it onto the DC metro. I have been stopped by metro police once. They calmly asked to see it, were generally curious about where I got it, quickly returned it and went about their day. I think it's a disgusting over-reaction to deploy more than one officer to investigate a report of someone carrying something that might be a sword. If they're running around clearly attacking people with a confirmed weapon, sure.. send in the necessary resources. If they might just be carrying an umbrella, send at most one person who can handle it even if it does turn out to be a weapon. And that's assuming weapons are banned in that area because it's a school or something. In other areas of the same country I think people have a constitutional right to own weapons in which case this wouldn't even need to be investigated. I also had one person tell me they thought they saw me carrying a gun. People aren't just afraid of sword shaped items, they're afraid of any long black narrow item. Just like Boston is afraid of anything with batteries, wires and LEDs.