4 ms·
> it's not really a waste, it's proof of work Every kind of waste I can think of is a proof of some kind of work. That doesn't make it a good thing.
by mehrdadn 9y ago
> it's not really a waste, it's proof of work
Every kind of waste I can think of is a proof of some kind of work. That doesn't make it a good thing.
- bamboozled 9y agoThe value provide by these systems is trust, which literally requires proof of work to establish. Facebook news feeds don't require proof of work in the same sense.
- Nursie 9y agoThat's not a requirement for trust. It's a requirement for this particular kind of decentralised trust.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> The value provide by these systems is trust, which literally requires proof of work to establish. This is going to go on a tangent but I do not see why proof of work has anything to do with trust. Does your trust in me increase somehow if I give you a string whose hash ends in twenty zeros? i.e. if I subsequently told you I had found a number whose hash ended in thirty zeros but didn't give you the number, would you somehow trust me more than someone else who hadn't shown you proof of work for twenty zeros? Not really. If anything, proof of work is not producing trust, but eliminating it (and the need for it).
- bamboozled 9y agoIt's computationally expensive to trick the network by rehashing all blocks in the chain, which is essentially needing to re-do all the proof of work operations since the begging of the BTC ledger. This is how POW adds integrity, for bitcoin and how you can trust your not dealing with a tampered system. I'm not saying it's efficient, but it's worked well so far. Good explanation here: https://decentralize.today/how-does-proof-of-work-um-work-f44642b24215 https://decentralize.today/how-does-proof-of-work-um-work-f4...
- 0wing 9y agoProof of Work is better described as Proof of (resource) Waste (for late adopters). The only thing PoW attempts to do is increase the amount of capital wasted via wasting electricity and computational cycles as time progresses. Ironically if you actually look at the protocol, miners are rewarded less and less yet have to work harder and harder. The vast majority of the supply sits with less than ~100 of the early miners who put in the least amount of work for the most amount of coins.
- tromp 9y agoNo; most kinds of waste are not instantly verifiable, but proof of work is.
- mcv 9y agoWhat's verifiable is that you wasted a lot of work. Is anything useful actually being done with all those calculations that are being performed? It seems the only purpose is to prove that you performed this amount of useless work, because the system is built on rewarding new bitcoins to those who waste the most work this way. It's intentionally wasteful just because the system needs something that isn't easily gamed without massive investment of equipment and energy. Other cryptocurrencies manage to exist without being designed around wasting energy.