4 ms·
> The author is cherry picking studies to try and prove his hypothesis, ignoring that the "studies" he cites show only a possible correlation Not really, he st
by naasking 9y ago
> The author is cherry picking studies to try and prove his hypothesis, ignoring that the "studies" he cites show only a possible correlation
Not really, he starts out explaining that most previous research on birth order effects was well and truly debunked. This doesn't disprove the existence of birth order effects, and he makes a decent case.
> First, he's taking the results of a voluntary survey of users of his own site
And he thoroughly discusses the self-selection bias.
> Another example: younger siblings often specifically don't want to go to the same school as their older siblings, so if an older sibling gets into Harvard, they are less likely to bother applying.
If first-borns are more likely to go to Harvard, that's a birth order effect too. If they're not more likely to go to Harvard, then Harvard should have an even mix of birth orders and so aren't subject to the bias you point out.