10 ms·
> “We also want to work across the industry (ideally including Apple) longer-term to address more robust, cross-device advertising targeting and measurement cap
by kstrauser 9y ago
> “We also want to work across the industry (ideally including Apple) longer-term to address more robust, cross-device advertising targeting and measurement capabilities that are also consumer friendly.”
Just to be clear: you want that. Whatever lies you tell yourself to get to sleep at night, no one outside your parasitic industry wants this. I, for one, absolutely 100% do not want you to target and measure me robustly across devices.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Just to be clear: you want that. Well yeah, they said 'we ... want'. How much clearer do you think they could have stated that? They never said you or anyone else wanted it.
- rob_b 9y agoI believe the goal was to identify the disconnect between what they envision and what the targeted users actually want. I’m in agreement that this is not something that I would want and am glad that the difficulties exist to being with.
- _sdegutis 9y agoCan't speak for GP, but what I took from the quote and GP's response was that the advertising industry is kind of in a monopoly position of being able to screw all consumers over with nobody to reign them in, and now that someone is finally standing up to them and making it every so slightly more inconvenient for them, they're throwing a hissy fit, and that their statement kind of shows that they're well aware of all this and are pretty fine with it actually, and not even really trying to hide it.
- Freestyler_3 9y ago"Criteo, which took advantage of that loophole" You see, even when they get presented with rules, they try to work around them.
- ajkjk 9y agoThis is not constructive. The meaning of emphasizing 'you' and then providing a contrasting viewpoint is not lost on anybody.
- chrisseaton 9y agoBut there's an attack there. 'Just to be clear'. They were crystal clear. The GP's attack is unfair.
- jacobolus 9y agoClose to nothing the ad industry unilaterally “wants” or has ever wanted is “consumer friendly”. Most of the purpose of advertising is to trick consumers into doing things they otherwise don’t want to do or buying things they otherwise don’t want to buy. That goes doubly for building pervasive spy systems compiling a detailed dossier about every person on the internet, with absolutely zero transparency or public accountability and no liability for selling that information or having it hacked.
- Feniks 9y agoYep every once in a while I see someone talks about "acceptable ads like static images". But those days are long gone. You can't have ads without tracking.
- rhizome 9y agoIt's pretentious for them to assert that the industry they're speaking for includes Apple.
- sandov 9y agoThey imply that consumers also want it by saying "consumer friendly". It's like a robber saying: We want to develop victim-friendly ways to steal you.
- plushpuffin 9y agoI'm pretty sure you just described a kidnapper, not a robber.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- EgoIncarnate 9y agoI don't think it's that simple. Nobody wants their privacy invaded, but they do want cheaper products. In theory better targeted ads allow a company to spend it's advertising budget more effectively. Selling more products for the same amount of ad cost should allow for cheaper products. I'm sure some companies will not pass on the savings, but I believe economic theory says the market as a whole should. If the savings are enough, some people may be willing to give up some of their privacy in the name of cheaper products. How much more do companies make? Is all this invasive tracking really necessary in order to keep websites like Google and Facebook free? Is it worth saving 10% (or whatever) on some product? Unfortunately the decision is forced upon everyone by advertisers with little thought to allowing for an informed choice (or any choice really).
- rob_b 9y agoThe prevalence of Alexa and other “assistance” devices shows that people willingly allow their privacy to be invaded for the perceived benefit gained from it. Advertising is one of those things where they want to analyze every action, effort, and thought, without any regard for the impact it has on the affected users’ privacy and there will be lines of potential customers waiting to signup after being enticed by the carrot. I think the blame is shared between both sides and I do believe the pendulum will continue to shift as long as technology continues to be embedded in our everyday lives.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoI think it’s more likely most people outside the HackerNewsosphere don’t understand what it is, let alone the value of the “it” they are trading away.
- dageshi 9y agoIf it doesn't cost them any actual ongoing money then I think most people simply don't care. Same reason people find advertising annoying, but don't really care on any deeper level, it doesn't cost them anything tangibly.
- appachai2 9y agoBest of luck paying 1 cent for every search result you do. And ofcourse you don't even realize but ads is one of the best ways for underprivileged to get on to internet.
- EgoIncarnate 9y agoYou can have still have ads without invasive tracking, they just might not be as effective. If the difference in effectiveness is enough to make Google, etc unprofitable than maybe there is an argument to be made that it is necessary. If it means they make 10% less profit, people would probably prefer privacy.
- appachai2 9y agoThat's the 90s. I don't think people were happy with that. I wasn't on internet then, so not 100% sure. In general, I see money as a representative of how effective certain company/technology/etc. is and there were no multi billion dollar companies in 90s (though the internet was young at that point). I am pretty sure there are tons of things Google/Facebook/Amazon/etc. can improve but not having any data about user isn't definitely one of those approaches.
- EgoIncarnate 9y agoI think it's a matter of degree, not absolute. You can do targeted advertising without being invasive. If Facebook wants to target ads on their site based on information I have entered in my pubic profile I am okay with that. If Google wants to target ads based on keywords related to what I am searching for at the time I am okay with that. It's when you start tracking across time and across sites and inferring things I may not to have public that I think it gets invasive. Google and Facebook know they are being invasive. They specifically don't allow advertising on things that might trigger people and make them realize how invasive they are being. For example, you can't start retargeting people who searched for information on erectile disfunction with ads for Viagra. People would rightfully get upset about that level invasiveness. Instead of not being invasive, they just don't allow the things that would trigger people. If people in general were made to realize how creepy all the tracking is, laws would require advertisers to change. Given the option I would prefer that not being invasive be the default. If that makes things slightly more expensive, so be it.
- d0mine 9y agoRelevant: "privacy is the right to be human" https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8797-social_cooling_-_big_data_s_unintended_side_effect https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8797-social_cooling_-_big_data_s...
- jnsaff2 9y agoI was at that talk and it was amazing, but I remember it as: “privacy is the right to be imperfect”. Not a big difference and I might remember it incorrectly, but worth a note me thinks.
- madez 9y agoWhat an amazing talk. There are some audio problems in the beginning, but the quality of the content makes easily up for that. The talk is about an aspect of the change that technology and digitalization bring to our society, and how we deal with that. Language is a key factor in change, and the talk is focussed on that. I highly recommend watching it.
- balls187 9y agoSo you want to pay for all internet content? It's not mutually exclusive: 100% paid content vs instrusive and obnoxious tracking. However Content publishers are desperately trying to increase revenue and these ad-tech companies provide a means to do so.
- user5994461 9y agoCriteo is the only good employer in France when it comes to work conditions and salary. It's easier to sleep at night knowing there is a roof over your head.
- elaus 9y ago> Criteo is the only good employer in France […] I feel like this needs some additional specification/limitation to make it a believable statement. The only good employer in the ads/data selling business?
- user5994461 9y agoThe only good employer in tech for highly skilled developers. Remember that the GAFA only have offices in a very few locations worldwide. Can't work for them if they are not here.
- C4stor 9y agoThat's simply not true. I left Criteo a handful of years ago and I can easily admit the work conditions were really nice, and the skill level among the team quite high. I can also say there are other companies with comparable perks and technology level (or maybe the code level of Criteo has very considerably increased, but looking at what's open sourced, like cuttle, it doesn't seem like it), like some founded by former criteo employees (or c level dudes, since JB Rudelle is creating a new tech company with Romain Niccoli) Your answer sounds to me like a false dichotomy argument.
- user5994461 9y agoWhat other good employers do you have in mind?