3 ms·
I suspect perhaps that the AI community were used to (for decades) solving _no_ problems. Now that _some_ problems are solved in their field (e.g. facial recogn
by dboreham 9y ago
I suspect perhaps that the AI community were used to (for decades) solving _no_ problems. Now that _some_ problems are solved in their field (e.g. facial recognition for social networking purposes, playing pong, playing chess) the thinking is that now all problems are going to be solvable. I think we are going to learn that this isn't the case. Perhaps there is just a threshold of problem hardness beyond which we can't get yet at any particular point in technology-time, or perhaps there's a hard barrier waiting to be discovered beyond which current approaches just can never take us regardless of cleverness or hardware speed/density?
- Chaebixi 9y agoWasn't it sort of the same way during the first AI boom? Expert systems providing some real value in limited and sexy prototypes working with a simplified blocks world that hinted at something power world-changing. Then... > the thinking is that now all problems are going to be solvable ...and then failure and the "AI winter" for a generation after the initial promise had been discredited.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> I suspect perhaps that the AI community were used to (for decades) solving _no_ problems. Where's that coming from? There's certainly been some important advances recently, but to claim that no progress was made is strange. Just to give one blatant example, Deep Blue defeated Kasparov in 1997; Chinook had fully solved draughts (checkers) by 2007; TD-Gammon played backgrammon consistently at world champion level by 1995; two computer programs, JACK and WBRIDGE5 won five bridge championships between 2001-2007. All of those are 10 years older than AlphaGo/Zero and each has a very long history going back to the 1950's in the case of draughts AI [1]. You probably haven't hear dabout most of them because they were not advertised by a company with the media clout of Google or Facebook, but they were important successes that solved hard problems. There are many, many more results all over the AI bibliography. And, just to settle this once and for all- this bibliography starts a lot earlier than 2012. _______________ [1] All that's in "AI: A Modern Approach", 3d ed.