5 ms·
It looks like it must be using kelvin as its canonical units: 0C + 0C = 273.15 K + 273.15 K = 546.3 K = 273.15 C The weirdness is that conversions like that
by _delirium 16y ago
It looks like it must be using kelvin as its canonical units:
0C + 0C = 273.15 K + 273.15 K = 546.3 K = 273.15 C
The weirdness is that conversions like that don't work for units that have different zero points. Perhaps addition of temperatures isn't really well defined? If 273.15 K + 273.15 K does not equal 0 C + 0 C, despite 273.15 K = 0 C, it's not clear what addition "means" in this context.
One restricted form of addition that makes sense (which maybe is what's intended?) is to consider the 1st temperature an actual temperature, and the 2nd temperature a temperature difference in units of degrees-C (or degrees-K, or degrees-F). So e.g.:
"5 C warmer than 30 C"
= 30 C + 5 C
= 303.15 K + 5 K
= 308.15 K
= 35 C
But then addition isn't commutative. The problem is that "degrees C" is overloaded here, to mean both a position on a scale, and the size of a unit on that scale, with no conventional short way of distinguishing which one you mean (which is one reason Kelvin was invented, since things aren't ambiguous if you put absolute zero at 0 K).
- nixme 16y agoGoogle can actually differentiate between the two meanings: degrees Celsius and Celsius degrees. As you explained, the query posed by the title is meaningless, but 0 degrees Celsius + 0 Celsius degrees is handled correctly: http://www.google.com/search?&q=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0+celsius+degrees http://www.google.com/search?&q=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0+...
- _delirium 16y agoAh, that's pretty interesting. It makes sense when you read the two phrasings next to each other, but it does seem like a pretty subtle wording difference. I think in practice people tend to differentiate which one is meant by context more than by "degrees Celsius" versus "Celsius degrees" being used consistently. Should Google should convert the query somehow? It seems like adding two temperatures in degrees Celsius is something that never really makes sense (or subtracting, multiplying, or dividing them), so faithfully executing it like they currently do is rarely what's intended.
- ugh 16y agoThey should convert the query because that’s exactly what people want to know when they type in those kinds of queries.
- bruceboughton 16y ago>> when they type in those kinds of queries If I wanted to know 50 degrees Celsius + 35 Celsius degrees, I would probably omit the units and just ask for 50 + 35. I find it unlikely that many users actually run into this problem.
- ugh 16y agoIt’s no big deal, sure.
- izaac 16y agoAhh, yes. The "do what I mean" feature.
- nixme 16y agoYes, they should just convert. Or be annoyingly pedantic: Did you mean: 0 degrees Celsius + 0 *Celsius degrees* :)
- mathias 16y ago0 celsius degrees + 0 celsius degrees = 0 kelvin: http://www.google.com/search?q=0+celsius+degrees+%2B+0+celsius+degrees http://www.google.com/search?q=0+celsius+degrees+%2B+0+celsi...
- antileet 16y agoSeems it is easy enough to confuse even Wolfram Alpha http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=0+degrees+kelvin+%2B+0+degrees+celsius http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=0+degrees+kelvin+%2B+0+... Funnily enough the original query is handled well[1] by W|A: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0+degrees+celsius http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0... And the query that fails in Wolfram Alpha, works fine in Google's Calculator: http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=0+degrees+kelvin+%2B+0+degrees+celsius http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8... :) 1: By "well", we probably mean according to intuition
- nkassis 16y agoThat last one is odd. Should it not convert them first on the same base first? But then which on should it convert to? If you go for 0 celsius to 273.15 K then you'd get 0 K + 0 C = 273.15K if you do the other way you get -273.15 C. Whoa now I have a new tool to explain that AB is not always = BA to friend ;)
- Retric 16y agoNo, swapping them gives the same value. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0+degrees+kelvin+&cts=1282046066594&aq=f&aqi=h1&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=0+degrees+celsius+%... Google always convert temperatures to Kelvin for this stuff. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=0+degrees+celsius++*++1.2&cts=1282046202827&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=0+degrees+celsius++... The assumption is if your doing math with temperature you are using it in a physics context.
- serichsen 16y agoActually, Wolfram Alpha is doing a sensible thing in each case: it is not adding the temperatures, it is comparing them, resp. calculating the difference, when you give different scales. You can see that in the output, where it says "difference". The confusion is all on your side.
- 16y ago
- jurjenh 16y agoA quick check of Wikipedia states: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celsius http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celsius) Why technical articles use a mix of kelvin and Celsius scales In science (especially) and in engineering, the Celsius scale and the kelvin are often used simultaneously in the same article (e.g. "…its measured value was 0.01023 °C with an uncertainty of 70 µK…"). This practice is permissible because: the degree Celsius is a special name for the kelvin for use in expressing Celsius temperatures, and the magnitude of the degree Celsius is precisely equal to that of the kelvin So based on that, it is permissible to do 0C == 273.15K.
- woodall 16y agoYou just screwed me all up. 32 F + 32 F = 64 F 0 C + 0 C = 0 C HOWEVER it should equal about 17.78 degrees Celsius. Now we 17.78/2 = 8.89 C = 282.04 kelvin. That is suspiciously close the to 0 C = 273.15 K- however it is also not that close. My whole understanding of temperature has been flip upside down. Wait. This is why I am not an engineer. If we add a glass of liquid that is at 0C/32F/273K to another glass of liquid that is at 0C/32F/273K the temperature will still be 0C/32F/273K. A better way to measure this would be in energy/joules gained/lost- we would also need volume, properties, ect. In this case we are trying to lower 0C by adding 0C. Since the water is already at 0C then there is no energy needed. You about blew my mind; I've never thought of temperature as a number line. http://www.physicsforums.com/archive/index.php/t-185960.html http://www.physicsforums.com/archive/index.php/t-185960.html http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/64505.html http://mathforum.org/library/drmath/view/64505.html http://www.essex1.com/people/speer/heat.html http://www.essex1.com/people/speer/heat.html My next project will definitely have to be a temperature/volume/energy converter
- sesqu 16y ago10 °C = 50 °F (temperature) 10 °C = 18 °F (temperature difference) Celsius and Fahrenheit date to before temperature was understood to have a lower limit. Both measure only temperature difference from their respective zero points, with the conversion to energetic temperature demanding that one knows where the zero points are. The conversion is implicit in common use, so that 10 °C + 10 °C = 273.15 K + 10 °C + 10 °C = 273.15 K + 20 °C = 20 °C edit: changed substantially
- shdon 16y agoAnd thus 32 °F = 16 °F, which, with conventional mathematics, can only be satisfied if °F = 0. Express this in English as "Fahrenheit is nothing", which is something that every European already knows. That's why we use Celsius :P
- omaranto 16y agoYou're absolutely right that two different things are measured in degrees: temperatures and temperature differences. And they work as you said: you can add temperatures differences, you can add a temperature difference to a temperature, but you can't add two temperatures. (This is like pointers and ints in C.) Mathematically temperature differences form a group under addition and temperatures (idealized to have no minimum temperature) form a torsor for the group. A good introduction to torsors is John Baez's Torsors made easy: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/torsors.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/torsors.html
- shasta 16y agoWell, you can add temperatures. Temperature is defined to be average kinetic energy of particles, and addition of kinetic energies is well defined. The way Google does the addition is in this sense correct - there's a reason it's called absolute zero. The thing is that you usually don't want to add temperatures, for the same reason that you generally don't want to add other averages: they're usually not particularly interesting quantities. For this reason, you might encapsulate the definition of temperature and not expose the addition operation, but the dimensional analysis is fine the way Google does it.
- kd5bjo 16y agoAdding kinetic energies is well defined, but adding averages is not.
- aphyr 16y agoWhat the what? Averages over kinetic energies are summations. Adding them is well-defined and has a straightforward interpretation as the average energy per particle. Formally, temperature is defined as T = 1/(\partial(S)/\partial(E)) with fixed external parameters volume, particle count, etc. where S is the entropy of the system and E is its total energy. Playing fast and loose with words, as you pump energy into a system, if it becomes chaotic slowly, you're at high temperature. If it becomes chaotic quickly, you're at low temperature. Much of the difficulty involved with calculating temperatures comes from the fact that we chose the inverse of that partial to be "temperature"--which means that you cannot add temperatures for most systems together and negative absolute temperatures are "hotter" than positive ones, (yes, Cindy, you can experimentally obtain systems below absolute 0 :)). However, it is usually possible to calculate the thermal equilibrium of the system, which would be an excellent "average" temperature.
- cabalamat 16y ago> The problem is that "degrees C" is overloaded here, to mean both a position on a scale, and the size of a unit on that scale I understood that Celsius always referred to the position on the scale, and the unit was always Kelvin. At least, that's how I use the terms.
- Groxx 16y ago>But then addition isn't commutative. "30 C warmer than 5 C" = 5 C + 30 C = 278.15 K + 30 K = 308.15 K = 35 C Am I missing something?
- adammichaelc 16y agoThe second result on Google for the search is now Hacker News. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=Palemoon:en-US:unofficial&q=0+degrees+celsius+%2B+0+degrees+celsius&btnG=Search&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&... I was curious about how this could happen so quickly, so I looked up the PageRank for ycombinator.com, and it's a 7 out of 10. That's a good amount of Google juice, which explains how they can so quickly rank on a keyword (and it's a very obscure keyword, so not much competition up-top).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]