3 ms·
My favorite part about the blockchain is that it is a standard building block for decentralized byzantine consensus. Throw Ripple's XRP Consensus algorithm at 5
by EGreg 9y ago
My favorite part about the blockchain is that it is a standard building block for decentralized byzantine consensus. Throw Ripple's XRP Consensus algorithm at 50-100 nodes and you know that 30% or more would have to be compromised to break the guarantees.
That's really cool because I can code the rest of the interface (front end etc.) with sloppy security and then ACTUALLY BOLT ON a secure layer with guarantees at the end.
Makes development much more streamlined. As the author of a huge codebase (https://qbix.com/platform https://qbix.com/platform) I worry that there are lots of security holes. With such a large attack surface, most new open source projects are swiss cheese, like early Wordpress (which is still full of holes from plugins).
Here, we just build our MODEL layer with a blockchain and KNOW the rules are going to be enforced.
Combine that with IPFS and a token and suddenly you don't have to pay for hosting to scale to billions of people. It's nice.
- xchaotic 9y agoIt's nice in an utopian kind of way, but it's actually less efficient - i.e. more costly overall. So you're talking Facebook paying for their hosting by showing ads vs you trying to charge customers real money or slow down their computers. I have a guess which one is going to prevail.
- EGreg 9y agoHmm how do you figure? Having people host with several nodes running a consensus algorithm is worse than trusting all your data to one actor in "the cloud"?
- joosters 9y agoRipple is not trustless, so the blockchain part of it is moot. Since you have to trust Ripple (because they have full control), you might as well let them store the blockchain data on their own centrally controlled database.
- EGreg 9y agoWhat are you talking about? What exactly can Ripple do on its own network that you have to trust t not to do? And anyway it's open source software! Why don't you go download the XRP consensus protocol from their github repo and try it. Ripple's servers won't even be part of the network.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoIf you want to be part of the Ripple network you have to trust Ripple's set of trusted validators. MySQL is open source, but that doesn't make a given MySQL server decentralized. Ripple in this case is that MySQL server.
- EGreg 9y agoIf you want to be part of the Bitcoin network, you have to trust Bitcoin's miner du jour (actually du 10 minute). What is there to trust? That they'll take your transaction? About the only thing they can do is refuse to include it in a block. Not much to trust really.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoYou don't have to trust anyone. You have to only trust that over 50% of mining power is motivated by cryptoeconomic incentives, which is a much more reliable assumption than assuming someone is altruistic or a good actor. The fact that miners do not need to be known and trusted third parties means that there is great difficulty for any network adversary to identify enough miners to make an attack effective, and that even they were able to identify pools controlling >50% mining power, they would have great difficulty sustaining this attack as the network reacts by switching to new pools. These facts in turn make it unlikely that a network adversary would 1. target miners in an attack as a means of controlling/obstructing the network 2. succeed in causing long lasting harm to the network in the event that they attempted such an attack. Ripple's set of known and trusted validators can very easily be stopped and controlled by any reasonably powerful set of state level adversaries, and are themselves in a position to extract rent from the network due to the potential for such a group of known parties to collude, and the coordination problem that users of the network would have in hard forking away from such a colluding set of validators.