5 ms·
Because, while you can by dint of extreme effort produce a user experience with IRC that's broadly comparable with what Slack offers out of the box, doing so re
by throwanem 9y ago
Because, while you can by dint of extreme effort produce a user experience with IRC that's broadly comparable with what Slack offers out of the box, doing so requires so much relatively rare expertise, and so much more support investment, that it's not cost-effective to do so.
- walrus01 9y agoWe have an IRC server that lives in private IP space and is only accessible by VPN. It was not rocket science to set up. If you think that running ircd-hybrid on debian requires "rare" expertise, then your definition of rare and mine do not exactly match.
- throwanem 9y agoRunning an ircd doesn't require rare expertise. Running an IRC infrastructure that your sales team can and will use, that's as reliable as Slack is - well.
- u801e 9y agoIs using an IRC client any less intuitive compared to using a locally installed Slack client (or, in the past, using something like AIM, MSN Messenger, Yahoo Messenger, Google talk, etc)?
- walrus01 9y agoin my opinion, no, there are a lot of perfectly usable GUI IRC clients. technical teams can use irssi from the command line.
- throwanem 9y agoNo, as long as you pick a client that supports automatic image unfurling, file sharing via some cloud storage service or other, a broad range of emoji including customizable ones (people care more than you think!), and run a bouncer so your users don't lose their entire scrollback every time they disconnect. I'm not saying that an IRC experience comparable to Slack can't be achieved. I'm saying that it is so much work to do so that, for many organizations, just paying Slack a few bucks a user makes a lot more sense than sinking scarce and vastly more expensive engineer time into reinventing that particular wheel.
- walrus01 9y agoThere are a number of people that will say automatic image unfurling and file sharing are unwanted features which also pose security risks, if you want to operate a truly internal-only text chat system...
- throwanem 9y agoIf you want a truly internal-only text chat system for security reasons, you're not looking at Slack to begin with.
- monkeywork 9y agoand does your IRC server / client combo work in a seamless manner with consistent user interface over practically all platforms? does it allow for chat history to be easily seen? does it allow the user experience that the non technical members of the company need to actually use it?
- craigsmansion 9y ago> a user experience with IRC Probably, but the OPs case was that they were trying to get work done. > doing so requires so much relatively rare expertise [..] support investment [..] not cost-effective "apt-get install ircd"? That's Debian for, "I'm getting too old for this shit."
- bogomipz 9y ago>" extreme effort produce a user experience with IRC that's broadly comparable with what Slack offers out of the box." You mean like communicating with people? >"relatively rare expertise" Do you realize that IRC has been around for 30 years and that a lot of open source projects have their own IRC channel?
- throwanem 9y agoYes, I do realize that. I also realize that, when you need to be able to easily include people who aren't engineers or ready to deal with what engineers deal with - that is, when you're a business - IRC requires much effort beyond the "apt-get install ircd" baseline to provide even a minimally satisfactory user experience.
- bogomipz 9y agoThere are plenty of easy to use IRC clients like Adium, Colloquy, etc. It's no more difficult than learning HipChat or Slack features.
- u801e 9y ago> when you need to be able to easily include people who aren't engineers Plenty of people were able to use IRC in the past without IT help or training. They just installed a client like mIRC and figured it out from there.
- throwanem 9y agoYes, at a time when Windows 98 was considered a perfectly acceptable desktop operating system, and smartphones didn't yet exist. The UX bar is much higher now.
- bogomipz 9y agoTyping in a text box and reading text on a screen is just as easy now as it was 15 years ago. Typing and reading text on an IRC client is also no more difficult than doing so on Slack.