3 ms·
This shouldn't be surprising; this is an obvious result of rent control. If rent control isn't applied to all rental units (as is the case in SF), then the uni
by kelnos 9y ago
This shouldn't be surprising; this is an obvious result of rent control.
If rent control isn't applied to all rental units (as is the case in SF), then the units not under rent control end up being higher than average to make up for the units under rent control.
Even if rent control is applied to all rental units, then you see large spikes in rent that are speculative to several years in the future whenever a tenant moves out and the unit is re-listed.
The problem is that you can't just kill rent control and expect everything to be ok overnight, especially in a place like SF where the housing supply is constrained. Two things:
1) Demand outstrips supply even at the high prices commanded by non-rent-controlled units, so if you were to kill rent control here, the only thing that would happen would be that the units that were previously subject to rent control will get price hikes. I wouldn't expect rents to fall for the units that were never subject to rent control, because there are still people willing to pay those prices to live here, even if they'd prefer something lower.
2) Even if I'm not entirely correct, and there is enough supply that the overall market rate actually would be lower than the current market rate for non-controlled units, we'd still lose a lot of lower-income residents; I would be very surprised to find many (if any) landlords in the city who wouldn't raise rents at least modestly if their units stopped being subject to rent control. Some of the less exploitative ones might work with their existing tenants so as not to force them out of the city, but there are a lot of people in SF in rent-controlled housing that can't afford much more in the way of increases than rent control allows.
We need to 1) build like crazy, 2) kill rent control, 3) have some sort of phase-out period where we subsidize housing for lower- and middle-income people hit hardest by post-#2 rent increases. (And probably other things; I'm no economist.)