4 ms·
> A blockchain ensures that some sequence of agreements was made in a way that everyone can trust. [...] The rest is fairy dust and noise. Amen. "Blockchain" i
by Terr_ 9y ago
> A blockchain ensures that some sequence of agreements was made in a way that everyone can trust. [...] The rest is fairy dust and noise.
Amen. "Blockchain" is today's fad just like the "nanotech" mania of yesteryear. That doesn't mean there aren't advances and opportunities, but it feels like 90% of the people promoting it can't even give a high-level explanation of why it's a good fit for their use-case.
> For example, why would be want a "fat" protocol?
This may seem weird, but bear with me: I think this is like people talking about intellectual property (copyrights, patents, franchises, etc.) The underlying idea is that you can create some core framework which everyone wants to use (or can't avoid) and that therefore you can collect rent (or at least sew up an incredible starter bonus) making it more consequential than the individual pieces.
The current internet is (perhaps thankfully) a contrast, where nobody (AFAK) is making big bucks off of TCP-IP/HTML/Browser licensing fees.
- ThomPete 9y agoThey actually can and fairly well IMO. What seems to be a bigger problem is that people don't want to accept that that has value.
- Spooky23 9y agoA friend of mine told a great story about how some Koop aid drinkers were pitching blockchain internally for internal chargeback for services. So you’d use your corpcoin to rent cubes and get pens from the facilities folks, and trade coin to get servers, etc. the idea had traction until the accountants revolted.
- krrrh 9y agoDidn’t Ronald Coase win the Nobel prize in economics for basically pointing out why this was a bad idea? [1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem
- Terr_ 9y agoOof. It's hard to know where to even start poking holes in that. Like whether everybody's OK storing the data all across the world, versus running a tiny internal network that can be taken over by a disgruntled employee.