5 ms·
It's just one of those convenient things that people choose to believe because it lets them do things they wouldn't otherwise conscionably be able to do. Much
by taneq 9y ago
It's just one of those convenient things that people choose to believe because it lets them do things they wouldn't otherwise conscionably be able to do.
Much like in the past, we've declared that "animals don't have souls / feel pain" (so it's OK to kill and eat them), "fish don't feel pain" (so fishing for fun is OK despite obviously being horrible for the fish), "black people are inferior" (so it's OK to enslave them), "babies don't feel pain" (so it's OK to operate on them without anesthetic), etc. The thing doesn't have to be true, it just has to sound close enough and people will latch onto it to justify their behaviour.
- Valmar 9y agoThis sums up the whole debate debate in a nutshell.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agowhat about mosquitoes, parasites, amoebas, bacteria?
- Valmar 9y agoCan it be proven that they don't feel pain?
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoNo. Then what about sponges, plants, or rocks for that matter? Can't prove that they don't feel pain.
- mojomark 9y agoListen. You cannot definitively prove that fish experience or don't experience pain anymore than you can definitively prove that OJ Simpson murdered his ex-wife. However, you can build a body of evidence to support a conclusion. You can build up so much evidence that it seems impossible to refute, but even then, there will still be a tiny probability that the conclusion is false. That's what science experiments are all about. It's about probability; evidence pointing to a probable truth. How one interprets the evidence is certainly up for debate. Humans are walking experimenters. As we go about our lives, we collect evidence that we use to draw the most probable conclusions about the world we live in. For example, I've concluded that the my coffee mug will not spontaneously begin to levitate on my desk because all of the evidence I've collected in my life (years spent watching the mug and other similar objects that never started to levitate on their own, learning about gravity in school) tells me that it's extremely improbable my cup will not remain planted on my desk unless someone/something touches it. However, it's a truism that there is an unfathomably extreme small probability my cup will begin to levitate. We build scientific experiments to collect evidence about things we don't commonly, or wouldn't naturally, experience. For example, in the 1960's, this existence of the Higgs boson was conjectured. The probability of its existence was good, because the math pointed to it, but it was not extremely high probability. We can't 'see' such a particle directly, so humanity built meticulously controlled experimental set-ups to extend our senses and weed out noise that could otherwise obscure the evidence pointing to the 'truth'. Today, we are 99.999999999% sure the higgs boson exist [1], but that's still not 100%. It will never be 100%. That said, if you wish to dispute the conclusions of the author's hypothesis regarding whether or not fish experience pain, then I suggest you do it in terms of the interpretation of the experimental results with citations and evidence to back up your ideas. On HN, I expect a higher caliber of critical thinking. Otherwise, I may as well be reading comments on Yahoo! clickbait. 1. https://phys.org/news/2012-12-cms-atlas-higgs-like-particle-sigma.html https://phys.org/news/2012-12-cms-atlas-higgs-like-particle-...
- goldenkey 9y agoIf they are so simple and small that their runtime complexity with regard to manipulating matter is close to 0-- then when you kill them, they die so quick their reaction is only enough to output a bit of data. I for one feel like its moot to debate whether we would feel pain if a giant sliced our head off at the speed of sound. Thats just death-- a fast death with no sensory systems fast enough to notice. Now if youd like to debate about whether death by itself, painless death, is amoral, that would be interesting and relevant to these critters..
- j_4 9y agoI always found "catch and release" fishing to be a very misguided and hypocritical activity. I don't see eating meat as particularly immoral (this will likely change in the coming decades, as substitutes get better), but factory farming is pretty evil. Hunting and fishing help you avoid that. If you hunt for prey, then eat the poor thing, perhaps after contemplating on its life a little. If you do not, then you're literally torturing an animal for no reason other than entertainment, while deluding yourself that you're taking the moral high ground. This is similar to people who get outraged at hunters, but don't think twice about eating factory farmed meat daily.