2 ms·
I disagree. Take the immutability aspect highlighted. Without environmental influences, how do you cause a change? Genes can technically change during life, but
by belorn 9y ago
I disagree. Take the immutability aspect highlighted. Without environmental influences, how do you cause a change? Genes can technically change during life, but I doubt thats what the study referees.
The idea that genes dictate outcomes in immutable ways is exactly what the authors of this study disagree with.
To make a direct example on the study of a particular gene and depression. If you take a person with this gene, they have (if i recall right) 6 times higher risk factor for depression compared to other people, but only if they also have had a child hood trauma. People with the gene and no such trauma has no higher risk for depression than people without the gene and no trauma. The gene has a environmental aspect to it.
Page 5:
For example, a heritability of nearly 100% implies that environmental differences that exist in the population do not have an effect on a particular phenotype assessed at a particular stage in development.
Title: Finding 2. No traits are 100% heritable. Although heritability estimates are significantly greater than 0%, they are also significantly less than 100%. As noted earlier, heritability estimates are substantial between 30% and 50%,
The study is very clear here. Environmental influences are estimated to be between 70% and 50%, and never as low as 0% for any single trait.
Further more on page 6:
Many others have noted that
no traits are 100% heritable (e.g., Plomin, 1989; Turkheimer, 2000).
My original claim was that alone the genetic factor tend to have no effect, ie, no genetic factor gives 100% heritability for a trait in behavioral science. This study support this claim. I am sorry to say that either you read the study wrong or you misinterpreted my comment.
- tomp 9y agoDefinitely misinterpreted your comment. My interpretation of "no effect" is 0%, not <100%. Looks like we're mostly in agreement.