3 ms·
What's your point? That the EU banning antibiotics in healthy livestock is a bad thing, because it drives up meat prices? I'm completely happy with meat prices
by alkonaut 9y ago
What's your point? That the EU banning antibiotics in healthy livestock is a bad thing, because it drives up meat prices? I'm completely happy with meat prices where I live and our ban on antibiotics for growth (i.e. in health animals) predates the EU regulation.
> Or maybe everyone needs to brace themselves and endure having a cold for 2 more days and not resort to antibiotics for every little thing
The reduction in antibiotic use here by doctors is also pretty noticable. I certainly don't get antibiotics prescribed for every little thing. Also, it's important to remember that while doctors might seem like they throw antibiotics at every patient, they typically prescribe the same very narrow antibiotics for everyone and use broad spectrum ones more restrictively (which is a good thing). It would be terrible if people could buy broad spectrum antibiotics over the counter.
- hycaria 9y agoNot everyone is prepared for higher animal protein prices (I don't think it's a bad thing, and I don't consume them anyways). But the people most prone to ask for radical measures are often the least aware of situations and their consequences. >our ban on antibiotics for growth Which were the only approved use of antibiotics in animals in your country without a doubt. >I certainly don't get antibiotics prescribed for every little thing Yeah me neither yet the spectacular decrease we should see is not there yet. Maybe there are other, more exigent patients then ?! >they typically prescribe the same very narrow antibiotics for everyone and use broad spectrum ones more restrictively (which is a good thing). It would be terrible if people could buy broad spectrum antibiotics over the counter. Well luckily some are only available in hospitals or such. But when I hear war stories from a veterinarian friend who switched to human medicine and sees lastest quinolones used systematically no matter the health status of the person for benign procedures, we just facepalm. They don't want to take the 5% risk that someone will need aftercare I guess. But MRSA and nosocomial infections are the real, growing threat...
- alkonaut 9y ago> Which were the only approved use of antibiotics in animals in your country without a doubt. You mean countries had (or has) laws that prohibited antibiotics for its proper use (to treat infection) but allowed antibiotics in livestock for growth stimulation? Which countries were that? And what would be the reasoning behind that? As I understood it, the "bad" countries allow antibiotics for both purposes, whereas the "good" countries started restricting antibiotics for growth, and eventually banned it completely. Have I completely misunderstood you mean?
- hycaria 9y agoProphylaxis (=treatment of healthy patients) antibiotics used to be a routine thing especially in younger animals more prone to infections etc. It was not stimulating growth per se, but as a coincidental effect. It is not very common anymore, and has not been for over a decade now (in the EU, I'm not sure about overseas). But it's still possible for some specific sicknesses (one is sick, you can treat others that are not sick preventively) or productions (ie poultry and pigs iirc). (Growth is still systematically stimulated through hormones injections in cattle at least in the Canada/US, and this is completely banned in the EU, maybe there's some mix up there ?) > eventually banned it completely No, luckily it's not completely banned anywhere I know of, and I hardly see this happening tbh. Even in organic productions and such its a number of treatments (or quantity per animal) limit per year. It is not banned and breeding animals would be hardly sustainable if it were.
- alkonaut 9y agoRight. Yes I was considering the subtherapeutic use in otherwise completely healthy populations of livestock. Good to see that is also being addressed (as late as 2017 for the US). That only addresses dispensing it through, feed though so I'm unsure how common it is to simply admnister the same thing through some other means? Of course, the elephant in the room is the use in China/India/Brazil. I wonder how close we are to those countries adopting EU/US style regulation. Basically, how do we tell China/India/Brazil that they will simply have to accept protein prices that are much higher?
- nielsbot 9y agowould they be much higher? what is “much” here? (not trolling)
- cageface 9y agoAntibiotics are still used in massive quantities in the US solely to promote growth and also to allow animals to be confined in increasingly smaller and less hygienic environments and to compensate for increasingly dirtier and more dangerous slaughterhouse conditions. None of this is necessary. From what I understand this is less the case in the EU. 80% of the antibiotics used in the US are given to animals, not people: http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/09/are-antibiotics-turning-livestock-superbug-factories http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/09/are-antibiotics-turni...
- fpoling 9y agoBy far the cheapest protein comes from plants so I do not see how more expensive meat can affect protein availability. If one wants to insist that poor have right to cheap protein from meat, then the present time animal agriculture is just unsustainable and the poor people in future will surfer from it disproportionally.