3 ms·
Intel did release a microcode update (which "couldn't" be released early due to "responsible disclosure"). Taking all their processors off the shelves would be
by wmf 9y ago
Intel did release a microcode update (which "couldn't" be released early due to "responsible disclosure").
Taking all their processors off the shelves would be suicide.
- cabaalis 9y agoCan someone explain the disclosure procedures that were actually followed? It seems like everybody freaked out at the same time. AWS had apparently already protected all but a "small percentage" of their VMs. If there was some kind of responsible disclosure taking place, allowing vendors time to upgrade, it seems like it wouldn't have had so much impact.
- mousa 9y agoI think the disclosure procedures were abandoned because people outside of the loop had figured it out from Linux kernel upgrades.
- eridius 9y agoAIUI disclosure wasn't supposed to happen until tomorrow. Google broke the embargo because, as you said, people were starting to figure it out.
- bonzini 9y agoBreaking the embargo at 5pm EST was also coordinated with everyone who had been disclosed early. It wasn't anarchy.
- aidenn0 9y agoAlso by AMD's e-mail that all-but-disclosed the mechanism of Meltdown.
- Waterluvian 9y agoHow does a microcode update work? My sparse understanding is that instructions are physically encoded in the chips. That you could take a microscope and look at the different instructions.
- TomV1971 9y agoThat was a very long time ago. Microcode can be loaded by the BIOS.
- Operyl 9y agoCan also be loaded at boot time by the kernel, etc.
- cjbprime 9y agoOr even after boot time, I think -- you shut down one CPU at a time to load it.
- xxs 9y agoMost of the microcode nowadays is loaded by the OS (not BIOS)
- chopin 9y agoToday I learned something. Doesn't that open a huge attack surface? This code would run super-privileged isn't it?
- 0x0 9y agoCPUs will only accept uploads of microcode if they can verify the digital signature, of which the private keys are only known to the CPU manufacturer (i.e. Intel or AMD). Probably it will also only allow upgrades, not downgrades, on a running system. So the only "attack" you can perform if you've gained root is to patch CPU security vulnerabilities by upgrading to a newer valid microcode, and then also only until the next reboot.