8 ms·
Trends to Avoid When Founding a Startup
- sk5t 9y agoHmm, this article took a quick turn into a story about how it takes just one year of coding experience + something from fast.ai to become "world-class deep learning practitioners"; make of that what you will.
- paulgb 9y agoI don't see anything that mentions just a year of coding experience, but as a participant in their free MOOC I can say that it's highly worthwhile. It's unique and complimentary to the more academic material usually found on deep learning.
- karthikb 9y agoFrom the article... "And even for highly technical aspects like deep learning, fast.ai has shown that people with 1-year of coding experience can become world-class deep learning practitioners; you don’t need to hire Stanford PhDs. "
- paulgb 9y agoThanks, I somehow missed that.
- Alex3917 9y agoWhy would you need more than a year of coding experience to learn deep learning? Isn't it mostly math? I wouldn't think that mastering advanced Python syntax or whatever would be the limiting factor for most people.
- tinymollusk 9y agoI was in their recent course. No previous AI experience, although I've been coding for 20 years. Using what I learned in the class, I am regularly able to finish in the top 20% on most Kaggle competitions. Just being able to solve some of those problems allows me to provide employers with major value.
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoI don't know how that could mean anything other than becoming familiar with a deep learning library/platform product and implementing feature requests with it. In that case, I can readily see that. Especially if they have good teachers and teach the concepts thoroughly.
- pault 9y agoI don't think that's too outrageous as long as we don't read "practitioners" and hear "experts". Agree that the article is a thinly disguised recruiting advertisment though.
- taneq 9y agoDo you not think "world class" implies significant expertise?
- deepnotderp 9y agoI agree a lot with #3 but disagree heavily with #4. There are canonical examples of PhD theses that became successful companies, not to mention the dozens of companies who exited (e.g. CV companies to Qualcomm).
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoYeah, Akamai, Google, to some extent Bose come to mind. Most PhD theses would NOT become companies, so this is good advice for a PhD student but not for a founder. If a founder finds a PhD thesis that is worth productionizing, then the fact that it was a PhD thesis is irrelevant.
- philipov 9y agoThe advice is "Don't productionize your PhD" thesis," so I think it is in fact aimed at PhD students in the exact spirit you pointed out, not founders surveying the academic field.
- dpwm 9y agoFor what it's worth, trends #4 and #5 are both qualified with "AI Specific" further down. There will be some PhD theses that do solve real problems, but many are not going to make a startup successful by themselves.
- indescions_2018 9y agoJawbone founder Hosain Rahman developed his microphone tech while still a Stanford EE I believe. There are also the Quantum Computing startups to spin out of Yale CS. Gene editing pioneered at MIT Broad Institute. And on and on. Regarding AI / ML as a service specifically. Many startups may find themselves facing the same issues plaguing IBM Watson. Deep learning considers trillion dimensional spaces. Most enterprise prediction problems are simply not of an astrophysical scale. And where domain specific expertise is required. Such as Google Maps use of CV in rendering highres satellite image data to SVG for the browser. Simply having grad student level familiarity with OpenCV might not be sufficient. A Year of Google & Apple Maps (warning: bandwidth & cpu intensive) https://www.justinobeirne.com/a-year-of-google-maps-and-apple-maps/ https://www.justinobeirne.com/a-year-of-google-maps-and-appl...
- outsidetheparty 9y agoNegative trends 4 and 5 are not, contra the article, AI-specific; AI just happens to be the intellectual problem of the moment. The team I was on waaaay back in the prehistory of the web era was warned against hiring too many PhDs. We disregarded the advice. (These were smart guys, yo! They had PhDs!) We spent a couple of years tackling interesting problems instead of relevant problems, and just about entirely missed out on the first web bubble as a result. I love smart academic people. I love those big brains. I'll never hire one ever again. Give me someone who's more interested in working around a problem than in studying it, and we'll get things done. Give me a PhD and we'll have a nice paper about it about 5 years after anyone other than their thesis advisor cares.
- rmykhajliw 9y agoYep, all the points are the truth. I've got some of those mistakes in the past especially VC funding, and it's really painful. Staying small is not a big lose or something, actually you can earn 10x more money by staying small than burning billions and keep working crazy hours. For example you can look on what's up for the price of 19 instagrams they had around 30 employees. They were small and output was way bigger than in general VC - funded company.
- lpolovets 9y agoI have a vested interest as a VC, but I disagree that VC funding is a negative signal. That's a very blanket statement to make, and there are lots of toxic VC-funded companies but also lots of amazing ones. (Similarly, there are tons of toxic non-VC companies and tons of amazing ones.) The way I'd frame it is: 1) If you want to build a company that is venture scale, taking VC funding is a great option to consider. If you don't want to build such a company, VC funding is a very poor option. 2) There are good and bad VCs. The bad ones suck. The good ones will help you and support you even if the outcome is 2x or 0x. Fred Wilson at Union Square Ventures articulates this attitude well in several posts: a) "If you look at the distribution of outcomes in a venture fund, you will see that it is a classic power law curve, with the best investment in each fund towering over the rest, followed by a few other strong investments, followed by a few other decent ones, and then a long tail of investments that don’t move the needle for the VC fund. But that long tail is comprised of entrepreneurs and their teams. People who have given years of their lives to a dream that was ultimately not realized. And as I have written many times over the years on this blog, I spent the majority of my time on that long tail. This is irrational behavior if you think about fund economics, but I believe it is rational behavior if you think about firm reputation." (http://avc.com/2015/11/power-law-and-the-long-tail/ http://avc.com/2015/11/power-law-and-the-long-tail/) b) "There are two interesting things here that I always think about. The first is that even the very best investors in the VC business only get a hit about 1/3 of the time. That means that they have their share of "slog it outs" and "hit the walls" too. I am certainly in that camp. The second is that we end up spending an incredible amount of time and energy (hopefully not money) on the 2/3 of our investments that don't work out. When everything goes well, you really don't need that much from a VC. Of course, I have added value in all of my winners. But its the ones that don't work that I have left my blood, sweat, and tears on. And that's the paradox of being a VC that cares. Which is the only kind of VC you want to work with." (http://avc.com/2013/03/when-things-dont-work-out/ http://avc.com/2013/03/when-things-dont-work-out/)
- crdb 9y agoI'd frame 1) slightly differently, as there are many cases of bootstrapped unicorns. Time is also a currency, so you make a trade-off between time (extra years of your life spent acquiring funds to scale, and delayed product launch) and control. Time is also an issue when you have competition, in the sense that your competitors can get there first by raising money.
- c8d3f7b49897918 9y agoNegative trend 6: adopting a trendy, complex web stack before you absolutely have to when a simple one would get you to market faster
- dfee 9y agoI constantly need to remind myself of this.
- linkmotif 9y agoWhat are some examples of a trendy, complex web stack? Or, what are some examples of a non-trendy, non-complex web stack?
- parthdesai 9y agoAdding pub-sub/queue/message broker in your app when a normal when a normal connection to SQL db from your web app is more than sufficient. There are a lot of companies that have kafka in their stack when they actually don't need it. This is one thing i have seen a lot. On front-end side adding redux when a normal react-app would be just fine.
- birken 9y agoI don't want to diminish the success that this company is having being run in their own way, but give me a break with these blog posts. VC is a "trend to avoid"? Avoid "Hypergrowth"? I guess companies like Google, Facebook, Twitter, Amazon, Stripe, Airbnb, Dropbox, Pinterest and a hundred others all really messed up. I mean I could go point by point and give examples that are the opposite of these trends, but that isn't any more meaningful than these suggestions. You can choose to run a company however you want, and you should. If you believe these things are bad, don't do them. Attract employees that agree with you. The market will decide if you are right or not. But enough with the blog posts about it, especially if they are dismissing critical tools that many companies use very successfully. Every company is different, every product is different, every team is different. Use some common sense on what tools make sense for you, and keep an open mind.
- mschuster91 9y ago> I guess companies like Google, Facebook, Twitter, Amazon, Stripe, Airbnb, Dropbox, Pinterest and a hundred others all really messed up. Google and Amazon are hardly the classic 100x-hypergrowth model. Facebook and Twitter DID really mess up, have you seen how much utterly vile stuff you can report to them and it will still be around months later? Have you been at the receiving end of a shitstorm or Nazi trolls? People order SWATs over Twitter, leading to deaths. The president of the US leaves the rest of the world in panic when someone will finally declare war with him after yet another tweet. The reports from former "moderators" all have one thing in common, they're exploited worse than cannon fodder in wars (the soldiers at least were dead, the moderators will have to live with the videos of beheadings and CP the rest of their lives). Airbnb screwed up entire city rental markets and squeezed out thousands of poor people, hardly call that a success. Pinterest? Wtf how on earth is this worth 12 billion dollars? Or Snapchat with 25B $? Where is the actual worth represented in positive effects for society by this?! In the end all that creates this "wealth" is data. Data is volatile, it's intangible - and once it is too much, the noise ratio gets too high to be useful, and then most of the companies you mentioned will have a massive problem with finances because they're only worth as much as the data and eyeballs of their customers is worth. > Attract employees that agree with you and end up like Uber with a reputation of "every one is welcome here, as long he's a white male with tolerance for extremely high alcohol consumption"? > The market will decide if you are right or not. The market is so oversaturated with cash that an app that could literally do nothing more than distribute "Yo" could get 1.5M$ cash at 10M$ valuation. The corrective forces of the market have vanished long since, otherwise the business model of many VCs would have broken years ago. To make stuff worse, the employees are often enough paid with options that may or may not become entirely worthless (and some options even are until an IPO or after years of working for the company!). That's gambling with the future in a really toxic way. And while I'm at gambling: that more and more cash, both from the VC, the institutional financial and the private sector is flowing into ever more "coins" is also something that is dangerous and set up to explode. Yet another consequence of the current cash saturation. Don't get me wrong: VCs as an institution, startups and coins serve an useful purpose. But in current conditions (both political and financial) they and the business model they run have grown extremely toxic on society.
- stretchwithme 9y agoAvoid trends in general, unless they make sense. Well, that's what an AI told me to do.
- andreygrehov 9y ago#3. This is so truth. People have no idea what they talking about when they say "we are a family". Forget this whole family crap! Hire skilled and talented people. Let them do their job. Give them freedom and don't stand in their way. Employees barely know what a friendship is, let alone a family.
- stretchwithme 9y agoPretending to be a family is bad news. Especially if you tell prospective employees that and then remind them that employment is "at will".
- FireBeyond 9y agoRight? "We're a family... and if you fuck up, you're outta the family."
- solidsnack9000 9y agoSo, trying to be like one of the five families.
- stretchwithme 9y agoNot even. Business errors or just a bad economy can get you laid off from the family. "Times are hard, Jimmy. So Mom will drop you off downtown."
- jmtame 9y agoThe family relationship has always been a horrible way of describing the employee/employer relationship. There's divorce or disowning someone, but do you really want to try and draw that comparison when you fire someone? A team has players and they're always being traded to different teams. That's both more positive and honest when you're trying to describe a high-performant culture. And there's also no concept of unconditional love in a company. There's respect, which should be a given. But you shouldn't be expected to unconditionally love your co-workers.
- dboreham 9y agoJim Barksdale : "This ain't a family and I'm not yer Daddy".
- jdoliner 9y ago> Then I realized that most of the startups were indistinguishable from one another: nearly everyone was following the same destructive trends which are bad for employees and bad for products This is rich coming from the founder of a startup that's indistinguishable from all the other coding bootcamp, MooC startups out there with a dash Deep Learning thrown in to make it extra trendy. As for the actual advice, I think it's pretty hit or miss. > 1. Venture Capital Nothing in her description of VC is wrong here. But the lesson: "VC is to be avoided" is an oversimplification. VC money is a tool. It's not always the right tool, and it certainly has its downsides. But it has its upsides too. In many cases it's the only way to get a business off the ground. > 2. Hypergrowth I don't really know where the author puts the line between hypergrowth and just growth, as PG has said: starts are growth. They must always be growing, is there such thing as too much growth? Maybe, if really bad things are happening in the company because of the growth like people are burning out and quitting... but really that's only bad because eventually it will hurt growth. So I think the simple lesson is grow as fast as possible, don't be short sighted. > 3. Trying to be “like a family” This one I agree with. Trying to be like a family in a professional setting is dishonest, and eventually the truth of the situation becomes clear. It's better to be honest from the start. > 4. Attempting to productionize a PhD thesis We'll have to tell Larry Page he's wasting his time trying to turn that dumb Page Rank thesis into a company. There are a lot of companies that fail this way and there are a lot of PhD theses that shouldn't be commercialized but people try none the less. As with all things startups, there's a thousand failures for every success and the only way to tell the difference is to actually found the company. > 5. Hiring a bunch of academic researchers The only company I've really observed doing this is Google and it seems to have worked out for them. I can easily believe that their are companies out there that higher a bunch of researchers to do a job they're not really capable of doing. I've also known academic researchers who were able to have a huge impact in the role they were hired for even though it wasn't really research. The general statement of this is that you needed to hire people for roles they want to and can perform. Researchers might be a particular anti-pattern in this but it's far from the only one.
- sokoloff 9y agoIs doubling in a year even "hypergrowth"? Doubling revenue every a month or two? Sure. Doubling revenue in a year is a very strong growth rate for an established company, but it doesn't strike me as particularly hypergrowth. Doubling headcount in a year seems also fairly routine for early-stage companies (assuming funding and cachet is in place).
- Kerrick 9y agoDoubling headcount from 3 -> 6 is quite different than from 450 -> 909.
- nlh 9y agoGreat points. Strongly agree with #3 in particular ("like a family") because I've made this exact mistake with companies I've led in the past. To elaborate on what the piece touches on but doesn't specifically say: > You will need to make hard decisions for the sake of > the business. You can’t actually offer people anything > remotely close to lifelong loyalty or security, and it’s > dishonest to implicitly do so. To be clear(er): You will have to fire people, and firing someone who thinks of themselves as a family member or who you think of as similar makes the whole thing much more painful. Further, it can make you, as a leader, hesitate when it's an action you really need to take ("but this person is like my brother - we'll make it work!"). At my most recent company, we took the opposite approach -- we all liked each other a lot, we worked well together, and we ate lunch together as a team, but at 6pm everyone went home to their own lives and families. The lines were clear, the understandings were there, and I think it was a much better way to run things.
- EGreg 9y agoHow about taking it one step further and not hiring people onto a team but instead rewarding them: https://qbix.com/blog/index.php/2016/11/properly-valuing-contributions/ https://qbix.com/blog/index.php/2016/11/properly-valuing-con...
- nikanj 9y agoThe common mental model of a fledgling software startup is too large by at least one order of magnitude. For a decent, traction-but-no-rocketship product oriented startup, you need one solid back-end+ops guy, one solid front-end+UX guy, and one programmer for each mobile platform you wish to support. Add a CEO+sales+finances person, to keep the business side of the business compliant. Yes, you won't get a cool continuous integration autoscaling whatnot doodad. YAGNI also applies to infrastructure, people and organizational hierarchies. Don't build them just because Google and Facebook have them. Look for a profitable company that's just one size bigger than you are today, and aim for that. They've already proven that it's possible to operate at that size with the whatever they've got. Repeat as you grow.
- jjeaff 9y agoThere are startups out there running their whole backend on products like graph.cool and have no need for an ops person. And they are building their app in react native with one developer (which can then be launched in iOS and Android simultaneously).
- 40acres 9y agoA trend that I would like to see more startups buck is the use of the independent contractor model. While I believe startups like Uber and Lyft could not achieve the scale that they have w.o this model, there are smaller startups & markets where I believe the increase in value to customer service can really differentiate a product. Studies have shown that customer service, ability to execute & perform, and general quality of service correlate with whether or not the employee is an IC/temp or not. I've wondered if any startups have gone the opposite direction and hired folks FT/PT for roles that otherwise would seem to be filled by ICs.
- sytelus 9y agoThe catchiest (and wrong) assertion is this: "even for highly technical aspects like deep learning, fast.ai has shown that people with 1-year of coding experience can become world-class deep learning practitioners" Yes, any Joe can train deep network with dozen lines of Keras. Sure, your startup can use off-the self models and tweak it a bit... That doesn't make you "world-class deep learning practitioner". If you are designing the network for new problem domain, there are thousands of decisions to make - everything from hyperparameters to network architecture to distributions in data. Making these decisions without having developed lots of intuition and good foundations is very hard. I often find usual developers without ML background and experience completely lost in these cases. Debugging a model that doesn't work is super hard. There are no IDEs, no breakpoints, no watches and in fact not even error messages. Its purely statistical debugging and probabilistic fixes.
- matte_black 9y agoStill, it's nothing unlearnable. You read a couple good books and blogs, do some experiments, and you're about 80% of the way there.
- sytelus 9y agoNothing is unlearnable - it's never question of "if it can be done" but question of "how much effort is needed". Read few blogs, books and take Coursera classes etc are all good but the real thing is working on multiple real and new problems. Anyone who has read books/blogs etc, give them a new problem, for example, predicting pedestrian intent for crossing a road from set of video frames. See how far they get.
- matte_black 9y agoSo are you saying there are no best practices or patterns that are discovered over time that allows newcomers to progress in the field faster than the early pioneers?
- figgis 9y ago
- jwilliams 9y agoWithout hyperbole, one of the biggest trends to avoid is overgeneralization. A large part of one's experience at a startup is unique to that context. Certainly not all. But certainly a lot -- Probably the majority of what counts as advice. Being able to filter what's generalizable and what's not is the most useful skill an advisor can develop -- ironically, even more than the experience. (And I'm breaking my own hypothesis by giving advice there).
- quickthrower2 9y agoBeing pedantic: I thought the definition of 'startup' is a company aiming for massive growth. If not you are a regular business. So maybe the message is "You don't have to be a startup"
- plinkplonk 9y agoHow does fast.ai make money?
- newusertoday 9y ago+1, i am curious too, can someone answer this?
- hyperpallium 9y ago> You and your adviser picked your thesis topic because it’s an interesting technical problem with good opportunities to publish, not because it has a large opportunity for impact in an underserved market with few barriers to entry. This is obvious, yet an easy mistake. Behind it is applying the same values to a business as to a PhD - not only in topic selection, but also in execution. It's related to the conundrum that solving a problem that real people have now does not always require a technically great soluton. Even a revolutionary business does not necessarily require a technically great solution. Academic success requires academic values and skills; business success requires business values and skills. Of course, if you want to create a technologically revolutionary business, you'll need both.
- kriro 9y agoFirst of all fast.ai is awesome and most of the points they make align quite well with my personal views which of course doesn't mean they are the right views ;) but... """Hiring a bunch of academic researchers will not improve your product and harms your company by diverting so many resources (unless your goal is an aquihire).""" Disagree. Ceteris paribus a previous academic researcher isn't necessarily a worse hire than a graduate or someone who has worked at other tech companies. I'm really not a fan of this "don't hire people from academia" narrative. A good scientist is well versed in systematic problem solving which doesn't sound like a horrible skillset for someone working at a startup. Sure there's enough people with PhDs that can't write working code but there's also enough people that can. I'm not sure about the US but hiring a PhD isn't necessarily more expensive than hiring someone with job experience in the tech sector either. I get their basic idea but it's news to me that even AI startups are on "only PhDs all the time" hiring frenzies.
- hedonistic7283 9y ago>Negative trend 3: “Our startup is like a family” No, just no. I disagree with this. I’m just a lowly employee and I spend 1/3rd of my life with the office. I want that office to be my family when I’m spending so much of my life there.