3 ms·
A critical problem I see that needs solving is the Starbucks style open wifi login pages that fail to redirect when trying to visit HTTPS sites. A new secure a
by dmix 9y ago
A critical problem I see that needs solving is the Starbucks style open wifi login pages that fail to redirect when trying to visit HTTPS sites.
A new secure authentication system is needed for these set ups.
I’m blanking on the name of them but clearly they are widely deployed and likely causing lots of regular people to have trouble connecting to pages because they tried to connect to Facebook instead of an HTTP site.
- Kliment 9y agoCaptive portals? Browsers and some mobile devices have a workaround where on new wifi connections they try to connect to a particular url and if that gives unexpected content they know it's a captive portal and prompt you to log in. But ideally this would be in the network descriptor somehow.
- dawnerd 9y agoI wish gogo worked with this. I've ended up bookmarking http://captive.apple.com http://captive.apple.com just to trigger their login page.
- teekert 9y agoI have had this problem as well, and it became increasingly difficult to find non-https domains so I started using one of my own sub-domain for it (I needed it on the dutch railway system). But recently, Ubuntu added a captive portals catcher and gives a small browser window to login (I think it tries to contact an Ubuntu sub-domain first to test the connection, you can turn it off if you want). This is very handy!
- zootboy 9y agoWhy is this a problem? Just mash some keys and add a .com to the end. The portal doesn't check if the domain is real or not, it just intercepts all DNS requests until you've logged in.
- Kliment 9y agoand for the rare cases of those that don't, you can tunnel data over dns
- Freak_NL 9y agoHeh, I've been doing the same thing for wifi in Arriva and NS trains. I haven't gotten around to making my own website HTTPS yet, so I just use that.
- majewsky 9y agoYou can use http://neverssl.com http://neverssl.com for that purpose
- khc 9y agoI just use http://example.com http://example.com
- jraph 9y agoI use perdu.com to test my connection and for captive portals. The website is fast, light (to say the least), always up, the URL is short and there is no valid HTTPS version so no need to type http:// http://. It also makes people around smile (and ask what this website is while I'm testing stuff and not thinking about it). English translation: Lost on the Internet? Don't panic, we are going to help you * <----- you are here It is amazing how this joke has been there since 1998, without a change. In 2016, perdu.com was displayed 1-2 million times per day and his author was spending €65 per year for this (source: https://www.nouvelobs.com/rue89/rue89-internet/20160603.RUE3064/perdu-com-on-a-retrouve-le-plaisantin.html https://www.nouvelobs.com/rue89/rue89-internet/20160603.RUE3...).
- dmix 9y agoThat's a cute page, I personally use cbc.ca here in Canada because it's only 5 letters and always HTTP only.
- pfg 9y agoRFC 7710 solves this via DHCP. What's missing is support both on operating systems and captive portal devices.
- hannob 9y ago>A critical problem I see that needs solving is the >Starbucks style open wifi login pages that fail to redirect when trying to visit HTTPS sites. The "fix" is to have automatic mechanisms that query a known-http page and detect a redirect. Which is what browsers already do. If you want to build your own system or don't want the browser to do the magic use neverssl.com. > A new secure authentication system is needed for these set ups. What would that mean to have "secure authentication" here? What are the security expectations of a "click here to get internet" system? IMHO the best solution for captive portals would be to just not do them.