4 ms·
This rant unfortunately fails to clearly demonstrate how Kurzweil errs. It goes on about complexity and emergence, but why would complex interactions not emerge
by cageface 16y ago
This rant unfortunately fails to clearly demonstrate how Kurzweil errs. It goes on about complexity and emergence, but why would complex interactions not emerge from a computer simulation just as they do in the real biochemical system?
Because so far, despite the best efforts of many geniuses and heroic computing resources, our simulations don't even reliably predict the real-world outcomes of far, far simpler systems. Ilya Prigogine won the Nobel Prize in chemistry for demonstrating that sufficiently complex systems display emergent behaviors that can never be entirely predicted by studying their components in isolation:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilya_Prigogine#The_End_of_Certainty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilya_Prigogine#The_End_of_Certa...
Kurzweil is hopelessly out of his depth in these arguments and is talking nonsense. Personally I'll be very surprised if we can construct anything approaching human intelligence in my lifetime.
- chmike 16y agoBTW how do you define human intelligence ? What is it that we wouldn't be able to construct ? Put in another way, what construct would qualify as approaching human intelligence ?
- cageface 16y agoMy definition of human intelligence is intelligence that is broadly adaptable, self-training, and able to communicate via a system of symbols as ambiguous and semantically rich as human language. For instance, an intelligence that could be taught to read English and then have a reasonable conversation about a contemporary novel, with its own insights into the style and themes of the book, would qualify. That said, I do expect to see great strides in the sophistication of machines in the next 30 years. They don't have to think like people to be useful.